Welcome Welcome to Adelaide - Callum Ah Chee, Pick 1 PSD 2025

[BucketsNj]

I knew you'd come out of the woodwork and Ryan and Edwards deserved games last year but Maffew and his crew did what they do select their favourites when players could have been rested when players who were performing in the SANFL could have made their debuts but keep going with your coaches are always right narrative.

Ryan was injured for a lot of the year.
And apparently Edwards doesn’t run hard enough.
We have no idea what is happening in the Club. I think they’ve been pretty good at getting players ready to play.
And who are Ryan and Edwards pushing out? That back 6/7 is pretty good.

 

[cleanhands]

Ryan was injured for a lot of the year.
And apparently Edwards doesn’t run hard enough.
We have no idea what is happening in the Club. I think they’ve been pretty good at getting players ready to play.
And who are Ryan and Edwards pushing out? That back 6/7 is pretty good.

No one if there is an injury

 

[George CantStandYa]

Ryan was injured for a lot of the year.
And apparently Edwards doesn’t run hard enough.
We have no idea what is happening in the Club. I think they’ve been pretty good at getting players ready to play.
And who are Ryan and Edwards pushing out? That back 6/7 is pretty good.

Does the club know what’s going on down there? Eg naming Murphy as an emergency in a final before being delisted…..

Edwards could have been picked early on instead of Smith….

Or Edwards the midfielder could have been playing SANFL midfield, so this year he’d be more ready to step up to help fill a weakness…..

Besides who says Edwards doesn’t run hard enough? That’s a pretty big slur some of you are running with to justify a club selection, a club who have a history of stupid selections…..

 

[Syd Crow]

No one if there is an injury

Certainly weren't pushing out Murphy and Smith that's for sure!

 

[cleanhands]

Certainly weren't pushing out Murphy and Smith that's for sure!

 

[Bovo]

Murray, keep up Bov

The tennis player?

 

[Pugsley]

The tennis player?

Thats Andy from Toy Story.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

The tennis player?

The poster formally known as Murray...

 

[cleanhands]

Thats Andy from Toy Story.

 

[LoBu]

View attachment 2490317

Haha, didn't think so

 

[Danger in Texas]

Because he's the head coach of the side Ah Chee was thinking of moving to?

The idea that he wouldn't meet with Nicks before asking for a trade is ludicrous. Him having met with him means nothing.

I'm not a huge Nicks fan, nor a Nicks hater, but it's pretty clear which things Ah Chee emphasised and which were mentioned in passing. Nicks is firmly in the latter group.

It’d be fair to say he was an influence, but not close to a deciding factor

 

[MarcusP2]

It’d be fair to say he was an influence, but not close to a deciding factor

Probably so long as he wasn't Mark Neeld-esque then it didn't matter.

 

[cmndstab]

It’d be fair to say he was an influence, but not close to a deciding factor

He wasn't a deterrent, at least.

 

[Pugsley]

Does the club know what’s going on down there? Eg naming Murphy as an emergency in a final before being delisted…..

Edwards could have been picked early on instead of Smith….

Or Edwards the midfielder could have been playing SANFL midfield, so this year he’d be more ready to step up to help fill a weakness…..

Besides who says Edwards doesn’t run hard enough? That’s a pretty big slur some of you are running with to justify a club selection, a club who have a history of stupid selections…..

Too many facts here that the happy clappers can't digest

 

[Pugsley]

The poster formally known as Murray...

He knew about things

 

[George CantStandYa]

Too many facts here that the happy clappers can't digest

I just find it hypocritical that they are prepared to slur a young player and they have a crack at others for being critical of the club. At least the reasons for our criticisms are out there, we’ve witnessed it.

Blind faith in club employees will do that to you I suppose.

 

[craig crowing]

How about just cementing his future when another club comes with a 5 year contract and current team is full of quality players with more top draft academy players coming in.
Ok closer to family in WA asa well and some history in SA

 

[UcantCme]

Ryan was injured for a lot of the year.
And apparently Edwards doesn’t run hard enough.
We have no idea what is happening in the Club. I think they’ve been pretty good at getting players ready to play.
And who are Ryan and Edwards pushing out? That back 6/7 is pretty good.

Edwards shouldn’t be pushing out a defender - he is a more natural midfielder / winger and that’s where he should be getting his opportunity

 

[Pugsley]

Haha, didn't think so

Doesn't seem to be a habit of the happy clappers

 

[Syd Crow]

How about just cementing his future when another club comes with a 5 year contract and current team is full of quality players with more top draft academy players coming in.
Ok closer to family in WA asa well and some history in SA

He said he has family in SA as well. West Coast could probably have got him if they were really interested.

 

[LoBu]

Doesn't seem to be a habit of the happy clappers

Just drop it or move to another thread, you're wasting space here

 

[Pugsley]

Just drop it or move to another thread, you're wasting space here

You can put me on ignore this is a forum.

 

[AFC979810]

Because he's the head coach of the side Ah Chee was thinking of moving to?

The idea that he wouldn't meet with Nicks before asking for a trade is ludicrous. Him having met with him means nothing.

Huh.

How does this make sense? Him not meeting with the coach would be ludicrous - but the meeting means nothing.

 

[Bovo]

You can put me on ignore this is a forum.

Ah shit you mean all those years wasted and that’s all I had to do? FML

 

[Scorpus]

Even if Ah Chee was not factoring in the coach at all to his decision, Nicks would still request a meeting himself