Rumour Bluemour Discussion XXXIX

[Aphrodite]

Wants to leave for more opportunities…….

Let me guess ….








Linton St

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Let me guess ….








Linton St

14 year deal……..

 

[RPCB]

LWhitehead & Hogg, Rice & Hanna had the flexibility for matchups too…

I watched the replay of the 1995 QF the other day. And had to replay Dean Rice’s hit on Chris Scott a few times, it looked like Rice barely touched Scott and somehow still knocked him into next week.

 

[macky99]

If we had a fantastic offer from wce would Charlie go to Perth or stay with us?

Doubt he is heading to Perth but WCE pick 2 potentially may be part of the trade probably going to take multiple clubs to be involved.

 

[swuzzlebubble]

Doubt he is heading to Perth but WCE pick 2 potentially may be part of the trade probably going to take multiple clubs to be involved.

Yes but what if we had a deal directly with WCE. Does Charlie refuse or go?

 

[RPCB]

Yes but what if we had a deal directly with WCE. Does Charlie refuse or go?

He refuses. West Coast are the worst AFL team in history. I also seriously doubt that Graham Wright and co would even waste their time coming up with trade packages to get Charlie Curnow to WC.

 

[Foucault1989]

What are we thinking re: Binns? Is he considered not up to afl standard? Or worth persisting with?

 

[macky99]

Yes but what if we had a deal directly with WCE. Does Charlie refuse or go?

l would say no.
Doubt going to WCE would be of interest to him.

 

[woof39]

What are we thinking re: Binns? Is he considered not up to afl standard? Or worth persisting with?

I think he has next to 0 chance of becoming a good player. I get his strength is his outside game and running ability, but he's contested work is not at AFL standard. You still need to have some sort of ability in any contested situation. Maybe I have randomly missed seeing this.

 

[swuzzlebubble]

l would say no.
Doubt going to WCE would be of interest to him.

The quicker they improve increases their chances of keeping Harley longer.

 

[swuzzlebubble]

He refuses. West Coast are the worst AFL team in history. I also seriously doubt that Graham Wright and co would even waste their time coming up with trade packages to get Charlie Curnow to WC.

Pick 2 and their F1 could be quite useful to us for starters

 

[JJBagger]

Pick 2 and their F1 could be quite useful to us for starters

We’ll want an A grade player in return. Otherwise he doesn’t leave

 

[macky99]

We’ll want an A grade player in return. Otherwise he doesn’t leave

l believe the probability is higher gaining a few high draft picks.
l don't see Geelong & Sydney or Gold Coast giving up a A grade player.

 

[BlueTongue]

Isn't it just Hamill? Nothing yet on Hansen, Russell or Clark

Clark is staying, Hansen & Russell should be let go, Hamill made the decision to leave, as did Luke Power.

 

[katmanblue]

l would say no.
Doubt going to WCE would be of interest to him.

Would make a mockery of the doesn't want to play for Voss claim.

 

[Stamos]

l believe the probability is higher gaining a few high draft picks.
l don't see Geelong & Sydney or Gold Coast giving up a A grade player.

I don’t see us trading a contracted superstar for draft picks (especially when we’ve got highly rated FSs the next 2 years).
It would be a shocking look for the club, and significantly increase the pressure on Voss in the last year of his contract.

 

[macky99]

I don’t see us trading a contracted superstar for draft picks (especially when we’ve got highly rated FSs the next 2 years).
It would be a shocking look for the club, and significantly increase the pressure on Voss in the last year of his contract.

l agree but if it also depend on how Wright rates the list, if he is of the view we are a few years away with the right decisions l would not completely dismiss pick 2 involving multiple clubs being considered.

 

[Stamos]

l agree but if it also depend on how Wright rates the list, if he is of the view we are a few years away with the right decisions l would not completely dismiss pick 2 involving multiple clubs being considered.

It would be a massive about face not only on public comments, but on those leaked to the media as well.
It would look terrible, and not be a good way to hold the faith of the members.

 

[macky99]

It would be a massive about face not only on public comments, but on those leaked to the media as well.
It would look terrible, and not be a good way to hold the faith of the members.

lt would seem unlikely but who knows if someone presents a very attractive deal in our favour it may be considered.

 

[GT619]

Clark is staying, Hansen & Russell should be let go, Hamill made the decision to leave, as did Luke Power.

why is clark staying because cripps said so

 

[LanceRomance]

Yes but what if we had a deal directly with WCE. Does Charlie refuse or go?

Cant remember the last time a player that didn't want to be traded interstate, was traded interstate

Maybe our josh kennedy?

 

[swuzzlebubble]

Cant remember the last time a player that didn't want to be traded interstate, was traded interstate

Maybe our josh kennedy?

He's open to Sydney and GC (reportedly).
It comes down to: if he says he wants out and we offer him an out, does he then turn around and say he'd rather stay.

 

[Stamos]

lt would seem unlikely but who knows if someone presents a very attractive deal in our favour it may be considered.

But that’s the thing, a “very attractive deal in our favour” is going to include a gun player as the main part of the trade.
Draft picks are going to be additions, not the main course, or it’s not going to be very attractive.

 

[SurreyBlue]

Clark is staying, Hansen & Russell should be let go, Hamill made the decision to leave, as did Luke Power.

They all should go. However I felt our development was improving with Power. That’s a loss to me.

 

[SolGoodman]

Heat on the Sunny boys now, watch them panic buy for Charlie now.