- Banned
- #1
wich of these player do u reckon would be the most overrated, to me there all over rated and under achievers
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Most Over rated player
- Thread starter Carson_Kressley
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
and you must be lysdexic 
Crap thread. You might try putting overrated players in, not just ones you hate.
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #4
honestly what have these 3 players acheived . the media pump them up lets cut them individually:
Whitnall:too fat too slow. never acheived anything
Richardson: very overated has did absoulutely nothing. was paid well and not worth the money he been paid. he is the highest dummy spitting idiot of all time.
Ablett: living on his fathers name. he wont ever acheive anything individually.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Ablett won the AFLPA MVP Award this year - an award rated higher than the Brownlow by many AFL players.
Are you an idiot?
- Banned
- #7
Richardson is extremely highly rated and had he not done his knee years ago, he could have become something very special. Still a brilliant player that just cant kick accurately. Up there in the goal kicking tally so you havent really thought this thread out too well.
Gablett got 20+ votes this year and numerous awards.
roccacelli
Senior List
ablett is a superstar. its just that you carlton guys wish you had him. you cannnot say he is over rated. even if he is living in his fathers name. he performs well week in, week out. and he also acomplished something his father never done. a premiership! and he led them to that victory
forrrestGump
Cancelled
- Banned
- #10
lol, when carlton think that they would not take ablett and richardson in a season where their highlight was a hissy fit between witnall a and b, the afl should have beyond blue sponsor the blues
blues = poos of the afl, go merge with north fools and you might be competitive on the field
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #11
hahahahahaha why would we want him when we got the best player in the land, a guy called umm chris judd u may have heard of him, he has won everything and is a great achiever so u can take your ablett and stick him where the sun dont shine
- Banned
- #12
Where was the Warren 'take a bow' Tredrea option??? Likened to Wayne Carey at the start of his career, but in the end his AA defender opponent kicks more goals than he does and leads his club to a record 119pt GF defeat, and then if given a 'golden handshake' one year contract.
He hasnt won Coleman Medal has he
Interesting that it seems to have slipped the notice of a Tankton supporter but last time I looked Richardson and Ablett are both on AFL lists and the fat boy from Tankton went from Captain to scrap heap in less than a week.
This post is possibly the most ridiculous I have ever seen on Bigfooty and not suprisingly it was started by a supporter of Tankton!!
- Banned
- #15
He won the AFLPA and AFLCA awards this year,plus I think The Age and Herald-Sun awards.Did he not also win Geelongs Best & Fairest and finish top 3 or 4 in the Brownlow ?
Just because Lance was a useless fat **** at Carlton doesn't mean everyone else is.
Even saying Richo is over-rated is a bit harsh.Not his fault he has a hopeless coach and teammates that are picked up from the Reject Shop.
BOPPER
Debutant
- Feb 28, 2007
- 144
- 240
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, New England
How on earth is Gary Ablett Jnr over-rated? What a rediculous thread. Why would anyone vote? Seriously i think fast eddy is the only one voting. What a wank. Lance Whitnall is not even playing anymore so he doesn't get rated, if the question was "who was the most over-rated" then maybe i could understand. Even then i wouldn't have had him on the list. And last time i checked Richo has kicked more goals than any carlton player EVER.
Is this guy serious what a...
oh hang on, Carlton supporter.
My mistake, carry on.
By the way, where was Judd in that list? Just because Carlton were stupid enough to pay him 2 million if he went in the PSD?
oh hang on, Carlton supporter.
My mistake, carry on.
By the way, where was Judd in that list? Just because Carlton were stupid enough to pay him 2 million if he went in the PSD?
roccacelli
Senior List
ablett>>>>>carlton of 07'
- Nov 28, 2006
- 28,875
- 11,948
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Brendan Fevola.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
They are overrated. At least Richo tries.
reply to Barabbas' signature, things go better with many premierships and Things go better with back-to-back premierships.
I think the OP is still hurting from the day Geelong played Carlton at TD and Ablett ran out of petrol on the way there, had a fan help him refuel, then played on Walker and proceeded to tear him a new A-hole.
They actually attempted to buy Ablett for $2 Million a year by trying to convince him to go into the Pre-Season draft, but he refused.
Therefore, the OP is now exceptionally cheesed off.
a way to go yet before he's a superstar
which is why he's on this poll asking if he's overrated. i think he is, because he's a good player, not a great one.
and richo -easily the most entertaining footballer in the last decade
Lunchlady Doris
Hall of Famer
- Apr 3, 2006
- 35,943
- 15,118
- AFL Club
- Geelong
This thread went down well, another product of a sub-room temperature IQ
You need to watch some Geelong games.
You need to watch some Geelong games.
