List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2015

[Crazy Tails]

There's this from our good friends on FB referencing Witts amongst a few others

I can't get past the Australian paywall to confirm.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

It is very amusing that his name is being raised. We must be desperate.

If you mean desparate as big footy devotees then yes true.
If you mean Collingwood, not so, steady careful decision making

 

[bodga22]

Matt Finnis from the Saints was just on SEN
Sounded like they won't give up pick 5 and yet they want both Carlisle and Freeman!

 

[Matt_352]

Matt Finnis from the Saints was just on SEN
Sounded like they won't give up pick 5 and yet they want both Carlisle and Freeman!

Well they Not getting Freeman for their 3rd rounder so good luck dickhead

 

[Matt_352]

What did the list manager. end up saying about Collingwood?

 

[Pendles!]

Hard to believe the Carlisle thread is bigger than the Danger one.

When you take into account that two of the wingiest supporter bases are involved in that thread than it makes it a bit more believable!

 

[thetruth000001]

Well they Not getting Freeman for their 3rd rounder so good luck dickhead

2016 second rounder?

 

[Matt_352]

2016 second rounder?

Id do that

 

[Mick39]

Just as a hypothetical, Pick 7 / Witts to GWS, for Treloar & Tomlinsen.

 

[mattys123]

What did the list manager. end up saying about Collingwood?

7 minutes of fun.

Still listening to it myself.

https://soundcloud.com/nabtraderadi...ndcloud&utm_campaign=share&utm_medium=twitter

Using a tram analogy, it's a bus dickhead.

Apparently we can't do what the Dogs did, "soaring up the ladder" (to an elimination final loss).

 

[Pedro]

Well they Not getting Freeman for their 3rd rounder so good luck dickhead

We can posture all we like. It would be a shit result, but the PSD is my worry.

 

[Mick39]

Saints are trading their first pick in 2016 to get Carlisle.

 

[danielnajdek]

7 minutes of fun.

Still listening to it myself.

https://soundcloud.com/nabtraderadi...ndcloud&utm_campaign=share&utm_medium=twitter

Using a tram analogy, it's a bus dickhead.

Apparently we can't do what the Dogs did, "soaring up the ladder" (to an elimination final loss).

I listened to him when he was analysing us. 7 minutes I wished I could get back of my life.

 

[danielnajdek]

They wanna pay a bloke 400k yet wanna give us a third rounder. Good luck. 2nd rounder from next year please.

 

[mattys123]

I listened to him when he was analysing us. 7 minutes I wished I could get back of my life.

He actually didn't analyse us, just repeated the bloody obvious over and over again.

We know Seedsman, Kennedy and Freeman are leaving, he didn't even say if they were big losses or not.

I do like how he still can't bring himself to say Treloar is a lock with the Pies.

 

[danielnajdek]

He actually didn't analyse us, just repeated the bloody obvious over and over again.

We know Seedsman, Kennedy and Freeman are leaving, he didn't even say if they were big losses or not.

I do like how he still can't bring himself to say Treloar is a lock with the Pies.

His Richmond he is salty like the rest of them.

Guaranteed he wont have us as the big winner of trade week. Guy is a flog.

 

[Pedro]

I do like how he still can't bring himself to say Treloar is a lock with the Pies.

Once it happens, it'll be, "i've said for a long time that Treloar was a lock to the Pies. We all knew it 6 months ago"

 

[Saintly Viewed]

What did the list manager. end up saying about Collingwood?

Imagine being coached by that voice,
Youd be deliberately hoping to lose and miss finals just to miss a possible extra 4 weeks of plough and his voice training you.
If plough and his voice went to hawthorn he'd still stuff it up

Yuk!

 

[Pendles!]

Saints are trading their first pick in 2016 to get Carlisle.

That would be disastrous. They'll back themselves in to improve, but wouldn't be surprised to see them finish bottom 3.

 

[Pedro]

Imagine being coached by that voice,
Youd be deliberately hoping to lose and miss finals just to miss a possible extra 4 weeks of plough and his voice training you.
If plough and his voice went to hawthorn he'd still stuff it up

Yuk!

Haha. My dear old Mum who is pretty tolerant of most things, arks up whenever she hears his voice. Hates it with a passion

 

[HFF]

What do people think about Nathan Hrovat?
Midget but worth a look?

