Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[DapperDon]

Yarran is contracted .
Carlisle is not .
Carlton have first pick in the PSD .
If Carlisle nominates Carlton , best Dodoro accepts the offer or he will be unbuckling his belt and efc will be hurt badly ...

Here comes the Carlton brains trust!

 

[dee64]

Why hasn't Carlisle nominated his preferred club?


Oh yeah, Hawks are still playing!

Actually, has Bennell and Aish nominated a club yet?

I wouldn't be surprised if both beaten prelim finalists are into Carlisle. I know for a fact that one of them has met with him a 2 occasions.

 

[Steven Tyler]

I wouldn't be surprised if both beaten prelim finalists are into Carlisle. I know for a fact that one of them has met with him a 2 occasions.

24 y/o KPD
I'd say lots of clubs are interested

 

[Moist Biscuit]

I wouldn't be surprised if both beaten prelim finalists are into Carlisle. I know for a fact that one of them has met with him a 2 occasions.

I don't think Carlisle will leave Melbourne. Can probably count us out in that case.

 

[Red Bull]

Here comes the Carlton brains trust!

efc are in the weakest of positions here .
It's not rocket science matey .
Whoever Carlisle nominates ... grit your teeth !!

 

[Teeko]

Why are people using the Ryder trade as evidence of Essendon being difficult to deal with? Port were being greedy and were trying to get Gorringe as well, right up until the deadline. Remember when Gorringe had a big cry to the media when it didn't eventuate?

 

[DapperDon]

I wouldn't be surprised if both beaten prelim finalists are into Carlisle. I know for a fact that one of them has met with him a 2 occasions.

Hawks went hard last year. No reason why they wouldn't go again.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Hawks went hard last year. No reason why they wouldn't go again.

All about who he chooses. Club going after him means little

 

[SurreyBlue]

Can I just say again ... I hope he goes anywhere but Carlton. Do not want. Very overrated.

 

[BRWB]

Can I just say again ... I hope he goes anywhere but Carlton. Do not want. Very overrated.

Yep not keen on him either mainly due to his shit attitude. But if Carlton fall over it seems we are next cab off the rank.

 

[aussierulesrules]

This thread just continues to deliver. Special mention goes to all the Essendon folk who continue to blow a gasket over the "Essendon are hard to deal with" suggestions.

 

[DapperDon]

All about who he chooses. Club going after him means little

Thanks. I wasn't aware of this.

Thankfully you informed me and saved any embarrassment.

 

[DapperDon]

Before Essendon and Hird* tried to ruin his career, he showed great promise as a key defender - will be a better player than Hurley.

Could be. Better mark than Hurls, but does lack the vigor and hustle that Hurley gives.

Will be a gun wherever he ends up at though

 

[HARKER]

Why are people using the Ryder trade as evidence of Essendon being difficult to deal with? Port were being greedy and were trying to get Gorringe as well, right up until the deadline. Remember when Gorringe had a big cry to the media when it didn't eventuate?

It's a reputation gained by Essendon via Dodoro.

It's almost become a truism of sorts. Even the media play up on it quite a bit.

 

[Big Fresh]

Before Essendon and Hird* tried to ruin his career, he showed great promise as a key defender - will be a better player than Hurley.

He's a better forward than Hurley but nowhere near as good a defender.

 

[Bic]

Could be. Better mark than Hurls, but does lack the vigor and hustle that Hurley gives.

Will be a gun wherever he ends up at though

I thought Hurley was older than 25. But it is hard to argue with your statement.

 

[DapperDon]

It's a reputation gained by Essendon via Dodoro.

It's almost become a truism of sorts. Even the media play up on it quite a bit.

Actually, it was gained by Sheeds in the early 00's.

 

[Bic]

He's a better forward than Hurley but nowhere near as good a defender.

He potentially could be - his 2013 form showed the signs.

At this stage Hurley is better, and I was surprised he is only year older than Jake.

 

[carnthedons]

I thought Hurley was older than 25. But it is hard to argue with your statement.

Hurley's 1 draft prior to Carlisle.

Has shown to be a better player so far mainly through competitiveness, effort and intensity. If you put Hurley's heart in Jake's body you'd have the best KPP in the comp by a long way.

 

[HARKER]

Actually, it was gained by Sheeds in the early 00's.

Was it? I don't know but you can't mention Essendon without someone saying.........."Oh, they're so hard to deal with".......Wait until Trade Radio fires up

 

[Big Fresh]

He potentially could be - his 2013 form showed the signs.

At this stage Hurley is better, and I was surprised he is only year older than Jake.

Carlisle doesn't quite have the speed and agility to be the ultimate defender. His kicking is also a fair way behind Hurley's, not that it's terrible. He does have one of the best pair of hands in the league though. Even in the first half of 2013 he didn't lock down opponents amazingly well (regularly conceded 3+ goals) but his marking is awesome and he can control a game.

 

[BRWB]

Was it? I don't know but you can't mention Essendon without someone saying.........."Oh, they're so hard to deal with".......Wait until Trade Radio fires up

The Scott West trade was a big contributor. Ess wooed West and allegedly had him considering his options.

And guess what??

It was 2004 and Dodoro and Sheedy allegedly lodged paperwork asking for West. Their offer? A 2nd rd pick and Darren Welsh (who they delisted that yr).

And from there Dodoro's power to frustrate, insult and make club's burst out laughing grew....

 

[marky53]

The Scott West trade was a big contributor. Ess wooed West and allegedly had him considering his options.

And guess what??

It was 2004 and Dodoro and Sheedy allegedly lodged paperwork asking for West. Their offer? A 2nd rd pick and Darren Welsh (who they delisted that yr).

And from there Dodoro's power to frustrate, insult and make club's burst out laughing grew....

Lol. Must still be 2004 this year then

 

[BRWB]

Lol. Must still be 2004 this year then

Just some history fella since the question was asked. But hey multiple egs have been given that are more recent...but no doubt you will believe what you choose to.

 

[carnthedons]

Just some history fella since the question was asked. But hey multiple egs have been given that are more recent...but no doubt you will believe what you choose to.