Does anyone deserve a flag more than Nathan Jones?

[demontim27]

Well without having exact figures to look at, logic would say that given the minimum TPP requirements each club has, and the state of Melbourne's list during his time there, and the fact that he's been among their better players over that time, that he would be a pretty high earner, probably above what his talent level would warrant (if salaries were assigned in that simple a manner).

I’ve never said it’s not a decent earner. The point about TPP was already addressed. You should know we threw big money at two of your players in that time. We were overpaying everyone who came in

 

[ThaiTiger]

So you’re just making an assumption? And now have a new conspiracy theory too! How many players have their official salary released?

So, it does happen, but you just said it didn’t?

Been watching too much about the Anunnaki the last few days but it's got me thinking....

Is demontim27 the second coming of demondavey? If so, nice to have you back. The Dee's are looking good. Big game tomorrow.

 

[Ekomaira]

Robert Harvey...Lenny Hayes...

 

[Billy ray]

There are still 8 original suns on our list. In two years time that will be ten years.
If they remain on list do they deserve a premiership??










Yes. The answer is yes.

 

[demontim27]

Been watching too much about the Anunnaki the last few days but it's got me thinking....

Is demontim27 the second coming of demondavey? If so, nice to have you back. The Dee's are looking good. Big game tomorrow.

Lol no. Not even close mate

 

[ThaiTiger]

Lol no. Not even close mate

Ok, if you say so.

To the believers: The ancient Sumerian tablets do mention a fallen angel, or demon, called tim returning at the end of days just before the next Melbourne premiership. If you match up demondavey comments with demontim27 comments you will notice parallels and symmetries that can only have come from a higher intelligence that has been here before. Just sayin'.

 

[demontim27]

Ok, if you say so.

To the believers: The ancient Sumerian tablets do mention a fallen angel, or demon, called tim returning at the end of days just before the next Melbourne premiership. If you match up demondavey comments with demontim27 comments you will notice parallels and symmetries that can only have come from a higher intelligence that has been here before. Just sayin'.

I had an account under demontim about 6 months ago haha. Damn those sumarians

 

[The King!]

Buddy at Sydney

 

[Off The Couch]

Buddy at Sydney

Never - the curse has been laid

 

[The King!]

Never - the curse has been laid

 

[tigs2010]

A year ago everyone was thinking Townsend so dont be surprised if Jones repeats the feel good story and gets his this year

 

[Gydafud]

No one "deserves" a flag. They are not participation awards.

 

[Percel]

callum urch

 

[Duskfire]

Robert Harvey, Nick Riewoldt and Lenny Hayes, Scott west, Chris grant are well infront of him for deserving. I do hate to say it but maybe even figjam Buckley is.

I thought people went away on long weekends?

Yup. I would also put in Pavlich, Ablett Snr, Hocking, Couch, Matthew Richardson, am sure there are plenty

 

[STPer18]

Would be great to see Joel Selwood get another one.

 

[Tulip]

doesn't deserve s**t. always been an a-hole

What did he do?

 

[cuttlefish]

Goddard came quite close once, and then walked into an absolute shitstorm at Essendon. I feel for him a little.

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Pav and Robert Harvey spring to mind of past players.

Current, it would be nice for Masten and Josh Kennedy to win one...

 

[Boohemian]

Josh Kennedy and Mark LeCras deserve a premiership. Nathan Jones will probably be unceremoniously delisted before Melbourne win a premiership.

 

[DrEvil_]

Goddard came quite close once, and then walked into an absolute shitstorm at Essendon. I feel for him a little.

Do you feel for the pretzels?

 

[class78]

Probably the most overrated player of the last decade. Talked about as if he’s a multiple All Australian inspirational leader when he’d probably be about on par with Richard Douglas career wise. Media just love the hyperbolic ‘warrior’ story when he’s a B grade midfielder at best.

 

[Trav 20]

Probably the most overrated player of the last decade. Talked about as if he’s a multiple All Australian inspirational leader when he’d probably be about on par with Richard Douglas career wise. Media just love the hyperbolic ‘warrior’ story when he’s a B grade midfielder at best.

How could anyone be more overrated than "Big game Tex" ?

 

[PhatBoy]

No one "deserves" a flag. They are not participation awards.

Dude, we follow a team that won a comp with mark Blake at ruck

 

[Carson Dial]

Matthew Pavlich.

 

[John Wayne II]

Nathan Jones is an absolute champion. In the Pavlich Class. P