List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[Fehring]

Did some sleuthing and Jayden definitely played with Terry Milera:

https://safootballer.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/SA-Adelaide-Footballer-Magazine-2022-18.pdf

View attachment 2397201

I am very impressed with your work, and also very concerned for your mental health (and frankly all of ours)

 

[Fehring]

Which is why the shit on here is ridiculous
This signing or any other big news is not being released on Bigfooty

I hadn’t been on this forum in probably 10+ years. Wandered back with this Nas stuff and have promptly realised why I left.

We all need to get a grip and get out in the world. I’ve spent more minutes than I ever needed to on this topic.

Good luck to all. The sun will rise tomorrow and none of this matters cos we will all be dead one day. Log off and when the announcement is done, react as you see fit then. Pointless going around in circles now.

It's good to see a familiar old name! I hear you - not much has changed, though most of the old annoying characters have been replaced by new annoying characters! I still hang around though. Lots of good people on here as well, and I mostly lurk and stay out of fights.

 

[Yawkey way]

We are all passionate supporters. The forum is designed for healthy discourse including negative views. Everyone should be allowed to express their views within rules.

I've just taken the positive view on the Nas situation as all the evidence points that way.
But hey, he still might leave.

Big picture is stay or go the club will go on.

A couple of years along with a few summers in the gym, I’m sure Tauru and others will be thrilling crowds and putting bums on seats.

 

[Captain Paddy]

So who is the real troll?

Is it:



Or is it Leigh Montagna?

Takes up Aussie Rules at a young age, enters the 2001 AFL Draft in the hope the Saints select him, plays out a 16 year career at St Kilda before he manages to get a role in the media knowing that in 2025 the Saints will be trying to retain the most exciting talent in the competition and allowing him the opportunity to troll the Saints fans and in particular SainterinSydney ?

Close contest

That’s not what I was referring to but go off spaceman

 

[Sully111]

Is positivity on Bigfooty not allowed?

I hope he has the energy to get all the way from here until the end of trade week with this enthusiasm

It was tongue in cheek boss

 

[Captain Paddy]

View attachment 2397546

“That’s Photoshop” - Saints Bigfoot, probably

 

[Sully111]

View attachment 2397546

FMD

 

[stavro#4]

“That’s Photoshop” - Saints Bigfoot, probably

They are real.

Another few more floating about.

Everyone had the same idea yesterday.

Strangely I feel safe in the words of our little Italian meatball

 

[Darrian Barnett]

View attachment 2397546

Someone tell me this is real

 

[Molly29]

He’s a promising tall nothing else.

Also don’t want Moraes, didn’t like him in the draft and still don’t.

Whitlock may be steak knives, that's it

 

[Diehard Saint]

I did absolutely nothing different to every other single person on here that has tried to tell people that they have information or news… that was the entire point.

No one knows anything so anyone on here trying to convince you otherwise is just full of sh*t

But why do it?
What is the point?
Wouldn’t even cross my mind to do it - no matter what other people are doing.
We all know it’s an emotive time.
But whatever.

 

[SainterinSydney]

They are real.

Another few more floating about.

Everyone had the same idea yesterday.

Strangely I feel safe in the words of our little Italian meatball

They are real and are in line with what he said on the radio.

 

[stavro#4]

They are real and are in line with what he said on the radio.

And you know what. Good on him for taking time to reply to fans.

 

[BrutThough]

Yes he really is, maybe watch more of Aleer.

Shoenmaker needs to find some desperation and physicality but he can play football, his stats are actually pretty good, meters gained etc.

In 3 weeks of football aleer’s best stat for metres gained is less than 1 Shoenmaker drop punt. Older, smaller, no idea, can’t kick but hell 5 years on good coin, why not right.

If I thought he could play I’d be cheering on the chase but this is just plain crazy imo. It also brings into question the competence of the people making these decisions which is a huge worry.

Your argument is struggling if the only stat you only have to prove your point is meters gained.

 

[stavro#4]

I love that people have Aleer penciled in to our starting 22.

I watched that game yesterday and it was Aleer’s best in 3 weeks and he was still a liability. 7 touches, 12m gained in 92% game time. Shoenmaker is so far ahead of this guy is laughable and has a generational left peg that a better club would have figured out how to use.

The best result for us is to loose interest in Aleer and let someone else step up. If GWS get a second for him it will be something they laugh about over beers for years to come.

I’ve now seen over half of his games including the last 3 appalling weeks, he can’t play afl standard football.

Look slightly off topic to this conversation. But There is very little statistically between Aleer and Mac Andrew.

People would be very excited if we had Mac. So if Aleer could be a B grade version. I think he’ll be okay.

 

[stavro#4]

wolfpac13 might aswell post yours mate.

 

[Captain Paddy]

So who is the real troll?

Is it:



Or is it Leigh Montagna?

Takes up Aussie Rules at a young age, enters the 2001 AFL Draft in the hope the Saints select him, plays out a 16 year career at St Kilda before he manages to get a role in the media knowing that in 2025 the Saints will be trying to retain the most exciting talent in the competition and allowing him the opportunity to troll the Saints fans and in particular SainterinSydney ?

Close contest

View attachment 2397546

If Nas leaves we'll have our answer Dr Spaceman

 

[Train12]

And you know what. Good on him for taking time to reply to fans.

100% he knows the pain we as supporters go through

 

[stavro#4]

100% he knows the pain we as supporters go through

Let’s be honest. He absolutely DOES NOT have to engage with the fanbase or feel the need to try and cheer us up.

He also went big with this info on Friday night.

Does it mean anything categorically? No

But if you wanted to believe in someone - you probably won’t find a better source of comfort.

 

[Heavensent]

NWM is so gone. Best to accept it and focus on whit kind of bounty we can get for him by way of trade. If by some miracle he does decide to stay then consider it an unexpected bonus

 

[beside the seaside]

With Aleer it's worth remembering it would be coming from Lyon, Enright and Rivers. They're the ones that want him.

 

[Train12]

Let’s be honest. He absolutely DOES NOT have to engage with the fanbase or feel the need to try and cheer us up.

He also went big with this info on Friday night.

Does it mean anything categorically? No

But if you wanted to believe in someone - you probably won’t find a better source of comfort.

He would still be close to Roo and Ross, where he gets his information.

 

[unrelentingbelief]

Say what you want about how we’re winning against the bottom teams but I wouldn’t discount the emotional effect of the singing the song so many times before the end of the season. Got to have somewhat of positive binding effect on the group. Love to see the Ws

 

[Heavensent]

It's funny, I was more confident in our future prior to our 4 game winning steak

It’s likely the most underwhelming 4 game win streak in AFL history

 

[white knuckler]

Look slightly off topic to this conversation. But There is very little statistically between Aleer and Mac Andrew.

People would be very excited if we had Mac. So if Aleer could be a B grade version. I think he’ll be okay.

Ross has a habit of turning b grade defenders into a graders