Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft - Champs Edition

Should We Look To Win Next 2 Games


  • Total voters
    96
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Greeves 27 disposals (13k 14hb) 6 marks 1 tackle 2 clearances 10 contested possessions 63% 1 goal

Fred 23 disposals (12k 11hb) 3 marks 6 tackles 8 clearances 10 contested possessions 65.2%

Dalton 23 disposals (8k 15hb) 5 marks 4 tackles 1 clearance 10 contested possessions 65.2%

Swadling 20 disposals (8k 12hb) 3 marks 3 tackles 3 clearances 7 contested possessions 65% 1.1

Dovaston 18 disposals (9k 9hb) 1 mark 3 tackles 2 clearances 10 contested possessions 55.6% 2.3

Grjl 17 disposals (9k 8hb) 3 marks 2 tackles 2 clearances 3 contested possessions 64.7% 1 goal

Emmett 16 disposals (4k 12hb) 3 marks 1 tackle 3 clearances 6 contested possessions 81.3% 1 goal 11 hitouts

Burton 16 disposals (9k 7hb) 6 marks 1 tackle 81.3%

CDT 15 disposals (5k 10hb) 3 marks 2 tackles 2 clearances 8 contested possessions 40% 18 hitouts
 
Sharp is clear no.1. No one else is close to his work rate and intensity. You feel him looming large over every game SA played.
I haven’t watched a lot u18s this year, but appears that after a slowish start to the season, he’s stepped it up when it counts. If he finishes off the season with a strong SANFL showing how can we not take him.
 
I’m a no on Lindsay for one of our picks. Not seeing the potential as a mid, doesn’t win enough of his own footy to warrant midfield minutes.
Also plays the easiest position in the game to find a replacement for.

I like him but he'd be the ideal type of pick at 8-15.

Agreed it's one of the easier positions to play but one we are currently lacking.
I find Lindsay will translate similar to someone in the back half like Salem or Houli but definitely can't see him making it as a mid at AFL level but that's ok if he's great at distributing the ball from D50 and he will build a solid career around this.

People might melt over the comparisons but Salem is closing on 200 games, Houli ended up with 232 so they are long, productive careers just not the A Graders we all crave for with a pick inside the top 5.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Greeves 27 disposals (13k 14hb) 6 marks 1 tackle 2 clearances 10 contested possessions 63% 1 goal

Fred 23 disposals (12k 11hb) 3 marks 6 tackles 8 clearances 10 contested possessions 65.2%

Dalton 23 disposals (8k 15hb) 5 marks 4 tackles 1 clearance 10 contested possessions 65.2%

Swadling 20 disposals (8k 12hb) 3 marks 3 tackles 3 clearances 7 contested possessions 65% 1.1

Dovaston 18 disposals (9k 9hb) 1 mark 3 tackles 2 clearances 10 contested possessions 55.6% 2.3

Grjl 17 disposals (9k 8hb) 3 marks 2 tackles 2 clearances 3 contested possessions 64.7% 1 goal

Emmett 16 disposals (4k 12hb) 3 marks 1 tackle 3 clearances 6 contested possessions 81.3% 1 goal 11 hitouts

Burton 16 disposals (9k 7hb) 6 marks 1 tackle 81.3%

CDT 15 disposals (5k 10hb) 3 marks 2 tackles 2 clearances 8 contested possessions 40% 18 hitouts

In fairness to all of these guys with their DE.
It was absolutely blowing a gale which completely ruins the foot skills of a typical game.

Didn't watch it but like Rodriguez's stats there, 8 clearances (game high), 6 tackles (third best on the field) to go with 23 disposals. Doesn't appear to be a huge accumulator but more of a high impact player.
 
Greeves 27 disposals (13k 14hb) 6 marks 1 tackle 2 clearances 10 contested possessions 63% 1 goal

Fred 23 disposals (12k 11hb) 3 marks 6 tackles 8 clearances 10 contested possessions 65.2%

Dalton 23 disposals (8k 15hb) 5 marks 4 tackles 1 clearance 10 contested possessions 65.2%

Swadling 20 disposals (8k 12hb) 3 marks 3 tackles 3 clearances 7 contested possessions 65% 1.1

Dovaston 18 disposals (9k 9hb) 1 mark 3 tackles 2 clearances 10 contested possessions 55.6% 2.3

Grjl 17 disposals (9k 8hb) 3 marks 2 tackles 2 clearances 3 contested possessions 64.7% 1 goal

Emmett 16 disposals (4k 12hb) 3 marks 1 tackle 3 clearances 6 contested possessions 81.3% 1 goal 11 hitouts

Burton 16 disposals (9k 7hb) 6 marks 1 tackle 81.3%

CDT 15 disposals (5k 10hb) 3 marks 2 tackles 2 clearances 8 contested possessions 40% 18 hitouts
Grije 3 contested possessions playing as an inside mid is a huge red flag imo.

I'm worried he's going to struggle to win his own ball at AFL level.
 
In fairness to all of these guys with their DE.
It was absolutely blowing a gale which completely ruins the foot skills of a typical game.

Didn't watch it but like Rodriguez's stats there, 8 clearances (game high), 6 tackles (third best on the field) to go with 23 disposals. Doesn't appear to be a huge accumulator but more of a high impact player.
WA didn't have a very good game but for rodriguez to have 0 score involvements... (WA had 17 scores)
 
WA didn't have a very good game but for rodriguez to have 0 score involvements... (WA had 17 scores)

Far out that's crazy. Just double checked had 4 i50's & 10 contested possession so must've played in tight more.

Vs Vic Country in Perth he had a game high 8 score involvements so it's a complete contrast to that one.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Greeves was among the best for Vic Metro in a strong win travelling away against WA to get their Champs campaign back on track. Greeves is incredibly consistent and dependable with his attacking output and again found plenty of the footy. The extremely windy conditions made precise ball use difficult, but he was fairly efficient and attacking with his decision making. He's a regular goal scorer from midfield and again chipped in, but some of his pressure around the contest was lacking at times.

 
I don’t see CDT that far ahead of Emmett personally and if we really wanted a ruckman we can always trade our second rounder again to get back into the late first round to snag him.
Hes pretty short, monster tank though, will go all day. There are rucks next year too that are proper size. Or wait and target one when we have a better idea what they can do. Dodson was last years basketball ruckman and they're about to land TDK. He may be gettable soon.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I’m feeling anxious about the draft and who we will select with our early picks …. I will continue to analyse the games and performances in the meantime
Let us know once you're sure. Will give us all comfort.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top