List Mgmt. 2016 Trade and Free Agency Targets Part 4

[gringo2011]

Ridiculous picking that late.
It will most likely leave a hole in a list, unless they someone pluck some players that late.

They drafted well last year at least hardwick, Burton and Lovell all look the goods. They will drop away hard though because they have compromised next year too. I love JOM but the risk was too huge. I would have been worried giving up pick 10 for him.

 

[puppy_dog7]

The laughable thing is the bloke on AFL.com.au giving Hawks a trade rating of B..
Is he flipping Serious?! B

They'd have to be a C- at best.

Gave up all their draft picks and their top 2 BnF place getters for T. Mitch and a cooked Jaeger

Edit: just for comparison, we got rated a B+

 

[bird_man]

What are our chances of a guy like florent? I thought he'd be well gone by 23 but Cal twomey has him ranked 18th in the draft and there's only 5 Victorian picks before ours so maybe a possible slider?

Very unlikely I think unfortunately

 

[saint_]

Lets be cunning at try and get a 3rd First Rounder when trade period comes next year!

 

[JG22]

If we can get a Fyfe or Shiel reckon we would do it, but taking two firsts would be very beneficial.
A key back and midfielder or two mids.

 

[Stewart66]

The laughable thing is the bloke on AFL.com.au giving Hawks a trade rating of B..
Is he ruddy Serious?! B

They'd have to be a C- at best.

Gave up all their draft picks and their top 2 BnF place getters for T. Mitch and a cooked Jaeger

Edit: just for comparison, we got rated a B+

Not really he barracks for Whorethorn

 

[RoundCubic]

Ins:
Main: Steele, Stevens, N. Brown, pick 23, pick 36, Holmes
Rookie: Irish A, Rookie pick
Cat B: Irish B

Outs:
Main: Curren, Delaney, Murdoch, Shenton, Fisher, Templeton
Rookie: Payne, Saunders,
Cat B: Holmes

It looks like Lee was offered a contract in an article I read....

Yahoo lies... maybe
hope we keep Eli

 

[cooperrules]

Yahoo lies... maybe
hope we keep Eli

mitch mcarthy as well

 

[RoundCubic]

It doesn't look as flash when you put it on paper but if Hawks nose dive we are doing extremely well from it. Steele was expensive when you look at what other teams paid for their GWS rejects so to be huge winners we need the Hawks to have a catastrophic crumble.

Probably because Steele isnt a GWS reject he's a GWS depth player way ahead of what Carlton have been taking

 

[dewah07]

For those saying Hawks sold the farm for JOM.

I have an uncle. He sold his farm.

Then he received a 7 figure sum for it.

This is not the Hawk's

campaigner, i think its just a saying

 

[Persevering Saint]

I love me some Kelly.

*jelly kelly photo*

 

[Persevering Saint]

Can we pick up any more DFAs, or must we only go to the draft?

 

[crasha301]

Lets be cunning at try and get a 3rd First Rounder when trade period comes next year!

Armo for gc 1st rounder 2017?

 

[puppy_dog7]

Armo for gc 1st rounder 2017?

Armo for Hopper straight swap next year

 

[PrinceofSeaford]

Very unlikely I think unfortunately

Who do you think would be a good get at 23?

 

[StKing11]

Lmfao Cats have had a shocker, nearly as bad as the Hawks. They won't be top 4 next year.

Out: Caddy, Kersten, Vardy, Smedts, Enright (ret), Bartel (ret), maybe Lonergan, maybe Clark

In: Tuohy, Black

Missed Deledio because they've got no money, why did they try and get him in the first place then?

Shopped Motlop - no interest.

For some strange reason gave up their 2017 1st rounder in the Tuohy deal, that will be their third straight year without a 1st rounder. Paid overs.

Gave up Caddy for unders when he wasn't desperate to move. Gave up Kersten for nothing.

 

[Barrels]

Lmfao Cats have had a shocker, nearly as bad as the Hawks. They won't be top 4 next year.

Out: Caddy, Kersten, Vardy, Smedts, Enright (ret), Bartel (ret), maybe Lonergan, maybe Clark

In: Tuohy, Black

Missed Deledio because they've got no money, why did they try and get him in the first place then?

Shopped Motlop - no interest.

For some strange reason gave up their 2017 1st rounder in the Tuohy deal, that will be their third straight year without a 1st rounder. Paid overs.

Gave up Caddy for unders when he wasn't desperate to move. Gave up Kersten for nothing.

With Kersten and Vardy gone, if Clark goes they're only a dodgy Hawkins back and a injury-prone Stanley away from having to throw Henderson forward alongside Buzza!

Similarly if Lonergan calls it quits they're down to a geriatric Taylor, undersized Ruggles, so-so Kolojdashnij or very very raw Gardner.

Their good is still good, but the cliff is coming fast.

 

[Loyal Sainter]

Barrels Who are the likely draftees we could get with 23 and 36? Any preferences ?

 

[bird_man]

Who do you think would be a good get at 23?

Powell Pepper, Galluccci and Cox are the ones I'm hoping for around that pick. Bolton as well but he's a long shot.

 

[holllywood]

Talking with my mate about Carlton's list management strategy.

Safe to say we came to the conclusion that it is horrendous.

How can you expect to compete with GWS if you pick up their off cuts? They have 9 ex-GWS listed players, and the only one who would get a game for GWS next year would be Marchbank.

Stinks of laziness (as Finey said) and arrogance from SOS. Why go back to the well that has given you close to nothing? The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and expecting a different result. He is setting up Carlton for years of pain if he continually picks up 3+ NEAFL players from GWS every year.

There is value in places other than the GWS reserves team.

Just another case of a favourite son ruining his team. He is not quite on Hird's level nor Buckley or Voss, but if he continues this current list management plan, it's only a matter of time.

 

[austinnn]

If JOM comes good, there will be a riot outside Rors house!

Rors = Graham Wright

 

[AaronSCHQ]

So, judging by the club's comments on Stevens' ability to go forward, will we see:

FB: Geary - Brown - Dempster
HB: Roberton - Carlisle - Savage
RK: Hickey - Steven - Armitage
CR: Newnes - Ross - Riewoldt
HF: Stevens - Bruce - Billings
FF: Weller - McCartin - Membrey
IC: Steele Gresham Montagna Acres

In Round 1 next season?

What does this mean for Dunstan, Gilbert, Webster, Longer and McKenzie?

Where do Sinclair, Templeton, Lee, Holmes, Pierce and Shenton fit?

Is Fisher done?

Is the team as listed quick enough?

Interesting times...

I just adjusted my Round 1 22 since the Stevens news. Same/same, but different! (in this team i was assuming Dunstan wasn't fit)

 

[Tommy Wigs]

Powell Pepper, Galluccci and Cox are the ones I'm hoping for around that pick. Bolton as well but he's a long shot.

What's the knock on Gallucci?

 

[Plumber66]

Hawks have literally replaced a Mitch for a younger Mitch.

Lewis is a big loss, but Vickery straightens them up.

Key for them will be the old brigade and if they have it in them for one last crack.

Don't know much about their kids but they're rate them to go this route.

 

[Tommy Wigs]

Was glad they held out for 2nd rounder for WHE, they were talking about 68 or something

I think it says a bit about the others to be honest. I don't rate WHE either. Marchbank a great get for the price. I think we might have the best of all of those traded by GWS, this year at least.