GoSaints 12 Phantom Draft Year 4

Remove this Banner Ad

Draft Order
RoundPickClubPlayer Taken
11West CoastHarley Reid
12North MelbourneZane Duursma
1, (bid)3Gold CoastJed Walter
14St KildaDaniel Curtin
15HawthornNick Watson
16Western BulldogsColby McKercher
1, (bid)7Gold CoastEthan Read
1, (bid)8Western BulldogsJordan Croft
19MelbourneRyley Sanders
110GWSConnor O'Sullivan
111GeelongNate Caddy
112EssendonJames Leake
113AdelaideDarcy Wilson
1, (bid)14HawthornWill McCabe
115MelbourneOllie Murphy
1, (bid)16Gold CoastJake Rogers
117SydneyZane Zakostelsky
118North MelbourneRiley Hardeman
119AdelaideCaleb Windsor
120North MelbourneLance Collard
121North MelbourneArcher Reid
122GWSHarry Di Mattia
123North MelbourneWill Green
124CollingwoodArchie Roberts
125AdelaideMitch Edwards
126North MelbourneWil Dawson
127CarltonKoltyn Tholstrup
228RichmondCharlie Edwards
229West CoastAngus Hastie
230GeelongLuamon Lual
231West CoastAshton Moir
2, (bid)32Gold CoastWill Graham
233CarltonCooper Simpson
234BrisbanePhoenix Gothard
235EssendonTaylor Goad
236CollingwoodJoel Freijah
237FremantleJack Delean
238EssendonGeorge Stevens
239SydneyCaiden Clearly
240GWSClay Hill
241BrisbaneRiley Weatherill
242MelbourneLogan Morris
343FremantleLuke Lloyd
344BrisbaneCharlie McCormack
345BrisbaneRy Cantwell
346SydneyBrodie Ryan
347Western BulldogsHarvey Johnston
348North MelbourneShaun Mannagh
349Gold CoastPASS
350FremantleAiden O'Driscoll
351EssendonMichael Rudd
352HawthornEvan Smith
353HawthornTew Jiath
454HawthornCalsher Dear
455FremantleSam Clohesy
456RichmondKoen Sanchez
457SydneyPASS
458BrisbanePASS
459RichmondKade de la Rue
460Western BulldogsLachie Charleson
461CarltonWill Patton
462RichmondArie Schoenmaker
463Western BulldogsVigo Vistentini
464Western BulldogsTarkyn O'Leary
465Port AdelaideKane McAuliffe
466West CoastJoe Fonti
467Western BulldogsPASS
468HawthornPASS
469GeelongJack Callinan
470GWSGeordie Payne
471CarltonPASS
472GWSPASS
473St KildaWill Brown
574West CoastPASS
575North MelbournePASS
576FremantlePASS
577RichmondPASS
578GeelongPASS
579EssendonPASS
580AdelaidePASS
581St KildaJosh Docking
582MelbournePASS
583St KildaWill Rowlands
684Port AdelaideNathan Philactides
785Port AdelaideWill Lorenz
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

winalotroos said:
Wow that is wishful thinking, but I get it I am very late
Click to expand...
Yeah to be honest I didn't expect it to get up. blueiris was the North list manager this year, I offered what I had, he took it, might be worth asking him. However, I will say had the shoe been on the other foot, I would've taken Duursma and Curtin
 
In reality, GWS has said they will just take the 3 picks in the ND; I would expect they'll just keep this late pick open in case there's a need to match a very late bid on Harvey Thomas (our academy lad).

However, for this Phantom Draft, I'm going to take a player. Would we really take one of the two I've mulled over in the ND? No, I don't think so. We might look to make a rookie selection.

The two players I've considered are Billy Wilson and Geordie Payne. Neither really fills a need - Wilson is more outside, although the hope is he could develop an inside game; Payne is a medium defender and we're relatively well stocked for them. The only rationale for me is that Adam Kennedy is a possibility to retire at the end of this season, and Geordie Payne strikes me as being built in a similar mould. Able to intercept and rebound, but the hope would be that he could develop into a lock-down defender, which is a role we're less well stocked in.

So, with pick #70, GWS select: Geordie Payne (TAS)

STRENGTHS:

  • Competitiveness
  • Intercept marking
  • Run-and-carry
  • Speed

IMPROVEMENTS:

  • Decision making
  • Disposal consistency

Geordie Payne was perhaps unlucky to have missed out on Allies selection having returned some strong performances prior to the National Championships, though he made every post a winner once more highly touted teammates stepped up to representative level. Recruiters took notice as the Tasmanian managed to maintain such output and when the Devils returned to full strength, with his gutsy intercept marking making an impression. Payne is also switched on in the attacking phase, often taking the game on with speed.

He's the type of player who sets off as soon as he wins the ball, and while he still needs to improve on slowing the game down when the time calls for it, provides plenty of offensive flair with this rebounding prowess. This ‘run at all cost’ mentality has occasionally gotten him into trouble, with his ball use suffering as a result, where he can be prone to putting teammates under pressure with rushed disposals. Payne took out Tasmania's best and fairest this year among a relatively stacked field and is said to have attracted interest from the likes of Adelaide, but is otherwise a chance late in the National Draft.

Coona Blues you're up next with Carlton.

GWS will PASS for pick #72 and any remaining picks.
 
Offical deal: Saints trade R3 2024 Melbourne and R3 2024 Carlton to Collingwood for picks 73, 84 and R3 2024 Hawthorn


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

IMG_1346.JPG
 
There were others considered, but my plan here is to bring in some midfielders that can complement Pou and Owens, with the understanding that if this was a real draft some of them won't make it, or would be taken as rookies but I've got the list spots spare, I think. There is A grade potential here.

Pick 73: St Kilda select Will Brown, (Sandringham Dragons) (Vic Metro)

At this stage of the draft, I tend to focus on mentality and this kid has a great head on his shoulders. He's a local boy as well, which is added points. A natural leader and the Dragons Premiership captain, Brown's ability to move through traffic was something that attracted me to his playing style, and he moves the ball well with his hand, but at times his ball use by foot can be lacking. He is also a strong aerial threat and has some natural forward craft. As a said from the top, A grade potential.
 
bone2468 its your pick

Also Haggas I noticed you were after another pick, yet Port are not listed, considering Port only took one selection to the draft, I've given you an additional two after the final selection of the draft, does that work or would rather only the one? I am not giving you any more then two, if you want more players, just list them at the final pick as 'rookie selections'
 
Gosaints12 said:
bone2468 its your pick

Also Haggas I noticed you were after another pick, yet Port are not listed, considering Port only took one selection to the draft, I've given you an additional two after the final selection of the draft, does that work or would rather only the one? I am not giving you any more then two, if you want more players, just list them at the final pick as 'rookie selections'
Click to expand...
Fremantle pass
 
Anyone that hasn't passed and has less then three selections that wants to pick again, let me know and I'll add you in.

That applies to Pie 4 Life as he has only taken two selections, if he wants to pick again, that pick would go at the start of R8 after Port's third selection

I'll work out the rules for next year around this, but I was thinking at the start of the draft until the end of the first round, those that don't have three selections can requests selections at the end of the draft, these would be added in ladder order as the 6th and, (if needed) 7th round.

After the end of the 4th round until the last pick is taken, those that didn't end up using three selections may apply to have selections added to the end of the draft, as round 8 and (if needed) Round 9 selections.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

bone2468 its your pick
Gosaints12 said:
Also Haggas I noticed you were after another pick, yet Port are not listed, considering Port only took one selection to the draft, I've given you an additional two after the final selection of the draft, does that work or would rather only the one? I am not giving you any more then two, if you want more players, just list them at the final pick as 'rookie selections'
Click to expand...
Yeah I think we might take 2 but probably 1. But I’m the manager now haha.

Pick 85: Nathan Philactides
Pick 86: Will Lorenz
 
Haggas said:
Anyone keen to do a 2024 phantom draft 2 rounds?
Click to expand...

I was gonna ask because we've done some future trading, do people want to do a mini draft in March/April, (before the champs) for 2024 based on this years ladder with the trades we put through?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

PMBangers
BigFooty Official 2023 Bigfooty Phantom Draft
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
241
Views
30K
briztoon
briztoon
eth-dog
Phantom Draft eth-dog's 2023 Phantom Draft
2 3
Replies
52
Views
9K
eth-dog
eth-dog
PMBangers
BigFooty Official Bigfooty Phantom Draft - Trial Run
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
160
Views
14K
Shai
Shai
adammania9
Phantom Draft Adzy's 2023 Phantom (Full Phantom posted 16/11/23)
2 3
Replies
61
Views
15K
Pure_Ownage
Pure_Ownage
Holden Hillbilly
Draft Profile SA Draft prospects 2024
Replies
0
Views
94
Holden Hillbilly
Holden Hillbilly
Smythe
Draft Watcher SMYTHE's 2024 Draft Thread
2
Replies
40
Views
3K
briztoon
briztoon
getgaff
Phantom Draft Getgaff 2022 Phantom Draft
2
Replies
43
Views
11K
Callipygian
Callipygian

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top