 

[JOELY]

There's this from our good friends on FB referencing Witts amongst a few others

I can't get past the Australian paywall to confirm.

View attachment 181187

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/spo...mpson-a-new-deal/story-fnca0u4y-1227558052881


Greater Western Sydney are hunting for an experienced ruckman, which appears to be an indication that all is not well with their injured man-mountain Shane Mumford.

The Giants have contacted at least two clubs and several player agents regarding trading in a big man, and their search has so far involved contracted Western Bulldogs ruckman Will Minson and Sydney’s back-up ruckman Tom Derickx.

GWS will also sound out Geelong free agent Dawson Simpson, who has been restricted throughout his career by injuries.

It is believed the Giants are offering above market value to both clubs and players in their attempt to lure an experienced big man.

Mumford, one of the driving forces in the Giants’ rise in the first half of the season when they won seven of their first 10 games, broke down in round 11 and required surgery that brought a premature end to his season.

The 28-year-old Sydney premiership player had his left ankle reconstructed after being hurt against Collingwood. He had a deltoid ligament repaired and coach Leon Cameron suggested his rehabilitation could take up to six months.

However, the GWS best-and-fairest winner last year in his first season with his third club, could be under a fitness cloud as to when, or indeed if, he will be available to resume training.

Minson, an All-Australian in 2013, was in and out of the Bulldogs’ line-up this year with 10 senior games, but was recalled for their elimination final loss to Adelaide.

The Dogs have already delisted ruckman Ayce Cordy, leaving them only Minson, Tom Campbell, who played six games this season, and pinch-hitter Jordan Roughead to play in the ruck.

Derickx played only one game this season for the Swans, bringing his career total to 15 games over four years with Richmond and Sydney.

The Giants played all three developing ruckmen this year — Tom Downie (seven games), Rory Lobb (nine) and Andrew Phillips (four) — but the trio appeared to be in need of support from a more seasoned big man. Phillips will probably be traded to Carlton with several other teammates including Lachie Plowman later this month.

Gold Coast ruckman Zac Smith is not on the Giants’ radar as he will this week nominate either Geelong or possibly Essendon as his club of choice before a trade deal is worked out.

Neither is Brisbane free agent ruckman Matthew Leuenberger, who is tossing up whether to cross to Essendon or Sydney. Leuenberger’s manager, Paul Connors, said yesterday his client would make his decision within the next 10 days.

Meanwhile, rejected Gold Coast midfielder Harley Bennell appears poised to return home to Western Australia and join Fremantle after failing to impress Richmond last week.

The Tigers said several factors influenced their decision not to offer him a contract but would not elaborate following several meetings with club officials and players last week.

Bennell, who is under contract with the Suns for two more years, was sacked following a series of off-field indiscretions involving the use of illicit drugs and alcohol.

 

[Robroy22]

I haven't looked elsewhere (Carlisle thread, Hawks trade links etc...) but with Lake and Hale going wouldn't the Hawks be slightly interested in Carlisle now? Carlisle and Aish would be handy for them to keep up their average.

 

[GoalSneak07]

Interesting from the Saints list manager Ameet Bains on Trade Radio today saying that they were well into talks with us and Nathan Freeman crossing over to the Saints compared to the talks with Carlisle. My question is, what are St Kilda offering do you think that makes him think we're in a position to deal Freeman off so easily?

I mean a third rounder is not enough IMHO for a top 10 pick whose had 2 years in the system and only has had a bad run of injuries preventing him from breaking into our best 22. They (Saints) must rate him enough to throw a nice contract at him yet by all reports (Experts on Trade Raddio today) stating that a 3rd rounder might be what the Pies will have to take.

That's piss weak if it happens our clubs put a bucket load of work into this kid. As a Collingwood member I'm going to be very disappointed if that's all we can garner for a guy whose got potentially another 10 years in the system. You don't get picked in the top 10 for nothing. In this case he potentially has.

 

[ClaytonM]

Witts was the reason we pulled out of going for Kruz club would be filthy if he changed his mind to go interstate

But I would be delighted! Trade Witts for good return, don't get Kruz who I don't want, and deny Blues a possible pick 2 compensation pick.

Win! Win! Win!