Autopsy Round 4, 2020: St.Kilda v Richmond *MADDIE'S MATCH*

[Winmar2Lockett]

blasphemy! How dare anyone question the selection of the dual best and fairest!

We all see the game differently but I do wonder why Seb is a protected species on here.

The panicked hand pass over his head when he had two options to give it to on our side of the contest was atrocious.

Anyway, super win, a win full of character after last week’s meek capitulation.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Munga]

3. Butler
2. Carlisle
1. Steele

I laughed at SEN's rolling AA team this week, no mention of Butler. He's been BOG a few times already and impacted every game so far, clearly AA atm.

 

[saintskit]

Not enough love for Steele on here, he was great

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

I'm no Ross defender mate.

Far from it, but I can admit when someone has done well.

No need for the champ call cobba.

fair, but the champ call cam with a ?

I will say, kent made me eat my words, even if I was ripping into him after his first touch/dropped mark turnover kick

 

[Remboy]

Can someone make the pick 10 for Clark, Long and Battle thread a sticky. I think we’ll be grateful for that one for a while.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

We all see the game differently but I do wonder why Seb is a protected species on here.

The panicked hand pass over his head when he had two options to give it to on our side of the contest was atrocious.

Anyway, super win, a win full of character after last week’s meek capitulation.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

yeah that one really hurt

 

[SaintersUnite]

Imagine comfortable beating the Premiers and your fan base is still bickering amongst themselves, couldn’t be us right guys?!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[theprospect]

- Personally not a fan of Marsh however the team balance today was spot on

- Butler recruit of the year, and in AA form

- Battle back in

- Marshall back to his best role, FT#1 ruck

- Membrey finding form

Been a great day. Only negative I can think of is having to put up with ******* Liverpool supporters everywhere

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

Imagine comfortable beating the Premiers and your fan base is still bickering amongst themselves, couldn’t be us right guys?!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

I prefer to save my positivity for IRL interactions, personally

 

[ScrappyDo]

He did an outstanding job on Martin.

Sooo, Ross becomes the tagger and Steele goes on ball?
I can deal with that for a while..

 

[Crusty Undies]

Amazing we get flogged by the Pies who couldn't beat the Tigers.
We gave away around 4 goals through stupid mistakes - Wilkies handball , Marshall 50m etc

We just need to see how our injuries are for next week.

The Marshall one wasn't a mistake, he clearly touched the ball and went to lay a tackle afterwards.

 

[NextYearPlease]

I've never heard of anyone missing with a black eye.

Surely next week Geary comes back and it is going to miss out - we could be without Gresham and Jones next week - they are big losses.

On SM-T290 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[kernelT]

Marshall was better playing on his own today but... I don’t think he’s “the third best ruckman in the league” yet that often gets posted here. Nankervis had his measure today, he still has plenty to work on. Exciting talent though and nice to be consistently competitive in ruck duels throughout a game.

Jones still does my head in even when he’s playing well, think he’s going to be one of those frustrating players that does great things and then sprays kicks undoing something amazing.

 

[plugger66]

We all see the game differently but I do wonder why Seb is a protected species on here.

The panicked hand pass over his head when he had two options to give it to on our side of the contest was atrocious.

Anyway, super win, a win full of character after last week’s meek capitulation.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Ross isn’t a great player Never been a favourite of mine but the difference is people who don’t rate him have him going from a top 5 player to outside the 22 which is absolute crap. He is clearly in the 22 and by some margin.

 

[Munga]

We'd be 2nd now if we didn't cough up the Kangas match

 

[Curunir]

I much prefer Ross playing the defensive mid role rather then Steele - I think Steele offers more offensively tbh

 

[plugger66]

Marshall was better playing on his own today but... I don’t think he’s “the third best ruckman in the league” yet that often gets posted here. Nankervis had his measure today, he still has plenty to work on. Exciting talent though and nice to be consistently competitive in ruck duels throughout a game.

Jones still does my head in even when he’s playing well, think he’s going to be one of those frustrating players that does great things and then sprays kicks undoing something amazing.

Marshall was beaten today for sure but he was still in our top 6 players. And more importantly because a better more mobile player was forward. That was the big difference imo. Might be a coincidence that membery played well or maybe not. Who would know.

 

[Sheepey]

Just watched Ratten's presser. Apprently Jones was experiencing tightness but they don't think he has torn anything. Will go in for scans this week but he "might be available for next week".

 

[Remboy]

Marshall was beaten today for sure but he was still in our top 6 players. And more importantly because a better more mobile player was forward. That was the big difference imo. Might be a coincidence that membery played well or maybe not. Who would know.

You should have said something earlier in the year.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

Ross isn’t a great player Never been a favourite of mine but the difference is people who don’t rate him have him going from a top 5 player to outside the 22 which is absolute crap. He is clearly in the 22 and by some margin.

I disagree. I don't think he was 'some margin' better than any other saint tonight.. could you name me one player he was 'some margin' better than tonight?

 

[Crusty Undies]

Josh bruce cringes

and tom lynch

 

[plugger66]

I disagree. I don't think he was 'some margin' better than any other saint tonight.. could you name me one player he was 'some margin' better than tonight?

Surely you aren’t one of those idiots supporters who work in one game blocks

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

Surely you aren’t one of those idiots supporters who work in one game blocks

yeah that's fair, just thought you might have had one

 

[sainterryan]

We'd be 2nd now if we didn't cough up the Kangas match

I’m dreading that loss coming back to bite us at the end of season

 

[kernelT]

yeah that's fair, just thought you might have had one

Regardless of how you rate Ross generally, I think it's better to see him playing to his strengths… his primary role was to blanket a couple of A grade midfielders which he did a very good job of, plus he had some influence with the footy with 16 touches, 4 i50's, 3 clearances - similar numbers as Martin.

Better than him running around half back where we have far better options and users of the footy.