I never watch this show and now I know why. I had to find the bit you've highlighted as I assumed you must have made a mistake, but no, you were 100% correct.Tuned out when they graded Swallow as a 'B' midfielder and McGlynn an 'A'.
They rate Gibson an A grade mid which is great, but I reckon none of them would have heard of him before last week. I'm certain his A grading is based on that 1 game.