List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion

[phantom13]

Lovin the port lurkers in here pissing their panties about the whole deal.

It’s adorable

 

[SainterinSydney]

From Port board

 

[stavro#4]

Lovin the port lurkers in here pissing their panties about the whole deal.

It’s adorable

A few starting to wise up to Butters for Nas as more appropriate value

 

[billings2paddy]

A few starting to wise up to Butters for Nas as more appropriate value

NAS value is increasing by the week

 

[akaifu]

NAS value is increasing by the week

Exactly, so why would he re-sign right now?

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Exactly, so why would he re-sign right now?

cLuB jUst NeEdS tO SiGN HiM!

 

[mighty_sainters]

cLuB jUst NeEdS tO SiGN HiM!

Offer him the TDK money.

 

[jwikked]

Offer him the TDK money.

offer him the rumoured Harley Reid deal lol. It'd be nice to have both, but I'd take NWM every day of the week.

 

[stavro#4]

Exactly, so why would he re-sign right now?

We offered him a deal a few weeks back.

 

[PJays]

Offer him the TDK money.

Crazy to think St Kildas lost 6 in a row but have one of the best players in the comp.

It tells you how bad we'd be without him

Vs Collingwood he was in discussion for BOG. Definitely top 3 or 4

Vs Hawthorn he was BOG with daylight 2nd

And again today. Daylight 2nd

That's 2 of the main premiership contenders... plus a finalist in Hawthorn. He's killing everyone.

Yet we're still losing.

With him on board and more development into Pou, Tauru, Travaglia, Garcia, Hall, Caminiti.... and a healthy King, and our future is bright. Many of these competitive losses against good teams become wins.

But Nas is the key that unlocks everything.

TDK isn't in the same league.

 

[Linton Street Saint]

Offer him the TDK money.

How hard is it for people to understand that it's not about money at all.
You're not giving TDK money for 2 years and if you think he hasn't been offered essentially a blank cheque for a long term contract then there isn't much left to say.

 

[botts]

View attachment 2372811

From Port board

Looking forward to getting butters the other way then

 

[Captain Paddy]

How in the hell did someone in control think up the Max King contract , and now the TDK offer ? I believe we may have also upped the Josh Battle offer at the last minute too , like absolute amateurs. Withdraw the irresponsible TDK offer , find a Meek , Sweet type “cheap as chips” ruckman. Offer NWM 200,000 more than the others , and go get a youngish gun midfielder with our splash cash.

TDK offer is essentially pick purchasing.

$1m to TDK + $700-$800k Marshall is on.

In TDK and First rounder

Out Marshall

 

[Captain Paddy]

I know he can be a divisive topic, but what are we going to do about Brad Hill?

Just horrifically out of touch, constantly avoids any potential contact and his decision making and ball use has been average at best.

Had a hand in 3 out of Geelongs first 4 goals today.

I know he is an OG Ross boy, but Ross might have the rose coloured on with Hill

 

[PJays]

In TDK and First rounder

It's absurd that people on this board call you crazy for questioning what's been reported in every media source umpteen times (that TDK's being offered significantly more $$$ than NAS)

Yet people seem to think we'll get a 1st rounder for Marshall.

Very unlikely.

 

[Captain Paddy]

It's absurd that people on this board call you crazy for questioning what's been reported in every media source umpteen times (that TDK's being offered significantly more $$$ than NAS)

Yet people seem to think we'll get a 1st rounder for Marshall.

Very unlikely.

I doubt the club would let him go for less tbh

 

[akaifu]

It's absurd that people on this board call you crazy for questioning what's been reported in every media source umpteen times (that TDK's being offered significantly more $$$ than NAS)

Yet people seem to think we'll get a 1st rounder for Marshall.

Very unlikely.

How is it unlikely in a weak draft and with the current ruck merry-go-round set to occur? Crows & Cats with perfect picks to swap for Marshall given they are in the window and need a ready-made ruck replacement. Marshall also contracted - we have all the leverage

 

[my name was taken]

offer him the rumoured Harley Reid deal lol. It'd be nice to have both, but I'd take NWM every day of the week.

Fun fact: if we snag Reid and keep Marshall instead of TDK we would have #1 and #2 in frees against in the league. GameDay threads will be amazing

 

[mighty_sainters]

How hard is it for people to understand that it's not about money at all.
You're not giving TDK money for 2 years and if you think he hasn't been offered essentially a blank cheque for a long term contract then there isn't much left to say.

