Remove this Banner Ad

Rumour Bluemour Discussion thread - The sequel - I know what SOS did last Sumner

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
He ain't no greased lighting, but we like our Kruez.
He is a bit like lightning, his tap outs never hit the same spot twice.
 
Left field and indigenous...

Has to be Ahern. I'd reckon is would be worth 12 months of rehabilitation to get that sort of player bundled into the trade.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Phillips can take a mark, kick straight, snag a goal forward and has mobility. Hampson.
Yes, but apart from that ....?
No, I think it's the last one, mobility (and balance and agility) around the ball which I didn't think was too good.
I just remember him being flat footed many times. Probably wrong, though, I'm just an ignorant couch potato.
 
Fyfe - keen on a move to Melbourne, reportedly had/having issues with teammates who may lack the professionalism he has, sees the window closing once Sanderlands retires, did I mention he's keen on a move to Melbourne!

Judd can be a great salesman!!!

Money no object and Freo will not match, Fyfe not a gold digger but he knows his 'brand' will be off the charts if he gets to Melbourne...

Blues want him which usually ends up in one result!!
 
Left field and indigenous...

Has to be Ahern. I'd reckon is would be worth 12 months of rehabilitation to get that sort of player bundled into the trade.

the indigneous will be referring to pickett.

Ahern isnt left field at all.
 
Fyfe - keen on a move to Melbourne, reportedly had/having issues with teammates who may lack the professionalism he has, sees the window closing once Sanderlands retires, did I mention he's keen on a move to Melbourne!

Judd can be a great salesman!!!

Money no object and Freo will not match, Fyfe not a gold digger but he knows his 'brand' will be off the charts if he gets to Melbourne...

Blues want him which usually ends up in one result!!
100% brown & gold in 2017 then........
 
Fyfe - keen on a move to Melbourne, reportedly had/having issues with teammates who may lack the professionalism he has, sees the window closing once Sanderlands retires, did I mention he's keen on a move to Melbourne!

Judd can be a great salesman!!!

Money no object and Freo will not match, Fyfe not a gold digger but he knows his 'brand' will be off the charts if he gets to Melbourne...

Blues want him which usually ends up in one result!!
He is going to St Kilda:eek:
 
The Blues have asked about young midfielder Matthew Kennedy being tied to a deal but the Giants have rejected this approach.

If we are giving up Pick 5, then what they should be giving up should make the uncomfortable too. It shouldn't just be Marchbank and a heap of fringe players.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

If we're giving up pick 5 then we want back at least one proven high quality player without injury concerns.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

All this talk of us not being close to a premiership window. Who would have thought the WB two years ago, when they were a basketcase, would be on the brink of a premiership? They would not have won if they had simply traded away their senior players.
How does anyone really know when their premiership window is open?
Think of them building from the end of 2011. We started our rebuild last year.

Yes things can always change quickly, but when everyone thought they were a basket case, they really weren't and had a good list in place.

Keeping the senior core of Boyd, Murphy and Morris has certainly helped.
 
If we're giving up pick 5 then we want back at least one proven high quality player without injury concerns.
Agree totally, this proposed trade is a step backwards in our rebuild, Marchbank is out of contract has a history of injuries, is worth 15-25, if Tuohy is traded that should have been sufficient to provide a fair trade.

The other players mentioned so far has done nothing as yet to justify the decision to offload pick 5, last year we were able to strike a trade for some high picks from GWS, why are we carving in this year.
This goes completely against the message from Management that they would only trade pick 5 for something exceptional.

Most teams that have sustained success have a core group of 6-8 real quality players, we need two more drafts to access the high end quality to build a list to have sustained success, very disappointed if we carve to this unless there is some proven AFL quality as part of this trade.

We should be backing our talent scouts in to identify the best talent with pick 5 this year.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top