Rumour The Thread formerly known as the rumour file, now with zero rumours

[Weiterbot23]

Why the **** would menzel want to leave royal parade to live in Geelong? Just so he can watch his brother recover from knee recos?

I love menz, but if he leaves...my god I will turn!

 

[V23]

Geelong better not have said to Daniel "we'll give you another year if your brother agrees to come to the Cats". If Daniel has another serious knee injury (hopefully he doesn't) then Troy would be back to playing on his own again. Nothing short of Boyd and Mitchell will soften the blow if Menzel leaves.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Tom Mitchell deal is a done deal.
Menzel wants to play with his brother geelong offering up 3 players plus a pick carlton trying to hold on to him all of the above information is coming from an afl umpire.

The Menzel thing just doesn't make any sense.
His brother is a 95% chance to never play footy again.

 

[Silvagnis]

Tom Mitchell deal is a done deal.
Menzel wants to play with his brother geelong offering up 3 players plus a pick carlton trying to hold on to him all of the above information is coming from an afl umpire.

Jordan Murdoch better be part of the deal.

 

[AndyLucimitis]

Tom Mitchell deal is a done deal.
Menzel wants to play with his brother geelong offering up 3 players plus a pick carlton trying to hold on to him all of the above information is coming from an afl umpire.

Just doesn't sound like a deal Geelong would do ?. Are you saying a total of three players or they are offering up a choice on one of the three players plus a pick.


For Menzel you'd accept nothing less than their first round pick (which will be mid-teens) then at least one starting 22 player.

 

[JamisonRun40]

Has someone told Menz that his brother might not play another afl game. Well if Menz wants to go let him. Can we have Motlop then?

 

[AndrewVadermk2]

Just doesn't sound like a deal Geelong would do ?. Are you saying a total of three players or they are offering up a choice on one of the three players plus a pick.


For Menzel you'd accept nothing less than their first round pick (which will be mid-teens) then at least one starting 22 player.

Has someone told Menz that his brother might not play another afl game. Well if Menz wants to go let him. Can we have Motlop then?

motlop n tommohawk

 

[slashin_velvet]

Has someone told Menz that his brother might not play another afl game. Well if Menz wants to go let him. Can we have Motlop then?

Yep - if he wants out, then let him go....no point keeping someone who doesnt want to be there.

Find out what Sydney want for Mitchell, and get a deal done.

 

[Bosun]

Tom Mitchell deal is a done deal.
Menzel wants to play with his brother geelong offering up 3 players plus a pick carlton trying to hold on to him all of the above information is coming from an afl umpire.

No problem. Hawkins, Taylor, Motlop and their 1st rounder will do just fine.

 

[Sector 7G]

Jordan Murdoch better be part of the deal.

Guthrie and Pick 15. Get it done

 

[Just Kreuzing]

If Geelong want Menz then we need to get a like for like in return.

Half forwards that can go through the midfield like Duncan or Motlop are good starting points.

Add in a Stokes, Horlin-Smith, Christensen or Kersten and we may be getting somewhere.

Add in their first rounder just to seal and sweeten the deal....

 

[Jamie007]

If Menz wants out and Geelong don't offer up something decent, then I'd let him walk and have to play for gws or stkilda. We need to set a standard that we won't be walked over by clubs.

 

[Jamie007]

But god I hope he wants to stay.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Pray ET1 doesn't read the rumour thread today.
The fan will be covered i'm telling you!!!

 

[Jamie007]

Well

Pray etsal1 doesn't read the rumour thread today.
The fan will be covered i'm telling you!!!

I guess when you tag her in a post about it you can't really pray that she won't see it can you.

 

[Barhead]

Was told wants to play with his brother and loves the surf

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Well

I guess when you tag her in a post about it you can't really pray that she won't see it can you.

Good call. I better edit it

 

[Jeremias]

Guthrie and Pick 15. Get it done

They come to us with that offer and I'd tell them to go and get ****ed.

 

[Aphrodite]

Tom Mitchell deal is a done deal.
Menzel wants to play with his brother geelong offering up 3 players plus a pick carlton trying to hold on to him all of the above information is coming from an afl umpire.

I call rubbish and I doubt you are even a Carlton supporter!

 

[inyourcool]

Menz loves Carlton, why the **** would he be leaving?!!?

#getagrip

 

[Weiterbot23]

They come to us with that offer and I'd tell them to go and get ******.

Is Guthrie no29? He's pretty handy imo. Rather keep menz but this wouldn't be a bad deal.

 

[Jeremias]

Is Guthrie no29? He's pretty handy imo. Rather keep menz but this wouldn't be a bad deal.

Handy footballer, sure. He's no Menzel who is a special talent.

 

[Weiterbot23]

Handy footballer, sure. He's no Menzel who is a special talent.

Yeah but if they threw in 15 that would be ok.

We could try and use 15 in a straight swap for Tom Mitchell, which would be unders.

Obviously keeping Menz would be better but Mitchell and Guthrie would soften the blow and we wouldn't have to hold our breath every time Menz falls on his knee.

 

[passmark]

Was told wants to play with his brother and loves the surf

loves the surf.

That's a goodun.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

loves the surf.

That's a goodun.

Yeah, not sure what brand of washing powder has to do with where you play footy, surely our property stewards wash all the jumpers....