Autopsy AFL 2025 Rd 24 - Lions v Hawks - Sun August 24th 7:20pm AEST (Gabba)

[Dewyyyyy]

Take away Lewis goal and we further on front, ‘you have never player footy’ he says to some bloke on the internet. My god- least you’re consistent with your rubbish in all threads.

Lewis was hit front on and in the head, “take it away” tho right?

And if you can’t understand game situation having a more significant impact depending on umpiring calls, you are missing something entirely.

 

[Dewyyyyy]

ah ah . . . Razor said! Game Over

Well he said:

Doesn’t like the rule

Andrew’s was insufficient and should’ve been paid and wasnt

Amon’s the same but was, his question was do you believe it was a skill error, which is obviously a yes, Ray reckons no.

My point to him would be do you not see him being

• off balance
• back pedalling
• ball coming off the wrong part of the hand and almost missed his hand

The other question I’d have is if he was going to do it on purpose I’m sure he wouldn’t of been dumb enough to put it on the full, he would’ve done what Andrews did infront of Ginnivan further out near the boundary. He didn’t because he was trying to get the ball to his two free teammates.

The rule says sufficient intent and he’s made sufficient intent by trying to hit Ginnivan and CMac who are both open, skill error and out.

Bigger issue is as Ray raises, the rule itself sucks anyway.

 

[bungalow_bill]

A few Hawks fans taking this loss quite badly. Coming to terms with the fact that their team is very ordinary.

 

[Dewyyyyy]

A few Hawks fans taking this loss quite badly. Coming to terms with the fact that their team is very ordinary.

Interesting that’s how you take it, says more about you.

 

[57 Milner]

Yeah, insufficient intent every day of the week for that Amon handball. Lucky not to be given 50 for dissent on top of it.

 

[Spudwick]

I posted because what you said just completely baffled me.

Point in case.

 

[Sherrinator]

Are you Amon? Lovely for you to tell us your side of the story.

Either that or you’re bullshitting (obviously).

Anyone with any idea, especially with how Hawthorn play or are most likely to score from that situation. Is a handball chain or kick out of defense. Not a stoppage in Brisbane’s forward 50.

Clearly a skill error that was awfully called.

They are all skill errors in not hiding it to the point it fools the umpire. Ultimately, that handball took the pressure off the Hawks and would’ve allowed them to set up defensive versus getting caught HTB inside 50 or a dump kick which gets intercepted and straight back i50 again.

 

[randyzany]

Funny enough not replayed 50 times in the media besides being a worse decision. Who would have thought.

I seldom watch broadcast TV, stick mostly to the interwebz. Mainly focused on Geelong games and pay secondary attention to non Geelong games, rarely every watch full non-Geelong games. The incident can't be that ubiquitous if you couldn't find a simple link to the footage.

 

[Dewyyyyy]

They are all skill errors in not hiding it to the point it fools the umpire. Ultimately, that handball took the pressure off the Hawks and would’ve allowed them to set up defensive versus getting caught HTB inside 50 or a dump kick which gets intercepted and straight back i50 again.

Assuming HTB as likely is funny considering there were 2 free Hawks players and more ahead of the ball, but you think a defensive stoppage against a damaging and good stoppage side is what Amon wants, funny. Especially since it hit the wrong part of his hand and he almost missed his hand..

 

[jonnobackpocket]

Lewis was hit front on and in the head, “take it away” tho right?

And if you can’t understand game situation having a more significant impact depending on umpiring calls, you are missing something entirely.

You lost to a better side, time to stop tearing up and accept it. Your incessant whining is pathetic.

 

[Dewyyyyy]

You lost to a better side, time to stop tearing up and accept it. Your incessant whining is pathetic.

Hilarious, it’s a talking point out of the game, and when it’s the only thing being spoken about, it gets added onto.

You’re literally whining right now.

Hawthorn lost, weren’t good enough, especially when it mattered, but it was a close and decisive contest.

 

[jonnobackpocket]

Lewis was hit front on and in the head, “take it away” tho right?

And if you can’t understand game situation having a more significant impact depending on umpiring calls, you are missing something entirely.

‘Hit in the head’ ha ha I can make stuff up too.

 

[Dewyyyyy]

‘Hit in the head’ ha ha I can make stuff up too.

Rewatch it and you’ll see it

 

[Chief]

• Are Geelong now the flag favourites?
• Can Brisbane survive without Neale?
• Umpiring: disgraceful or just drama?