List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 Part 3

[Tassiepies83]

Don't hate Dunn but not really a big Upgrade from Brown

Key word there TD is upgrade

 

[Jonno94]

Thought the club had something else planned when they let Brown go, what an awful result this will be.

 

[Big Bryza]

Because we need another bloke approaching 30 who couldnt get a game at his own club

Dunn is as good a defender as Oscar McDonald but they went with the younger player to get games into him. Fairly simple to understand I would've thought.

 

[Horaceg]

Let's wait until the trade period ends before judging. I reckon we are going to be alright.

I have a feeling we haven't played all our cards.

 

[Countrypie]

Dunn is shit defensively. Frost and, in particular, Brown are much better negators.

I seem to remember him stitching up Cloke one day....but then again that may have not been much of a recommendation in itself

 

[unplugged]

When you have a look at what the Hawks got for Lewis - future captain, second in the B&F, we are probably making out well to get anything for Cloke. It really seems to be a buyers market this year. No one is shelling out much for anyone.

It's funny, every year it's said that Hawthorn are great traders. They sometimes give up overs in order to "always" get their man/men.

But you could just as easily say that they're not good negotiators.

 

[regpies]

That'll do me, I'm done, goodbye

 

[Big Bryza]

I call it now, we are going to have the worst percentage in 2017. Why retire Toovey to bring in Dunne. Makes no sense. How can we have salary cap problems playing in the bottom half of the ladder?

What else could go wrong from here:
- WHE could go to blues or Roos.
- Cloke stays
- Gubby gets suspension / fine for GWS drug affair and we have no footy boss
- injuries to key players like every year in football.

Lol, please. Tooves was awful this season.

 

[TradeDraft]

That'll do me, I'm done, goodbye

That be the best we can get

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Don't hate Dunn but not really a big Upgrade from Brown

Maybe not an upgrade overall, but if he's a similar level, but a better kick, then he might be a better fit for our team.

 

[4#Didak#4]

I seem to remember him stitching up Cloke one day....but then again that may have not been much of a recommendation in itself

Yes I was just thinking that, he physically matched Cloke that day and it was surprising, however Clokey's output since maybe takes some shine off that effort.

 

[loki04]

Can't believe the Dunn hate. Will be excellent for us

Yeah it is not a poor decision and really beggars can't be choosers.

The Treloar trade has had a short term restriction on our ability to trade and hit the draft. (Not saying it was the wrong decision as he is a true gun).

 

[Big Bryza]

Can't believe the Dunn hate. Will be excellent for us

Same. Some people have zero understanding of it.

 

[loki04]

Maybe not an upgrade overall, but if he's a similar level, but a better kick, then he might be a better fit for our team.

I think he will end up surprising quite a few on here if he can come close to anywhere near some of his better footy.

At his best is a quality player.

 

[Wooljay]

View attachment 301866

That'll do me, I'm done, goodbye

 

[PepperFace]

Apparently Collingwood are trying to get Zac Dawson involved in the Dunn/Silvagni deal

 

[loki04]

FB: Maynard Dunn Ramsey/Sinclair
HB: Howe Reid Scharenberg/Langdon

All of a sudden our ball use looks a mile better, defensively as long as they cover we shouldn't get over exposed and have Keeffe who may come in for the uber talls 200cm fwds.

 

[TradeDraft]

Apparently Collingwood are trying to get Zac Dawson involved in the Dunn/Silvagni deal

Ha Ha Very Funny

 

[4#Didak#4]

It's funny, every year it's said that Hawthorn are great traders. They sometimes give up overs in order to "always" get their man/men.

But you could just as easily say that they're not good negotiators.

Some may say they are selling the farm for O'Meara.

I did find the deal remarkable given they were "desperate" he stay and "disappointed" he left. I keep re reading that deal looking for the missing pick the Dees should have given up.

How good would have a straight Lewis for Cloke swap be. Lewis is a hard edge competitor who will give the young Dees a lot of backbone.

 

[Soups]

I don't think everyone understands that Dunn is probably the best backman we can pick up cheap. You can't always go and pick up superstars, especially when you don't have the currency. We'll head to the draft with a few selections and hopefully we can pick up some KPP to groom over the next couple of year.

Silvagni, now that's a different kettle of fish. Replace spuds with even bigger spud.

 

[jonbe54]

You've literally posted the same thing every day of the trade period.... We get it!

Same question gets posted every day of the trade period - ermmm have a go at them??

 

[magpies2013]

Surely we are talking the pi55.mayne dunn silvagni all in 1 trade period. they can't be fair dinkum can they.

 

[loki04]

Apparently Collingwood are trying to get Zac Dawson involved in the Dunn/Silvagni deal

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Some trivia if we get L Dunn apparently out of all present day players he has played the most games without any finals played.

I assume this deal isnot done yet

 

[Jonno94]

We should also go after Garland so we have 3/6 of the Demons star backline.

Some trivia if we get L Dunn apparently out of all present day players he has played the most games without any finals played.

I assume this deal isnot done yet

Seems he wants to continue that record by joining us.