Traded Chris Yarran [to Richmond for Pick 19]

[Tiger_Of_Old]

FA compensation next year would be better than pick 31+ anyway

Really?How much compo would one expect considering the said player playing in the reserves at best would get?

 

[bmaurizio]

He can nominate all he wants, but it's not his prerogative his preference is just a guideline.
No contractual significance , the basics remain the same as always.
We demand adequate compensation equivalent to a first rounder and quality or potential otherwise we keep him , simple as that.
A presto

 

[Chism]

No matter how this trade goes down or even IF it does there is going to be serious egg on faces either way!!

lol

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

He can nominate all he wants, but it's not his prerogative his preference is just a guideline.
No contractual significance , the basics remain the same as always.
We demand adequate compensation equivalent to a first rounder and quality or potential otherwise we keep him , simple as that.
A presto

Geez expensive reserves player.

 

[captain cotch 9]

The only player i know of that has publicly requested a trade and nominated a club and has still stayed is Ryan O'Keefe
I think something like pick 12 for Yarran and pick 20 will happen.

 

[TigerTime88]

Surely even Carlton supporters agree pick 12 is overs. I certainly think pick 30 is unders.

Pick 30 + 12 for Yarran and 19.

Lennon still yet to resign.

Trades are going to be held up everywhere because of Dangerfield deal. Prepare yourselves for a slow first 2 weeks.

 

[Bay Pie]

Geez expensive reserves player.

Yep, but is it worth it when you know you'll get a better pick, in a better draft the following year, when he leaves as a RFA?

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

Carlton want a first round pick......not going to happen
Richmond want to use their second round pick......not going to happen

These are ambit claims

A fair and reasonable solution will be found

 

[Bic]

Where is Lennon at with a deal with Richmond?

Just coincidence and people drawing conclusions around Lennon possibly being involved with Yarran? Seems like it.

Pick 30 won't get it done, so somewhere, someone is going to have to budge.

 

[Bic]

Carlton want a first round pick......not going to happen
Richmond want to use their second round pick......not going to happen

These are ambit claims

A fair and reasonable solution will be found

This sums up this trade perfectly! Ha

 

[Tiggytigers]

We'll geez no wonder Carlton finished bloody last, overrating there list. Delusional...

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Surely even Carlton supporters agree pick 12 is overs. I certainly think pick 30 is unders.

Pick 30 + 12 for Yarran and 19.

Lennon still yet to resign.

Trades are going to be held up everywhere because of Dangerfield deal. Prepare yourselves for a slow first 2 weeks.

I think your proposed deal is the one that reasonable Carlton supporters were looking at. Your pick is 31 and ours is 20 at this stage with Gold Coast activating their compo pick at 19.

I see #12 and #31 for Yarran and #20 putting Yarran's value at roughly #16-17. This acknowledges the Blues contract leverage sufficiently. I also think, as Wells indicated re Henderson, that the Tigers will be looking at Yarran's best form, not his worst.

 

[Tiggytigers]

Keep him, fine by us, we get him as a free agent next year

 

[bmaurizio]

Lennon for Yarran will probably be an equatable solution.
Not such a great deal for CFC but better than than a 2nd rounder in a weak draft.
Obviously Ben not signing yet is an obvious indicator.

 

[juss]

I think your proposed deal is the one that reasonable Carlton supporters were looking at. Your pick is 31 and ours is 20 at this stage with Gold Coast activating their compo pick at 19.

I see #12 and #31 for Yarran and #20 putting Yarran's value at roughly #16-17. This acknowledges the Blues contract leverage sufficiently. I also think, as Wells indicated re Henderson, that the Tigers will be looking at Yarran's best form, not his worst.

I think the deal will be pick 12 for Yarran and pick 20. That was basically the same deal we offered Melbourne for Trengove before he failed a medical. It will all come down to whether we rate Yarran higher than we did Trengove to see if we throw in our second rounder.

I reckon that's the least Carlton would take. Pick 12 adds another elite junior player.

 

[TigerTime88]

Lennon for Yarran will probably be an equatable solution.
Not such a great deal for CFC but better than than a 2nd rounder in a weak draft.
Obviously Ben not signing yet is an obvious indicator.

I'm shocked your suggesting not a great deal for Carlton.

Lennon was pick 12 and has come in and shown why. Will be a gun and if I had the choice I would prefer to keep him over Yarran.

 

[TigerTime88]

I think the deal will be pick 12 for Yarran and pick 20. That was basically the same deal we offered Melbourne for Trengove before he failed a medical. It will all come down to whether we rate Yarran higher than we did Trengove to see if we throw in our second rounder.

I reckon that's the least Carlton would take. Pick 12 adds another elite junior player.

I think 30 has to go back. Yarran is talented and AFL form is better than TAC Cup so I am all for that.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Keep him, fine by us, we get him as a free agent next year

What sort of contract ... years ... money? Possible we could get tier 2 compo but even tier 3 is better than #31.

I'd say you don't necessarily represent Richmond on this trade. They must be after him for a reason.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

bergholt's draft calculator has Yarran's value as #19 in a #12 and #31 for #20 trade. We could deal with that.
https://www.draftguru.com.au/pick-value-calculator#12,31,|Chris Yarran,20,

 

[Pounce]

Lennon for Yarran will probably be an equatable solution.
Not such a great deal for CFC but better than than a 2nd rounder in a weak draft.
Obviously Ben not signing yet is an obvious indicator.

Carlton are not getting Lennon. Keep dreaming.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

I think 30 has to go back. Yarran is talented and AFL form is better than TAC Cup so I am all for that.

Agreed. #12 for Yarran and #20 puts Yarran's value as #45.

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

bergholt's draft calculator has Yarran's value as #19 in a #12 and #31 for #20 trade. We could deal with that.
https://www.draftguru.com.au/pick-value-calculator#12,31,|Chris Yarran,20,

Seems fair....but I think Richmond will look to trade out for a high 2nd rounder (20-22ish) re the likes of Astbury and use that. I don't know, but for some reason I think 12 will be used for something else.

Could live with your outcome. Wouldn't be rapt, but could live with it

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

I think the deal will be pick 12 for Yarran and pick 20. That was basically the same deal we offered Melbourne for Trengove before he failed a medical. It will all come down to whether we rate Yarran higher than we did Trengove to see if we throw in our second rounder.

I reckon that's the least Carlton would take. Pick 12 adds another elite junior player.

It's an 8 spot upgrade in the top 20. If it put us well inside the top 10, the value is there. Not for #12 though.

The draft calculator says:

Yarran & 20 for 12 and 31 = Yarran valued at 19.
Yarran & 20 for 12 = Yarran valued at 45.
Yarran & 39 for 12 = Yarran valued at 23.

Personally think the first one is better value for Richmond while suiting Carlton. The last one overvalues 39.

 

[dlanod]

<Club 1> wants <trade suggestion 1>......not going to happen
<Club 2> wants to use <trade suggestion 2>......not going to happen

These are ambit claims

A fair and reasonable solution will be found

Fixed that if you wanted to post it on nearly every thread on this board.

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

Fixed that if you wanted to post it on nearly every thread on this board.

Thanks mate, sorry, I thought Yarran had nominated us and McKay had asked for a 1st rounder. Please help me out with what I am missing here