Geelong and Hawthorn record monumentally embarrassing 800 page shitfight thread.

[Josh_hawk]

Since I have him on ignore and seeing Lethality"s post i know who it is.

So can someone tell the Hawk Envy Obsessed Cheffy their are other teams in the comp.

That'd be like taking away his will to live

 

[Lethality]

Since I have him on ignore and seeing Lethality"s post i know who it is.

So can someone tell the Hawk Envy Obsessed Cheffy their are other teams in the comp.

He really needs to read the Advertiser's article and accept that even though Geelong have an inferior dynasty, it's no shame being beaten by Hawthorn and it doesn't take away from their accomplishments. (Except for the times when it did, i.e. 2008 GF 2013 PF)

 

[chefmeister]

It proves that you don't understand the point that is being made or are in denial. Either one.

Point originally being made was Collingwood weren't a worthy GF opponent because of 25 GF losses.
I simply said they had at least 4peated already which was just the right button to push to send you into a downward spiral, wildly flapping all the way down.

Not my fault you're so dumb as dog shit to need this explained to you after its already been typed out in black and white not much more than 20 minutes ago.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

We also beat Geelong in the 2013 prelim & 2014 qualifying final. Not our fault your club was too shit to make the big dance.

2007, 2009 and 2011 Hawthorn were gash so must be all valid premierships.

 

[Lethality]

Point originally being made was Collingwood weren't a worthy GF opponent because of 25 GF losses.
I simply said they had at least 4peated already which was just the right button to push to send you into a downward spiral, flapping all the way down.

Good on you for pointing out they 4peated, but as I already explained, this happened before Collingwood became a perennial Grand Final failure which saw them also lose the 2011 GF. So it's just not relevant to Collingwood's current Grand Final record.

If you ever needed more proof that these records matter, only take a look at the 2010 Grand Final. Two GF losers collide, it's not a coincidence it was a draw

Collingwood are a historically weak GF performer. There's just no getting away from it.

 

[Josh_hawk]

2007, 2009 and 2011 Hawthorn were gash so must be all valid premierships.

Never stop being the most boring poster on the bay

Surely the kids over on the Geelong board need your input

 

[TazHawk15]

He really needs to read the Advertiser's article and accept that even though Geelong have an inferior dynasty, it's no shame being beaten by Hawthorn and it doesn't take away from their accomplishments. (Except for the times when it did, i.e. 2008 GF 2013 PF)

I get why he hates the Hawks if anyone had tormented my team for 30 odd years the way the Hawks have tormented the poor old Handbaggers, I would be envious as well.

However the kid needs to let it go and I would suggest he do a search on the team board of the club he is supposed to support, I still think it is the best read in BF history.

On the Handbagger board do yourself a favour Cheffy and search "30 years of torment at the hands of the Hawks" a fantastic thread it makes very good reading.

 

[cats2rise]

Thank you for that geographical clarification ... they are still cheats though

Thats ok. I am surprised you know the word 'geopraphical ' as Hawks fans don't really know much outside their own bubble. But hey, if you are going to take aim at someone, at least be accurate.

I was also unaware hawks fans knew the phrase 'thank you.'

 

[Josh_hawk]

If you ever needed more proof that these records matter, only take a look at the 2010 Grand Final. Two GF losers collide, it's not a coincidence it was a draw

Now that is gold

 

[TazHawk15]

I was also unaware hawks fans knew the phrase 'thank you.'

Are you kidding?

I have a very vivid memory of saying thank you to my long term Handbagger mate when he handed over a fist full of money after the 2008 GF and 2013 PF.

We Hawk fans always say thank you.

 

[chefmeister]

Good on you for pointing out they 4peated, but as I already explained, this happened before Collingwood became a perennial Grand Final failure which saw them also lose the 2011 GF. So it's just not relevant to Collingwood's current Grand Final record.

If you ever needed more proof that these records matter, only take a look at the 2010 Grand Final. Two GF losers collide, it's not a coincidence it was a draw

Doesn't really matter what you already explained as it was just another excuse to save your dumb arse after the fact.

Nice try though - 9/10

 

[Lethality]

Doesn't really matter what you already explained as it was just another excuse to save your dumb arse after the fact.

It was my argument the whole time . . . maybe you only realised it later in the conversation, but that would be your issue.

 

[chefmeister]

Collingwood are a historically weak GF performer. There's just no getting away from it.

Yet they already 4peated which is what I originally said.
Continue to go off on your own tangent but there's just no getting away from it.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Never stop being the most boring poster on the bay

Surely the kids over on the Geelong board need your input

We only played perennial GF chokers because Hawks weren't good enough to make it - so all flags are rock solid. What's your problem with that Josho?

 

[chefmeister]

It was my argument the whole time . . . maybe you only realised it later in the conversation, but that would be your issue.

Nope, just didn't see its relevance to what I and JH were discussing.
But please, by all means continue 'explaining' yourself.

 

[Josh_hawk]

We only played perennial GF chokers because Hawks weren't good enough to make it - so all flags are rock solid. What's your problem with that Josho?

Geelong boards that way >>>>>>>>>

 

[Lethality]

Nope, just didn't see its relevance to what I and JH were discussing.

Collingwood's failure as a Grand Final opponent WAS what you were discussing with josh hawk. I just rejected that their fourpeat a century ago has any bearing on it.

 

[chefmeister]

Collingwood's failure as a Grand Final opponent WAS what you were discussing with josh hawk. I just rejected that their fourpeat a century ago has any bearing on it.

That's great but no one cares what you reject. After all you're accepting a FOTY backing you up and you're even 'liking' his posts to provide him encouragement.

"I rejected.."

lol

 

[Lethality]

lol, no one cares what you reject. After all you're accepting a FOTY backing you up and you're even 'liking' his posts to provide him encouragement.

I think everyone rejects it, it's just logic that something that happened a century ago doesn't negate what happened afterwards.

 

[Josh_hawk]

That's great but no one cares what you reject. After all you're accepting a FOTY backing you up and you're even 'liking' his posts to provide him encouragement.

"I rejected.."

lol

Rather large move away from topic at hand








(Deflection)

 

[Josh_hawk]

Back on topic

13 > 9
6 < 8
$ > -$
1989, 2008 > 1963

Etc, etc, etc

 

[chefmeister]

I was also unaware hawks fans knew the phrase 'thank you.'

shit dude, they thank us every year for including them in a marquee game at the G on Easter weekend.

 

[chefmeister]

Rather large move away from topic at hand

Well re-explaining it to you guys was becoming tedious.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Back on topic

13 > 9
6 < 8
$ > -$
1989, 2008 > 1963

Etc, etc, etc

This cute little minnow poster is calling others boring

 

[Josh_hawk]

This cute little minnow poster is calling others boring

So he pulls out the most overused meme on BF to prove he's not boring! Ha

Truth hurts doesn't it Charlie