Autopsy 1 point Heart stopper against Adelaide.
- Thread starter Heeney2Franklin
- Start date
- Tagged users None
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Worth a gamble doubt it’s successful but we almost have to roll the dice
- Thread starter
- #680
Kosi Pickett got 2 weeks for torpeding himself into a opposition head.
Feels spiteful tbh
Well won the game despite playing for half the game. To avoid sending us all to a early grave, is it possible they actually play out a full game instead of this trying to defend a lead crap?
The star on the rise that is Gulden continues to rise, 30 disposals and 5 tackles. Mills doing another good tagging job , this time on the lying rodent Dawson, holding him to 19 disposals.
The star on the rise that is Gulden continues to rise, 30 disposals and 5 tackles. Mills doing another good tagging job , this time on the lying rodent Dawson, holding him to 19 disposals.
Legit question. Can someone explain the high contact and high impact grading???
I get the high contact (head) but high impact (or potential to have high impact ) if that is always high for a high contact why even have the category???
Essentially the question is - can you get high contact and medium impact grading?
I get the high contact (head) but high impact (or potential to have high impact ) if that is always high for a high contact why even have the category???
Essentially the question is - can you get high contact and medium impact grading?
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
About on par with what’s been given all season. Thought he’d be lucky to get only 1 with the impact
Dubai Quacker
Wily Old Campaigner
Just get Sir Dane to present the case.
McCartin will be exonerated with the humble apologies of the court.
- Nov 11, 2012
- 35,234
- 41,458
- AFL Club
- Sydney
He won’t get off that unfortunately
- Oct 2, 2016
- 11,322
- 23,306
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Not if we appeal before our luck runs out
grimlock
Hall of Famer
The impact is usually dependent on the opposing team’s medical report. Although they didn’t do an HIA on him, wouldn’t surprise me if they reported McAdam showing delayed concussion
kickthething
Brownlow Medallist
McCartin will be reduced to 1. How is it considered High Impact, just wait for the delayed concussion to come along. Medium impact at best….player had no resulting effects. Set up to be 1 week on appeal.
The bloke is stretched out on the turf and they don't do a HIA. Srsly?
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Depends on the medical report if there are delayed concussion signs no way it’s not high
- Apr 17, 2010
- 7,337
- 10,121
- AFL Club
- Sydney
So yes and no.
The incident is assessed. Mro sees where the contact is made and judges the severity of the impact (low medium high severe). However they may adjust the grading up one degree depending on what type of incident it is.
Sling or dangerous tackles have been graded Medium/ high despite the player being tackled not being injured. The other one is raised elbows are never graded Low to discourage players from pointing their elbows, which is why Wicks copped two weeks for his elbow despite the impact being negligible.
For this collision to be graded high is farcical.
It will get downgraded. Will still likely get a week. They should argue on two points. The change of direction of McCartin towards the ball prior to impact meaning he is actively avoiding a collision. The second will be on the call of high impact. There is no way this can be graded as high impact based on precedence. Look at the sling tackle that was graded as medium impact this week in the Geelong game. Much more forceful impact to the head. I’d not only be challenging but also demanding for a written explanation from Christian as to how he differentiated the two. The man is a biased ****wit.
Cadsky
❤️ Mila ❤️ Alyssa ❤️
2 weeks was always going to be the case. This is the afl leveling the playing field after last night's shenanigans
Gulden made a lot of mistakes last night. Wasn't one of his best by any means. The raw disposal figures can be and often are misleading.
- Oct 2, 2016
- 11,322
- 23,306
- AFL Club
- Sydney
I swear there was another angle shown and McCartin doesn't get his head
kickthething
Brownlow Medallist
I think there is plenty of grounds here, McCartin follows the path of the ball, its an unavoidable collision, the high impact is what it is…this is a 1 weeker every day of the week. Christian once again blinks.
kickthething
Brownlow Medallist
It’s because the impact was not serious…Drs would have reviewed over and again on the bench and still chose to do nothing, because impact was low.
Sir Dane Rampe the lawyer, come on down to help McCartin out 
Similar threads