Sorry my fault, was being totally sarcastic.

 

[Parkysp]

I8

I know he can be a divisive topic, but what are we going to do about Brad Hill?

Just horrifically out of touch, constantly avoids any potential contact and his decision making and ball use has been average at best.

Had a hand in 3 out of Geelongs first 4 goals today.

I know he is an OG Ross boy, but Ross might have the rose coloured on with Hill

His last quarter was horrific. How Wilson was subbed when he was at least getting to contests and applying pressure I don't understand.

 

[Captain Paddy]

Am I crazy for thinking Nas is a brownlow smokey?

Was at $501 just a few weeks ago, no one in the media really even mentions him as a chance (but as we no most of them don't actually watch us - go see all the comments about the current list being the same as what Ratts had)

Nas is putting up some absurb numbers, plays a style that is eye catching and we really don't have many people to take votes off him.

We've (hopefully) got 4 more wins to come (Melb, North, Rich & Essendon)

That would give us 9.

Some of the standout games this year
R2 v Geelong - 29 disps
R3 v Rich - 29 disps
R4 v Port - 25 & 1 goal
R5 v GWS - 24 & 3 goals
R7 v Bris - 32 & 1 goal
R8 v Freo - 28
R9 v Carl 30 disps
R11 v Suns - 36 & a goal
R12 v Melb - 29 disps
R15 v Pies - 35 disps
R16 v Freo - 28 & 1 goal
R17 v Haw - 43 1000m
R19 v Geel - 36 & 2 goals

Could come home with a wet sail over the next 5 weeks

 

[Linton Street Saint]

Sorry my fault, was being totally sarcastic.

Fair enough all good, all the bed wetting makes for soggy reading

 

[Browny2Carlisle]

Am I crazy for thinking Nas is a brownlow smokey?

Was at $501 just a few weeks ago, no one in the media really even mentions him as a chance (but as we no most of them don't actually watch us - go see all the comments about the current list being the same as what Ratts had)

Nas is putting up some absurb numbers, plays a style that is eye catching and we really don't have many people to take votes off him.

We've (hopefully) got 4 more wins to come (Melb, North, Rich & Essendon)

That would give us 9.

Some of the standout games this year
R2 v Geelong - 29 disps
R3 v Rich - 29 disps
R4 v Port - 25 & 1 goal
R5 v GWS - 24 & 3 goals
R7 v Bris - 32 & 1 goal
R8 v Freo - 28
R9 v Carl 30 disps
R11 v Suns - 36 & a goal
R12 v Melb - 29 disps
R15 v Pies - 35 disps
R16 v Freo - 28 & 1 goal
R17 v Haw - 43 1000m
R19 v Geel - 36 & 2 goals

Could come home with a wet sail over the next 5 weeks

No chance. Umpires pick their favourite darlings. Probs be 3 votes P Dangerfield this game.

 

[Minga]

Am I crazy for thinking Nas is a brownlow smokey?

Was at $501 just a few weeks ago, no one in the media really even mentions him as a chance (but as we no most of them don't actually watch us - go see all the comments about the current list being the same as what Ratts had)

Nas is putting up some absurb numbers, plays a style that is eye catching and we really don't have many people to take votes off him.

We've (hopefully) got 4 more wins to come (Melb, North, Rich & Essendon)

That would give us 9.

Some of the standout games this year
R2 v Geelong - 29 disps
R3 v Rich - 29 disps
R4 v Port - 25 & 1 goal
R5 v GWS - 24 & 3 goals
R7 v Bris - 32 & 1 goal
R8 v Freo - 28
R9 v Carl 30 disps
R11 v Suns - 36 & a goal
R12 v Melb - 29 disps
R15 v Pies - 35 disps
R16 v Freo - 28 & 1 goal
R17 v Haw - 43 1000m
R19 v Geel - 36 & 2 goals

Could come home with a wet sail over the next 5 weeks

Very hard to win it if you’re not on a team with a winning ledger. I guess it’s possible he’d be in the mix.

 

[stavro#4]

Anyone catch the last question Ross was asked in his presser? Couldn’t make it out.

Answered with a. Smile and “in the fullness of time”