List Mgmt. Our List 2014 - Trade, De-list and Draft - (keep it all in here)

[Stig O'Hara]

Can players retire early in circumstances like injury? Or do they have to see out their contract?

Blake Caracella had to give it away when he copped a bad neck injury at the MCG.

Collingwood honoured his contract.

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

You will love him if he is a Norm Smith medalist at Carlton next year.

No, I won't.

 

[Cringle]

I'd rather just set our sights on the talented goodness that GWS and GC won't be able to retain. Get into their ears about not being an automatic selection and that. Tomlinson, Jacksch, Adams, Bruce, etc.

 

[LanceRomance]

No, I won't.

Alan Didak... 2014 Carlton Premiership Player. John Nicholls Medal. Norm Smith Medalist.

Has a ring to it.

You believe he could be a norm smith medalist for carlton next year?

My want to annoy the Collingwood fans is so strong I am going to will this to happen.

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

Alan Didak... 2014 Carlton Premiership Player. John Nicholls Medal. Norm Smith Medalist.

Has a ring to it.

Not to me. I'd rather a real Carlton player have those accolades.

 

[LanceRomance]

Not to me. I'd rather a real Carlton player have those accolades.

He can't help where he was drafted but if he chooses us he really would be Carlton.

 

[ESKIE]

Its scraping the ultimate biscuit barrel....

Go for a young gun

 

[Garth Vader]

People saying that they don't want Dustin Martin really amuse me.

Averages more disposals than any player at Carlton and has had more disposals than any player at Carlton. Is third on Richmond's goal kicking. Is only 22 and is a big strong powerful type capable of contesting and running.

We are desperately short on midfielders and we don't have any players who can go forward and play midfield and do both well.

If we are scared of players with off field issues and players who might be hard to manage then so be it but as a player he is everything we need and so is Dale Thomas.

I hope we aren't afraid of failure and aren't afraid of picking up a player who might stuff up. I hope we aren't afraid to make big calls at the trade table. To be afraid of these things is to be afraid of success.

Utlimately, the club will make a decision on this and hopefully it will be done with thermonuclear-due-dilligence.

Utlimately, I don't know Martin personally other than what has been reported but those things do worry me in terms of what messages they can send to young, impressionable people. Or should I just not give a sh_t?

 

[Aphrodite]

Alan Didak... 2014 Carlton Premiership Player. John Nicholls Medal. Norm Smith Medalist.

Has a ring to it.





My want to annoy the Collingwood fans is so strong I am going to will this to happen.

Good lord I feel sick Lance.

No just no it is so wrong!!!

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

He can't help where he was drafted but if he chooses us he really would be Carlton.

Didak will never be Carlton in my eyes!

 

[Aphrodite]

Not to me. I'd rather a real Carlton player have those accolades.

Agree.

Remember McKernan winning our B&F.

 

[Garth Vader]

Didak will never be Carlton in my eyes!

And....he has a missing middle-tooth, clearly not a good fit for us.

 

[LanceRomance]

Agree.

Remember McKernan winning our B&F.

Wonder what would happen if Carlton Blue Didak won the Norm Smith in a Grand final against Collingwood and Carlton Blue Dustin Martin won the Brownlow.

There would be endless lols.

 

[Aphrodite]

Wonder what would happen if Carlton Blue Didak won the Norm Smith in a Grand final against Collingwood and Carlton Blue Dustin Martin won the Brownlow.

There would be endless lols.

So much WRONG with this post!!

 

[Koutafidamidis]

Nope we don't need another average midfielder. We need guns. Like daisy. And dusty. Go the Double D's...

**** dem double d's boy!!!

haha, seriously...we need them both, and somehow that boyd kid seriously...Carlton of old when we didnt give a **** and we ran shit

being all fair and conservative got us ****ed in the ass!!! look what essendon did, they fought back and got no punishment at all, thats what we should have done but collins sold us down the river ****ed us for 10 years

 

[checkpoints]

I'd love to rig the draft to get Boyd and Lennon. Still feel Collingwood somehow rigged last years draft. Seriously how did theyget Grundy. Pretty sure most had him locked in the top3 based on talent...

 

[Juddrockz]

Contracted until the end of 2015

Wow,didnt realise that.Thanks for updating me.

 

[Neese]

Didak will never be Carlton in my eyes!

Yep, took me years to accept a Cloke

 

[BM123]

Setanta certainly didn't accept Cloke.

 

[Stamos]

Can't help but having a feeling Carrazzo may retire at years end as well,turns 30 in December.

Just signed a 2 year deal, so I figure that's unlikely

 

[Koutafidamidis]

Don't think so. Martin once shared lodgings with Cotchin and March for off field reasons.

Can you name the last player who we sent to live with Kernahan or Swann to keep him under control?

Wake up and consider why Caro wrote that Richmond aren't willing to overpay to keep Martin.

You can't compare Martin to Judd or Murphy.

Martin, Dayle Garlett and Thorp will get us a flag.

mate i respect you as a poster, but seriously man

who cares if he needs a minder? i really couldnt care less
I'm not marrying him...I want my footy club to win and I couldnt give a toss if Hitler played for us if he was a gun
and im jewish so lol!!!

 

[BM123]

mate i respect you as a poster, but seriously man

who cares if he needs a minder? i really couldnt care less
I'm not marrying him...I want my footy club to win and I couldnt give a toss if Hitler played for us if he was a gun
and im jewish so lol!!!

We have crossed the threshold here people

 

[Koutafidamidis]

We have crossed the threshold here people

godwins law!

seriously though!!! we need to start being arrogant pricks and winning everything again

I grow weary of this mediocrity

 

[Kensa Carter]

We have crossed the threshold here people

No to Hitler and his haircut.

 

[GoBlues!]

No to Hitler and his haircut.

...and his shit moustache.