List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 part 2 - see Mod Warning p 281

[Soups]

Do we need more midfielders

I think one more elite clearance player wouldn't hurt. If we had someone in there like that against the Hawks, they wouldn't have waltzed out of the middle and kicked that goal.

 

[spartan-magpie]

He's a worse kick than Cloke???

Is that even possible?

Levi casboult.

 

[Mondi21]

This fellow makes sense. Hoorah for this fellow.

My amorous mood around O'Meara cooled significantly after our resident physio TRS gave us some sobering factuals. If we could land someone cheap but reliable in defence that would allow us to send one/either of Howe or Reid forward that would be a great move on the board.

Also like that you've got Crocker on the forward line. My forward line from earlier is similar to yours - which is how I know you're clever - but I popped Varcoe in there when last night I imagined it with Crocker. Nice work old boy. Howe/Reid would replace Varcoe who goes to a wing.

Do you think Broomhead can play that Blair role? I think he could

 

[Apex36]

did brown do as much damage as cooney when he fell over in Arizona?

on a different not but relevant to the discussion, are ACL repairs still using patella tendon?

Standard ACL repairs use the hamstring now.

 

[Mondi21]

Oh God no!! Jong is better than Batchelor why wouldn't we just take him. Jong on his own is unders let alone taking a worse player for Cloke.

id rather Jong, Batchelor is no good

 

[Mondi21]

Witts can't play up forward.

Witts cant play forward id rather play Cox up forward than Witts, but to be honest i dont think we need to replace Cloke with another big bloke remember Fazalo, Elliot and if Howe plays up forward next season are all good above there head.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

id rather Jong, Batchelor is no good

The only reason we'd recruit Batcholor is to save on punching bags.

 

[theswimmer]

Do you think Broomhead can play that Blair role? I think he could

Idk, tell me if I'm wrong, but does anyone see a future for Broomhead in the black and white?

 

[Mondi21]

The only reason we'd recruit Batcholor is to save on punching bags.

haha Batcholor is similar to Langdon, Langdon being a little better in my eyes but both too slow off half back and cough the ball up too much, cant question is courage though.

 

[Jasper84]

Did anyone else suit up for the Deb Ball on here?

 

[Mondi21]

Idk, tell me if I'm wrong, but does anyone see a future for Broomhead in the black and white?

I do, the boy can play, uses the ball well on both sides of his body knows were the goals are and is hard at it, just been killed by injuries.

 

[AgroMagro]

Idk, tell me if I'm wrong, but does anyone see a future for Broomhead in the black and white?

21 games since his debut against the Cats in Rnd 7, 2013. Starting to forget what he looks like...

 

[Pendles!]

Idk, tell me if I'm wrong, but does anyone see a future for Broomhead in the black and white?

Doubt he'll be at the pies next year

 

[theswimmer]

21 games since his debut against the Cats in Rnd 7, 2013. Starting to forget what he looks like...

Yeah that's what I mean, let's face the facts, he may have been injured, but did he ever threaten to take a spot in our best team? I just don't like the way he plays, I think we need to move him on...

 

[Hagla]

21 games since his debut against the Cats in Rnd 7, 2013. Starting to forget what he looks like...

 

[Mondi21]

Doubt he'll be at the pies next year

id rather get ride of Blair and keep Broomhead

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Nope. Adams is untouchable.

Quoted for emphasis

Adams is untouchable

 

[Mondi21]

id rather get ride of Blair and keep Broomhead

He has more up side and age on his side

 

[theswimmer]

id rather get ride of Blair and keep Broomhead

Well that isn't going to happen whilst Bucks is coach... Blair is not leaving, Bucks loves him

 

[Rorzza]

Broomhead is a keeper even if he is in the closet for a while.

 

[RupetFan]

Yeah that's what I mean, let's face the facts, he may have been injured, but did he ever threaten to take a spot in our best team? I just don't like the way he plays, I think we need to move him on...

What? He's a small crumbing forward, He was in our best 22 at the start of the year last season.

 

[Mondi21]

Yeah that's what I mean, let's face the facts, he may have been injured, but did he ever threaten to take a spot in our best team? I just don't like the way he plays, I think we need to move him on...

I dont agree i think he could be in our best 22 by the end of next year if he stays injury free

 

[Matthew_13]

I could be wrong but something big I believe is happening behind close doors.

- Bucks come out in one of the most honest interviews ever and says 2017 it's finals or all over for him.

- We then have Cloke today ask to be traded and with Swans retirement we have a bit of cash spare

We all would agree that as good as Moore will be with only white and Cox as Kf to help we will struggle to impact the score board next year.

Bucks would not come out and throw his career on the line unless something was being hatched.

I could be wrong but just my thoughts

 

[theswimmer]

What? He's a small crumbing forward, He was in our best 22 at the start of the year last season.

I dont agree i think he could be in our best 22 by the end of next year if he stays injury free

Okay if you say so, I just think he doesn't fit.... Just my opinion, I could be wrong, I'm not saying I am right

 

[Mondi21]

Okay if you say so, I just think he doesn't fit.... Just my opinion, I could be wrong, I'm not saying I am right

and thats fare enough we all have an opinion and we all see things differently.