Danoz
Dananananananana Statman (òÓ,)_\,,/
IMO he meets the lack of motivation criteria for 100% delist. Specifically stated in the article on afl that he doesn’t have the passion anymore. Also is half way through a contract.
2017/18 Off Season Thread
- Thread starter fightingfury_88
- Start date
- Tagged users None
IMO he meets the lack of motivation criteria for 100% delist. Specifically stated in the article on afl that he doesn’t have the passion anymore. Also is half way through a contract.
Marklar_33
Brownlow Medallist
Seems like one of those ‘lacks motivation because he’s s**t’ retirements to me
Pie 4 Life
Hall of Famer
Seems like Bucks' thoughts on Mayne was the same as Clarko's on Vickery, but Vickery was on less $$$ and Clarko did it behind closed doors.
ShaunDuggan
🤎 🦍 🤎
So is that pay 0% of his remaining contract?
Danoz
Dananananananana Statman (òÓ,)_\,,/
I don’t know the rules
fightingfury_88
Community Leader
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #56
Considering he has an AFL contract for next season but has decided to retire, I'd imagine that's lack of motivation. The fact that he still counts against Hawthorn's cap space and list numbers next year makes me think cause to invoke the 0% salary paid delistment rule is valid. Thoughts from others?
ShaunDuggan
🤎 🦍 🤎
Sweet. Ive always been a little unsure with delistings.
Apply to delist Tyrone Vickery at 0% due to lack of motivation/talent
fightingfury_88
Community Leader
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #58
I changed my post slightly to what you quoted but I'm certainly in the camp that the 0% should apply.Sweet. Ive always been a little unsure with delistings.
Apply to delist Tyrone Vickery at 0% due to lack of motivation/talent
Marklar_33
Brownlow Medallist
Russian wouldn’t be having this s**t
sante
Emu
0% for sure
At least White played more games then Vickery
sausageroll
Brownlow Medallist
I agree with all of this
sante
Emu
Rookie Upgrade
Dan Houston - 2 years @ $144k
Long Term Extension
Lachie Neale - 5 years @ $780k
Second Year Extension
Sam Powell-Pepper - 4 years @ $600k
Will Brodie - 2 years @ $300k
Dan Houston - 2 years @ $144k
Long Term Extension
Lachie Neale - 5 years @ $780k
Second Year Extension
Sam Powell-Pepper - 4 years @ $600k
Will Brodie - 2 years @ $300k
It's setting a precedent to allow a 0% just because he had years on his contract left. I think it would be useful to go back and look at all the players who have been given the 0% in the past for comparison.
In saying that I'm not totally against Vickery getting 0%. Just know it's been a harshly applied rule in the past.
In saying that I'm not totally against Vickery getting 0%. Just know it's been a harshly applied rule in the past.
sante
Emu
He retired while contracted because he doesn’t want to play AFL anymore. Isn’t that why we have this rule?
If he didn't have a contract would him being delisted shock you?
sante
Emu
We’ll never know. Facts are he walked away from the game.
Without Russian here, I think it’s fair that we have a vote on these maybe?
Facts are he's not on a list. I don't think we actually know who made the decision. They're always going to do the right thing and let him say he's stepping down.
Just being a bit of a devil's advocate here though. Like I said, I don't mind Vickery getting 0%. I wouldn't have been surprised if Russian had said no (if he was here) though.
sausageroll
Brownlow Medallist
I never really understood the criteria for the salary discounts and was disappointed with a few rulings over the years that I thought were legitimate grounds for discount. So I definitely see your point and wouldn't argue if people thought we should be strict on the rule.
But I find myself agreeing more with the following approach...
I think if a player retires with a year or more left on his contract it's a nice simple rule that we can apply easily without having to think about it
Pie 4 Life
Hall of Famer
Brisbane Own Player Bids v.2
Jayden Laverde - 3yrs @ $233k
Mark Hutchings - 1yr @ $155k
Marley Williams - 1yr @ $155k
Sam Draper - 2yr @ $144k upgrade
Jayden Laverde - 3yrs @ $233k
Mark Hutchings - 1yr @ $155k
Marley Williams - 1yr @ $155k
Sam Draper - 2yr @ $144k upgrade
- Oct 19, 2010
- 7,864
- 4,428
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Ravens, Rabbitohs, Rockets, Everton
Own player bids
Bryce Gibbs 272 (4)
Shaun Grigg 194 (3)
Jarrod Harbrow 155 (1)
Dougal Howard 155 (1)
Kane Lambert 194 (2)
Toby Nankervis 194 (3)
Jarrad Waite 155 (1)
Bryce Gibbs 272 (4)
Shaun Grigg 194 (3)
Jarrod Harbrow 155 (1)
Dougal Howard 155 (1)
Kane Lambert 194 (2)
Toby Nankervis 194 (3)
Jarrad Waite 155 (1)
fightingfury_88
Community Leader
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #72
Nankervis bid is invalid. Below minimum for 3 years.
Pie 4 Life
Hall of Famer
When do I have to decide which contract to tear up fightingfury_88 ?
