- Moderator
- #301
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Funny, we beat Geelong last night in clearances.our total inability to win a clearance without Cripps its hard to see us winning another game.
I think another yr for Cas or maybe trade bait...say a pick 30I don't think I've ever seen a bloke cop more undeserved criticism on this forum than Casboult. His numbers are elite this season given his role. He never gives up, is physical, has hit the scoreboard this year and plays a critical dual-function role.
He is the player we need to protect Harry for the next few years, have no idea why letting him walk for a pick in the 20s (at best) is such a popular notion.
Ball retention and usage is our biggest problem, puts pressure on our another area of weakness, transition defense !!Funny, we beat Geelong last night in clearances.
Providing they want to win both.....They play North and the Suns both up in Brisbane. I would say a very high possibility they could take both of those as wins
I beg to differ,'d play him in back for the rest of the season.Will see plenty of the ball.Sorry, but for the moment SOJ is one of the plethora of key position players that needs a stint in the reserves.
We need to reduce our KPP by at least 2, SOJ is like Bambi if his name wasn't a Silvagni he'd be getting a game or two in the ressies.
He'll be a good player in time but I'm sure a game or two in the magoos won't do him any harm
and some of those tackles were so soft. I think White laid the only hard one all nightYour first paragraph, is spot on. Every single time we tried to group tackle or have 2 players trying to tackle the geelong player stood up, kept his arms free and then it was 3- 4 quick handballs and they were out again. Way way to easy, i understand pressuring the ball carrier but they should be able to summarise a situation and know when to leave their man. That scenario there murdered us last night.
Lamb and White are not up to it, not good enough for AFL. This is Lambs third club!Lamb is what he is .. no more no less ... has peaked.
Same as White ... he is what he is ...
Our "depth" (I will use that term atm because apparently words like plodders is upsetting) is barely VFL grade.
Until the spots from 12-22 are filled with decent players and the 23-36 listed players are constantly keeping them on their toes for spots .. times will be tough.
Seems to be a common theme with our draw of recent weeks . Teams getting extra rest . Thanfully for a change we have an opposition off a 6 day break next week . Not that i think it will help too much tho .Agree. Might sound like excuses but they're facts.
Another fact, Geelong had an 8 day break compared to our 6 day break. A two day difference at this stage of year might explain why we looked lethargic and slower last night.
Brisbane will need to win two games for us to get the spoon. Who are they going to beat?
They've been lucky to avoid the last two. Not this time.
SOJ is like Bambi if his name wasn't a Silvagni he'd be getting a game or two in the ressies.
Great post you can add that if Cas doesnt chop out in the ruck and Phillips was fit and were playing 2 rucks in the side Kruezer doesnt have the years he's had as the sole ruckman . Seriously undervalued Casboult this year .I don't think I've ever seen a bloke cop more undeserved criticism on this forum than Casboult. His numbers are elite this season given his role. He never gives up, is physical, has hit the scoreboard this year and plays a critical dual-function role.
He is the player we need to protect Harry for the next few years, have no idea why letting him walk for a pick in the 20s (at best) is such a popular notion.
If North win one more, and lose to Brissy by a bit, and we keep our current form, we'll finish last.
Not that it matters, because whatever pick we get is likely going to GWS for Kelly. Failing that, we just take it to the draft.
I don't think I've ever seen a bloke cop more undeserved criticism on this forum than Casboult. His numbers are elite this season given his role. He never gives up, is physical, has hit the scoreboard this year and plays a critical dual-function role.
He is the player we need to protect Harry for the next few years, have no idea why letting him walk for a pick in the 20s (at best) is such a popular notion.
Gotta admit, I've been thinking we're a chance for another spoon too, which is worrying.
Since when did finishing last become ok at Carlton?
Not if we keep enduring 10 goal losses. 1 game might do itvegas has to win 2 games.....unlikely
He is the player we need to protect Harry for the next few years, have no idea why letting him walk for a pick in the 20s (at best) is such a popular notion.
Last night was one of his most complete games but....Agree with this 100% - he has the best hands in the comp, his kicking has improved greatly and he is just about the best target in the comp. He has aggression, which we severely lack, looking at you Murphy, and he hurts blokes who get in front of him - I for one definitely don't want t see him go and think once we improve our midfield, he along with Charlie and Harry will form one of the best forward lines.
against 1301 for 1646 we are over 7 percent up on Lions rnd 19 even after cats loss we only dropped a couple percent cause near end of season totals dont fluctuate much.Not if we keep enduring 10 goal losses. 1 game might do it
Held on long after the ball was gone, pinned his arms and drove his head into ground, will get looked at by MRP but 'play on'.Crude tackle .. should get a week
Brain speed.Need more speed