Rumour Bluemour Discussion XXXIX

[TheBlueCampaigner]

As good a player as May has been, he's getting past his best. But the main thing is, he doesn't fit the no dickhead policy. Can't see anyway we go for him.

Personally couldn’t give a shit if we win a premiership with half a team of dickheads.

 

[4flagsin5yrs]

You’re going around in circles because you’re ignoring my points, and seem to refuse to acknowledge the massive difference between being a free agent and having a 4 year contract.

Better examples of comparison to Curnow than Cameron would be (despite not being KPFs) Petracca and Oliver.
If they were Free Agents last year (like Cameron was), they wouldn’t have been at Melbourne this year.

how'd that go for the Dees?

 

[ITCHY EYEBALLS]

I think May might be necessary.

Take his character out of it, we need another 2nd KPD with losing JSOS and HOF out next year.

Lewis Young/Haynes can't be our 2nd best defender next year, and Harry Dean won't be ready.

You can't take his character out of it.

Look up the term ****wit in the Dictionary, there's a picture of him.

 

[dumb]

Maybe GC, Geelong and Sydney can timeshare Charlie to split the bill. He plays Friday/Thursday night matches at Sydney. Saturday/Sunday matches for the Suns. And all Finals matches for Geelong. Simples.

you're giving the afl honchos ideas

 

[carlton_99]

Very very good defender at his best. And I can see an appeal for us given HOF injury and JSOS moving on. But it's a bit of a tough sell culturally. Just had a lot of moments where he has shown poor leadership on field. Not sure a change in club is going to change that.

 

[goreds]

As good a player as May has been, he's getting past his best. But the main thing is, he doesn't fit the no dickhead policy. Can't see anyway we go for him.

This is so true...

We only want wholesome players that love each other and hug trees during the off season. Model citizens who would self-report if they had more than 5 drinks over a 5-hour period during the off season...

How is that going for us???

This garbage club mentality (one board member) would stop us from recruiting the likes of Toby Greene!

 

[Stamos]

how'd that go for the Dees?

They probably should have traded Oliver (a complete loose cannon off field) last year, even though he improved this year, and Petracca was good.

 

[ITCHY EYEBALLS]

This is so true...

We only want wholesome players that love each other and hug trees during the off season. Model citizens who would self-report if they had more than 5 drinks over a 5-hour period during the off season...

How is that going for us???

This garbage club mentality (one board member) would stop us from recruiting the likes of Toby Greene!

It's what he does when he gets on the piss that's the problem

 

[jj1978]

Actually we are Carlton, pick up May and put him in the leadership group.

 

[SolGoodman]

Pretty sure GW has recruited a dickhead or two in his time as a LM.

If he and Austin see May as a necessity they would absolutely go have a chat I reckon.

 

[The_BigFella]

I’d take May for two years in a heartbeat. He’s obviously a pr*ck, but he absolutely hates losing—and honestly, I wouldn’t mind seeing that mindset instilled in a few of our guys.

 

[goreds]

It's what he does when he gets on the piss that's the problem

I know exactly what he's like and what has been swept under the carpet!

I'm not saying we should pick him up, but I just hate this squeaky-clean attitude to recruiting players. Every quality team has an enforcer type on their books, except us!

 

[RPCB]

Suck shit May

Only if he is sad about it. I reckon he would be thrilled.

 

[morningbrown]

May probably goes to the Bulldogs.

 

[AB_Blue]

May probably goes to the Bulldogs.

Perfect fit for them

I don’t think May and Wietering would work as they are similar players

 

[entitled supporters]

Why are people saying Carlton must give this give that.If they are trading Curnow nothing but Curnow should be going out . Everything should be in Carltons favour there should be no giving of Carlton picks unless they are worthless late rounds

 

[CCurnow3picks]

I completely agree with this sentiment.

The issue is that we’re oversaturated with football programs that prioritize manufactured drama over genuine analysis.

We’re in the middle of finals - the pinnacle of the season - yet most shows are leading with stories about Zach Merrett instead of focusing on the actual football.

Ads-EN made mention of the news cycle ATM - trading & Player movement Monday-Thursday - finals games focus Friday-Sunday.

Media investment/engagement is weighted to player movement - even in PF week!

 

[Michael Jezz]

If May is fit, premiership player in a position of need. Lose Weitering we only win 7-10 games.
Weitering and May fit & a few things go right, maybe we sneak into the 8.
May is a very good footballer
I would risk a 2 year deal but do the research

 

[Magruder]

Ethan Phillips is a safer bet.

and a better human

 

[Michael Jezz]

and a better human

If the game was played off the field- Ethan Phillips.
Onfield- Stephen May by a mile

 

[HereComesJuddy]

If May is fit, premiership player in a position of need. Lose Weitering we only win 7-10 games.
Weitering and May fit & a few things go right, maybe we sneak into the 8.
May is a very good footballer
I would risk a 2 year deal but do the research

Lose Weitering and we win 7-10 games?

He played all 23 this year and we won 9.

 

[agro]

Ethan Phillips is a safer bet.

For any forward that plays against him.

 

[swuzzlebubble]

I think May might be necessary.

Take his character out of it, we need another 2nd KPD with losing JSOS and HOF out next year.

Lewis Young/Haynes can't be our 2nd best defender next year, and Harry Dean won't be ready.

Push for Ballard in the CC deal if he goes to GC

 

[Gavstar]

Actually we are Carlton, pick up May and put him in the leadership group.

And believe we can turn him into an elite forward!

 

[SkyhorseTamer]

Ben Brown
Josh Kennedy
Tom Boyd
Cameron Mooney
Barry Hall

Franklin - grand finals and no cup but another to the list