Remove this Banner Ad

Rumour GFC 2018 Player Trading, Drafting, FA, Rumours, and Wish lists - PT4

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Both are more durable than Rohan.

What?!? Rohan is an aggressive player and that is why he may not look so durable but Murdoch and Thurlow haven't shown that sort of aggression and willingness to put themselves in the contest imo! I'd rather have Rohan in a final!
 
What?!? Rohan is an aggressive player and that is why he may not look so durable but Murdoch and Thurlow haven't shown that sort of aggression and willingness to put themselves in the contest imo! I'd rather have Rohan in a final!
And yet Murdoch has more tackles in his career than Rohan
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

What?!? Rohan is an aggressive player and that is why he may not look so durable but Murdoch and Thurlow haven't shown that sort of aggression and willingness to put themselves in the contest imo! I'd rather have Rohan in a final!
I am convinced that you are Gary Rohan....
 
What?!? Rohan is an aggressive player and that is why he may not look so durable but Murdoch and Thurlow haven't shown that sort of aggression and willingness to put themselves in the contest imo! I'd rather have Rohan in a final!

Murdoch is about 1,000x more aggressive than Rohan.
 
And yet Murdoch has more tackles in his career than Rohan
They have been playing different roles! Murdoch should have more everything coz he's played most of his career as a midfielder whereas Rohan hasn't!
I am convinced that you are Gary Rohan....
I like him and I think he's a great fit for the Cats!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

And yet Murdoch has more tackles in his career than Rohan
Come on mate, Murdoch has zero talent and even less composure and football nous. Rohan has both in spades.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Apart from the Kelly saga and picking up Dahlhaus/Kreuger/Rohan, are we chasing any other players realistically or is that it?
 
Hey I've been patient with Murdoch and he's had plenty of time to establish himself. He's had flashes of brilliance but too little, too late imo!

That would be because Rohan has pretty much never played as a pressure player, he's either been half back or the 2nd/3rd tall.

Come on mate, Murdoch has zero talent and even less composure and football nous. Rohan has both in spades.

Rohan is completely useless.
giphy.gif
 
Rohan is a poor man's Murdoch.

View attachment 572304
Not really. One was playing on the wing and should be getting 20 touches a game, and the other played deep forward as a 2nd or 3rd tall. Murdoch tries hard but isn’t as talented at Rohan, nor as good a mark, nor as good at kicking, and generally a pretty poor decision maker. Stats can tell whatever story you want to tell... but we all know Murdoch isn’t as good as Rohan
 
Imho Thurlow needs to slim down and horne his skills eg kicking.

Horne probably not the best word to use :moustache: .
I generally like to think of myself as up to date with the young folk and their use of the emojis but I must say the moustached dude is completely lost on me. Little help?
 
Apart from the Kelly saga, are we chasing any other players realistically or is that it?
If Smith goes to Adelaide, maybe Roughead from the Dogs as more ruck cover? Can't see it personally. I think we'll assess how many list spots and picks we have left at end of Trade Period, make decisions on Menzel/Thurlow/Murdoch and then hit the draft hard.
 
Come on mate, Murdoch has zero talent and even less composure and football nous. Rohan has both in spades.

When Murdoch runs into trouble he does completely idiotic things with the ball or gets run down.

Rohan will atleast attempt to get around that player or run straight through them.
Also much better at trying to receive a 1-2, something I wish Murdoch had
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom