Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft - Champs Edition

Should We Look To Win Next 2 Games


  • Total voters
    96
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

we really need norf to (continue to) suck and wce to not get a prio/compo pick because there's legit only sharp/duursma/greeves that have really put their hands up so far

Sharp is clear no.1. No one else is close to his work rate and intensity. You feel him looming large over every game SA played.
 
we should 100% be bidding on Zeke Uwland and Dylan Patterson, they are the only players that i'd want to draft. Greeves is proabbly the best candidate and ticks the most boxes but not in love with him. I'm very weary on Sharp, I just feel like he is a redundant archetype, exacerbated by the current midfielders on our list
 
was the one to beat since last year but no one has come close even though his senior sanfl form hasn't been that great this year due to his role there but he's a level above u18s

Greeves is probably closest, but as Barnzy said, his defensive application is lackig, especially compared to Sharp who has had some special defensive efforts in champs.

Duursma is next but just isn't the midfielder either of the above two are. Brilliant overhead and beautiful mover.

Then its meh. Cumming, Marsh and Barker (shattered about his possible acl) are far more interesting then Grlj, Lindsay, CDT, Fred etc... IMO
 
Hotton is making things interesting. Looks a bonafide midfielder rather than a Bolton pinch hitter. Let's see what he's got at top level and our needs may be different.
Hotton's transition game particularly offensively looks like exactly what we're after from his VFL stints. He charges to the next contest and is often there to crumb having just previously been at the last contest. And then how often has he bobbed up between the arcs as an outlet. I'm not sure he will spend much time charging into D50 though as he seems to be more mid/forward.
 
Hotton's transition game particularly offensively looks like exactly what we're after from his VFL stints. He charges to the next contest and is often there to crumb having just previously been at the last contest. And then how often has he bobbed up between the arcs as an outlet. I'm not sure he will spend much time charging into D50 though as he seems to be more mid/forward.
Makes Sharp the best fit for our midfield for mine.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I’m a no on Lindsay for one of our picks. Not seeing the potential as a mid, doesn’t win enough of his own footy to warrant midfield minutes.
Also plays the easiest position in the game to find a replacement for.
 
YesMakes Sharp the best fit for our midfield for mine.
Finally my boy, finally.

Napoleon Dynamite Reaction GIF
 
I’m a no on Lindsay for one of our picks. Not seeing the potential as a mid, doesn’t win enough of his own footy to warrant midfield minutes.
Also plays the easiest position in the game to find a replacement for.
Better kicking Short. Would give it 3 games into his second season for the pile on to begin. A shame as we need someone to help Banks.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Greeves is probably closest, but as Barnzy said, his defensive application is lackig, especially compared to Sharp who has had some special defensive efforts in champs.

Duursma is next but just isn't the midfielder either of the above two are. Brilliant overhead and beautiful mover.

Then its meh. Cumming, Marsh and Barker (shattered about his possible acl) are far more interesting then Grlj, Lindsay, CDT, Fred etc... IMO

It's what so many complain about with our current inside mids. They let players waltz it out of the contest with no pressure. Greeves is flat footed around the contest unless he's a chance to get the ball.

Sharp over Greeves for me and quite easily. Right now based off that game I'm also taking the risk with Duursma due to athleticism over Greeves and hope you get his ball use to manageable state. It's not like Greeves is an amazing ball user anyways. He's just okay.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top