Traded Bryce Gibbs [traded to Adelaide] - (cont. in Part 2)

[Weiterbot23]

He ain’t going to Adelaide

Carlton have failed to land Kelly, Rockliff, Hopper, Smith and Saad now. It has been a pretty disappointing start to the trade period so far for Carlton.

They won’t let Gibbs go now as the team is probably going to stay the same except they will just add Kennedy

Not as disappointing as Adelaides offseason with Lever and Cameron leaving, at least you aren't runners up there.

 

[Drewie11]

Not as disappointing as Adelaides offseason with Lever and Cameron leaving, at least you aren't runners up there.

Not much changing in your team so looks like another great year to watch Carlton try and play football

 

[marty36]

Just pay the price

Players that want to live in Adelaide are rare

Cant see Carlton allowing him to leave now, it would drain the experience too much

Its his own fault shouldnt have signed such a long contract

 

[Weiterbot23]

Not much changing in your team so looks like another great year to watch Carlton try and play football

I think our future is bright, unlike the crows most of our team aren't allowed into O28 night clubs. The end is near. Gibbs could have been the difference.

 

[Weiterbot23]

Cant see Carlton allowing him to leave now, it would drain the experience too much

Its his own fault shouldnt have signed such a long contract

Yeah 600k is fair unders if Rocky is getting 850+.

Especially as he has been paid most of it.

 

[Drewie11]

I think our future is bright, unlike the crows most of our team aren't allowed into O28 night clubs. The end is near. Gibbs could have been the difference.

You guys are starting to look worse than North Melbourne with failed recruiting efforts. Hopefully you guys didn’t pay Judd too much to try and convince Rockliff

 

[marty36]

Yeah 600k is fair unders if Rocky is getting 850+.

Especially as he has been paid most of it.

Like I said Gibbs has brought this upon himself, he needs to live with it

 

[Tushay]

You guys are starting to look worse than North Melbourne with failed recruiting efforts. Hopefully you guys didn’t pay Judd too much to try and convince Rockliff

People in glass ghost towns shouldn't throw stones.

 

[Drewie11]

People in glass ghost towns shouldn't throw stones.

Do you think Rockliff even knew who Kernahan was?

Rockliff: Hi Juddy, I’m guessing this is your Dad? Nice to meet you Mr Judd.... hilarious

 

[Weiterbot23]

You guys are starting to look worse than North Melbourne with failed recruiting efforts. Hopefully you guys didn’t pay Judd too much to try and convince Rockliff

I'd say adding a Mid with 2 years development and pick 13 is a positive

I would say losing Lever and Cameron is a negative

Would you agree?

 

[Tushay]

Do you think Rockliff even knew who Kernahan was?

Rockliff: Hi Juddy, I’m guessing this is your Dad? Nice to meet you Mr Judd.... hilarious

Probably need to have a look in the mirror and ask why Port is able to attract and retain talent and Adelaide is not.

 

[james Dean]

You guys are starting to look worse than North Melbourne with failed recruiting efforts. Hopefully you guys didn’t pay Judd too much to try and convince Rockliff

Don't be a cry baby just because SOS didn't cave to your undervalued offer of Gibbs. I'd be a bit more concerned as to why 2 of your players from your Grand Final team want to leave?

When was the last time a star asked to, and did leave Carlton? Aaron Hammill?

 

[Weiterbot23]

Don't be a cry baby just because SOS didn't cave to your undervalued offer of Gibbs. I'd be a bit more concerned as to why 2 of your players from your Grand Final team want to leave?

When was the last time a star asked to, and did leave Carlton? Aaron Hammill?

Bryce Gibbs?

 

[james Dean]

Bryce Gibbs?

When was the last time a star asked to, and did leave Carlton?

 

[Weiterbot23]

When was the last time a star asked to, and did leave Carlton?

Not as often as it happens in Adelaide

 

[SydCrow]

do you guys want Menzel back?

 

[james Dean]

do you guys want Menzel back?

Straight swap for Andrew Eccles?

 

[Drewie11]

I'd say adding a Mid with 2 years development and pick 13 is a positive

I would say losing Lever and Cameron is a negative

Would you agree?

I must have missed something, when did West Coast give you pick 13?

We used pick 14 for Lever so if we get 10 and 27 then that is a win

We used pick 7 in the ROOKIE draft for Cameron so if we get pick 18 or 19 then that is a massive win....

 

[Masqualero]

Not much changing in your team so looks like another great year to watch Carlton try and play football

A great trade period to see two of your players leave for peanuts.

Also apart from Cotchin who has learned from his mistake, who actually chooses to kick into the wind? LOL

 

[Drewie11]

Probably need to have a look in the mirror and ask why Port is able to attract and retain talent and Adelaide is not.

The same reason Port couldn’t find Hartlett a new home last year, they do big contracts at high high prices. Matthew Lobbe anyone???? Anyone at all

 

[Jeremias]

I must have missed something, when did West Coast give you pick 13?

He was obviously alluding to the fact Kennedy was taken at pick 13 in the draft.

 

[Drewie11]

A great trade period to see two of your players leave for peanuts.

Also apart from Cotchin who has learned from his mistake, who actually chooses to kick into the wind? LOL

Really, Peanuts? A pick 14 becomes pick 10 and 27

And a rookie pick 7 becomes pick 19. Not sure where you buy your peanuts.... actually yes I do... from Collingwood!!! Malthouse and Dale thomas. Daisy must still be pinching himself, and even after the year he had I believe you guys gave him another contract.... wow

 

[evo]

Do you think Rockliff even knew who Kernahan was?

Rockliff: Hi Juddy, I’m guessing this is your Dad? Nice to meet you Mr Judd.... hilarious

to be fair Sticks would be a pretty funny campaigner to have a beer with.

 

[marty36]

Straight swap for Andrew Eccles?

A mate of mine was certain Eccles would win a brownlow he was such a tosser, my mate that is

 

[Tushay]

The same reason Port couldn’t find Hartlett a new home last year, they do big contracts at high high prices. Matthew Lobbe anyone???? Anyone at all

Are you suggesting they're cheating or just doing a better job of managing their cap?