Do Collingwood need to enter a rebuild phase?

[Mr Meow]

Well, no

They nearly equaled your entire score in the with what they put on in the second half

Collingwood managed one great quarter against Brisbane. Pretty similar to Geelong being on top of Richmond in 2019-2020 finals before being overwhelmed and outplayed in the 2nd half. The old Pies upped their intensity and quality in the 2nd quarter but besides that were thoroughly outplayed.

 

[doppleganger]

Well, no

Well yes.

It was 9.2 Pies to Lions 8.7 if you ignore Q3.

They nearly equaled your entire score in the with what they put on in the second half

No shit, they scored 7 goals in Q3.

It is why it is redundant of people to ignore the full game, and only isolate small components of it.

 

[Gavin Excell]

Was a free kick every day of week
However lions were getting on top after HT and everything suggests would have ended up winning

 

[doppleganger]

Was a free kick every day of week
However lions were getting on top after HT and everything suggests would have ended up winning

Agree..for the most part.

The Lions burst out of the blocks in Q3, 4 goals in first 10 mins to take the lead.

Q4 Pies had stopped the bleeding, we actually breaking even at contest and clearance and Lions hadn't scored a goal yet in Q4 when Elliott incident occurred.

An Elliott free and he would have been having a shot to make it 11 goals to 11 goals, (Pies back within a kick) with 10 mins left and crowd roaring.

Shit happens, the free wasn't called and Brisbane went down the other end and goaled, 12 point turn-around and Lions out by 18 and quickly put the game to bed with another few quick goals.

 

[morsie]

Collingwood the biggest sporting club in the country.

Richmond might be in the top 50.

Its all relative.Its a small pond.At one time Barcelona had 2 million members including the then pope.Australia is just a bush league.

 

[Cdog71]

Well yes.

It was 9.2 Pies to Lions 8.7 if you ignore Q3.

No shit, they scored 7 goals in Q3.

It is why it is redundant of people to ignore the full game, and only isolate small components of it.

They hit the scoreboard nearly every second time they entered fwd 50.
Sure, you held them in the second quarter but they worked it out, you guys were spent and you couldn’t stop them.
I’m not gonna go on about the incident with Elliot. I hope they can make decisions like that this season when it matters.

Brisbane are the bench mark and at the end of the season last year there was daylight to the next best.

 

[bzparkes]

Do people still not know the rules enough to not understand why Starcevich didn't give a free away to Elliott?

 

[Lockyer24]

It was a clear and obvious free to those with functioning eyesight, I don’t think it’s too much to expect them to be paid in the biggest stakes game of our season.

 

[Mynamesinuse]

12 touches for Beau is gonna be 12 score involvements. This man gets the ball he is not worried about 1-2s, he’s breaking a couple of tackles and kicking a goal or giving someone an assist.

Yeah good luck with that in the midfield.

 

[bzparkes]

It was a clear and obvious free to those with functioning eyesight, I don’t think it’s too much to expect them to be paid in the biggest stakes game of our season.

It was a non-free to anyone who actually understands the rule.

 

[Mynamesinuse]

It was a clear and obvious free to those with functioning eyesight, I don’t think it’s too much to expect them to be paid in the biggest stakes game of our season.

Amazing that apparently this was a clear free yet Toby Greens head being ripped off in the prelim Daicos diving Daniel’s head first into the ground weren’t.

 

[HeathySure]

What was the final margin? Try and answer it without bringing Carlton into it.

Maybe you should study up on the sliding doors concept

 

[HeathySure]

Do people still not know the rules enough to not understand why Starcevich didn't give a free away to Elliott?

Elliot jumped up vertically, somehow by magic he ended up horizontally on his back, He did some magic without being touched there

 

[Robertio]

Maybe you should study up on the sliding doors concept

What was the final margin?

 

[bzparkes]

Amazing that apparently this was a clear free yet Toby Greens head being ripped off in the prelim Daicos diving Daniel’s head first into the ground weren’t.

Hard to be objective when the media fluffs your club so much they ignore criminally obvious frees against your star players but screams bloody murder when a non-free isn't paid to your club.

 

[bzparkes]

Elliot jumped up vertically, somehow by magic he ended up horizontally on his back, He did some magic without being touched there

So you don't understand the rule then?

Could've just said that.

 

[Lockyer24]

It was a non-free to anyone who actually understands the rule.

Understanding the rule isn’t your issue here. It’s the front on contact you seem to imagine is him cleanly punching the ball. Which he does not.

 

[bzparkes]

Understanding the rule isn’t your issue here. It’s the front on contact you seem to imagine is him cleanly punching the ball. Which he does not.

Again, that's not the rule, so you clearly don't understand it.

He flushed the ball, btw.

 

[HeathySure]

What was the final margin?

you need to understand the sliding doors concept

 

[HeathySure]

So you don't understand the rule then?

Could've just said that.

he got front on contact lol how else does he land on his back.

 

[Lockyer24]

Again, that's not the rule, so you clearly don't understand it.

He flushed the ball, btw.

He didn’t flush it in the slightest, there is considerable contact

 

[bzparkes]

he got front on contact lol how else does he land on his back.

Again, that's not the rule.

Go and real the rules, then come back.

 

[bzparkes]

He didn’t flush it in the slightest, there is considerable contact

He hit the ball and only ever had eyes for it and didn't drag arms, thus not a free.

Go and read the rules then come back.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Also a dropping the ball and deliberate out of bounds missed, rough ten seconds for the Pies

 

[Cdog71]

He didn’t flush it in the slightest, there is considerable contact

IMO
Eyes on the ball.
He didn’t disadvantage him.
The ball wasn’t there to mark because he had spoiled the ball.
Contact happened after that.