List Mgmt. The OFFICIAL 2013 Trade/Free Agency Targets Thread

[Chog]

In all honesty Delaney for 37 is massive unders.

 

[Jay-Z]

I know it's been said 1000 times, but surely if the Saints let Dal go as a FA we would give them Keys for their last pick. I just don't get the issue. There must be other things at play here

2 weeks ago most definitely. But after all this f***ing around I hope we sign NDS as a FA and then have a bidding war between Brisbane and St Kilda for keys


May or may not have been sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

 

[dus]

Our first free agent doesn't seem to be all that "free". Clauses in contracts like this should be banned.

 

[tcman]

In all honesty Delaney for 37 is massive unders.

How is 37 for a guy who played 4 senior games unders? We always over rate our own players when they are going elsewhere

 

[scooby1279]

I don't have any sources but to use pure logic if st Kilda have indeed agreed to let him go via FA, after nearly 3 weeks of extracting urine, surely we wouldn't object to sending Delaney there for steak knives?

Totally agree with you.

 

[GarnerSmash]

How is 37 for a guy who played 4 senior games unders? We always over rate our own players when they are going elsewhere

On its own his value is determined by what the opposition is willing to pay. If Brisbane are willing to pay more for him, what is he worth then?

But in this situation we need to remove emotion. If the saints said two weeks ago that they will let Dal Santo go FA if we deal a fourth for Delaney we would probably have jumped at it. Given that the saints are still non committal about releasing him then why should we automatically guarantee then Delaney on their grounds?

 

[Benno_900]

Robbo on SEN only minutes ago:

"I would be extremely surprised if Nick Rewoldt remained at St. Kilda next year."

...and he thinks North is where Rewoldt is headed.

He was referring to Dal Santo.

 

[floss_7]

How is 37 for a guy who played 4 senior games unders? We always over rate our own players when they are going elsewhere

correct, tell me again what did we pay?

And yet most on here don't give a hoot about the other players that are on the verge of being traded or delisted, (most of whom we have paid a lot more for).

Keys has shown he can do it, albeit in capacity not overwhelming.

 

[Farthers]

Definitely going to make 8000 posts before a decision is made.

 

[Donkey Chop]

2 weeks ago most definitely. But after all this f**king around I hope we sign NDS as a FA and then have a bidding war between Brisbane and St Kilda for keys


May or may not have been sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

We have to give up something. Being stubborn will get us SFA.

 

[tcman]

On its own his value is determined by what the opposition is willing to pay. If Brisbane are willing to pay more for him, what is he worth then?

But in this situation we need to remove emotion. If the saints said two weeks ago that they will let Dal Santo go FA if we deal a fourth for Delaney we would probably have jumped at it. Given that the saints are still non committal about releasing him then why should we automatically guarantee then Delaney on their grounds?

I agree remove the emotion. Delaney has played 26 games in 3 years. What would we pay to get him if he was at another club. I suggest we would not be lining up o pay more than pick 37

 

[GarnerSmash]

I agree remove the emotion. Delaney has played 26 games in 3 years. What would we pay to get him if he was at another club. I suggest we would not be lining up o pay more than pick 37

I don't think we would either. But then we aren't in need of a KPD. When this is all said and done I expect he will be a Saint but I would be curious to know what Brisbane and the Blues were willing to part with considering they are supposedly interested.

 

[numchuks]

How is 37 for a guy who played 4 senior games unders? We always over rate our own players when they are going elsewhere

Joined 4 days ago in the middle of trade week (month) and makes his first post in the trade thread, calling out North supporters for overrating their own players. The day before free agency deadline.


Seems legit.

 

[shagger_grant]

Joined 4 days ago in the middle of trade week (month) and makes his first post in the trade thread, calling out North supporters for overrating their own players. The day before free agency deadline.


Seems legit.

Well we do,but so do all the other supporters,at the end of the day it's a fan forum,that's what we do,but good point regarding the poster

 

[tazaa]

I wonder which mod will enjoy the sensation of locking this thread friday week.

 

[shinboner magic]

This better be signed off first thing in the morning.

Couldn't stand another near miss after the season that we have had.

 

[Joey7]

This better be signed off first thing in the morning.

Couldn't stand another near miss after the season that we have had.

People who still think dal is staying are delusional where gonna get him it's just how that remains in the air

 

[buttsauce]

We gave macintosh last year for pick37 didn't we? A guy who was in the all Australian squad. To say that delany has the same value this year is laughable. People you can't get a game in your first side shouldn't have much value at all.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

 

[shinboner magic]

People who still think dal is staying are delusional where gonna get him it's just how that remains in the air

Well it better come down before 1.30 tomorrow to get the deal done.

 

[utility]

We gave macintosh last year for pick37 didn't we? A guy who was in the all Australian squad. To say that delany has the same value this year is laughable. People you can't get a game in your first side shouldn't have much value at all.

Hampson for pick 28. Delaney is worth 37 on that basis.

Hamish was on the cheaper side because of his injury history and $$$.

 

[Spitta09]

People who still think dal is staying are delusional where gonna get him it's just how that remains in the air

Life ban if untrue

 

[Chog]

How is 37 for a guy who played 4 senior games unders? We always over rate our own players when they are going elsewhere

Yeah look, I was in a half-asleep delirium when I posted this and actually ment overs for the saints..

Delaney is nothing more than depth for us, and despite improvement, most posters here would agree that he is only a temporary backup and would not be in our best 22.

I think pick 55 is very fair. North appear to be asking more because he is an in-demand player but tbh I think we should just take NDS, give you guys Delaney for 55, and accept the deal as a win-win.

 

[Joey7]

Life ban if untrue

It was actually supposed to get done today - saints are just being difficult.

 

[Chog]

Hampson for pick 28. Delaney is worth 37 on that basis.

Hamish was on the cheaper side because of his injury history and $$$.

Yes but Richmond are idiots.

 

[Event Horizon]

Let me remind everyone - we have zero credible info to suggest the trade is behind held back by us over Delaney.