AFL Rd 3 Collingwood v Carlton -Prematch Talk and Team Changes

TradeDraft · Apr 8, 2012

In: Wellingham Ugle Ceglar Maxwell

Out: Sinclair Seedsman Paine(Unlucky but looked bit tired) Tarrant(Injured)

jefffff34 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

In - Wellingham Wood Johnson Maxwell
Out - Sinclair Seedsman Paine Tarrant (inj)

mattys123 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Ins; (In order of importance) 1. Johnson (we need a running half back) 2. Wellingham (we need more midfield depth) 3. Maxwell (we need a backline marshall) 4. Wood (against Carlton we need a real second ruck)

Out; Sinclair, Seedsman, Paine, Taz

Bring on the scum, it's time to start the 2012 Wars. :thumbsu:

Shellz · Apr 8, 2012

Any word on why wellingham didn't play??

I read calf somewhere??!!

TradeDraft · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

mattys123 said:
Ins; (In order of importance) 1. Johnson (we need a running half back) 2. Wellingham (we need more midfield depth) 3. Maxwell (we need a backline marshall) 4. Wood (against Carlton we need a real second ruck)

Out; Sinclair, Seedsman, Paine, Taz

Bring on the scum, it's time to start the 2012 Wars.

What is wrong with Ceglar as I think he is in Better Form that Wood

doppleganger · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Wellers didn't play in the VFL, why would he then come straight in??

TradeDraft · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

doppleganger said:
Wellers didn't play in the VFL, why would he then come straight in??

It Happend before when a Top 22 Player misses a VFL game and come straight back in to the AFL.

Depends if he is Injured or Not

Number 10 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

doppleganger said:
Wellers didn't play in the VFL, why would he then come straight in??

Because Sinclair is a liability.

mattys123 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

TradeDraft said:
What is wrong with Ceglar as I think he is in Better Form that Wood

Ceglar isn't a genuine ruckman yet, and with Warnock, Kreuzer and Hampson likely to play next week, we need an experienced second ruck.

It may only be for one week, but we need Wood next week IMO.

Number 10 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

I honestly don't know.

Would get Didak in for Sinclair

Looks like Wellers is injured.

Maxwell in for Tarrant.

Ceglar in for DAWES. - On the account that Dawes was almost as useless as Sinclair tonight. Can't mark, can't ruck, can't kick goals. Give him a kick up the ass in the two's. Ceglar was better than Wood today in the VFL.

Johnson in for Seedsman who did nothing wrong.

In conclusion:
IN: Didak, Maxwell, Ceglar, Johnson
OUT: Sinclair, Tarrant, Dawes, Seedsman

We desperately need some properly skilled players in the team who can spot up forwards: i.e. Beams, Didak, Johnson.

TradeDraft · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

mattys123 said:
Ceglar isn't a genuine ruckman yet, and with Warnock, Kreuzer and Hampson likely to play next week, we need an experienced second ruck.

It may only be for one week, but we need Wood next week IMO.

You Make a Fair Point on the Opposition but why would you not call Ceglar a Genuine Ruckman yet?

I thought he been our Best Ruckman in the 1st 2 VFL Games

TradeDraft · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Number 10 said:
I honestly don't know.

Would get Didak in for Sinclair

Looks like Wellers is injured.

Maxwell in for Tarrant.

Ceglar in for DAWES. - On the account that Dawes was almost as useless as Sinclair tonight. Can't mark, can't ruck, can't kick goals. Give him a kick up the ass in the two's. Ceglar was better than Wood today in the VFL.

Johnson in for Seedsman who did nothing wrong.

In conclusion:
IN: Didak, Maxwell, Ceglar, Johnson
OUT: Sinclair, Tarrant, Dawes, Seedsman

We desperately need some properly skilled players in the team who can spot up forwards: i.e. Beams, Didak, Johnson.

So you have the 2 Tall Forwards as Cloke and Paine?

Number 10 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

TradeDraft said:
So you have the 2 Tall Forwards as Cloke and Paine?

Spot on, with Ceglar and Jolly resting there. This will cause enough headaches for Carlton's shitty defence.

jonesy86 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Wellingham is not injured, apparently Bucks in the post match press conference said it was a management thing with a 6-day break.

Definite Ins: Wellingham and Johnson

Definite Outs: Tarrant and Sinclair

Possible Ins: Maxwell and Wood/Ceglar

Possible Outs: Seedsman and Paine

mattys123 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

jonesy86 said:
Wellingham is not injured, apparently Bucks in the post match press conference said it was a management thing with a 6-day break.

Definite Ins: Wellingham and Johnson

Definite Outs: Tarrant and Sinclair

Possible Ins: Maxwell and Wood/Ceglar

Possible Outs: Seedsman and Paine

Give the man a cigar. :thumbsu:

the mighty T · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

jonesy86 said:
Definite Ins: Wellingham and Johnson

Definite Outs: Tarrant and Sinclair

Possible Ins: Maxwell and Wood/Ceglar

Possible Outs: Seedsman and Paine

Yeah I've got to agree with this. I really like Sinclair, when it comes to his endeavor and attack on the ball, but he needs time in the vfl

Wellingham and Benny will bring much more stability to that side.

Gotta get wood in though.

Nicco_jj · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

People need to stop hoping didak will come in.

It's not going to happen. Deal with it.

Mick98 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

I don't think Paine deserves to be dropped,Like him.Also think Keeffe is improving every game.
Though I was ready to drop him like a hot potato early on(Keeffe I mean).Last 2 weeks he has been ok.

Tarrant worries me as does Didak......where is he anyway!!

Need Maxy back next week to organise the back line troops against the Scum.

THATSGOLD · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Nicco_jj said:
People need to stop hoping didak will come in.

It's not going to happen. Deal with it.

I wrote him off after the 2011 gf. Got shit canned. Still no sign of him after a minor injury. He is just about done and dusted now.I'll be surprised if he is able to get in to our senior team and contribute.

TheGreatGrundy · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Ceglar is not ready for aFL. He is skinny and lacks presence as a ruckman or reliability as a forward. Maybe next year after some body building. Wood for mine. When will Nate Brown be in the team because we need a replacement for tarrant.

Mick98 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Writing off Didak?
How fickle are you Pie's supporters?...really hope he comes back into our best and makes you all look stupid

THATSGOLD · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Mick98 said:
Writing off Didak?
How fickle are you Pie's supporters?...really hope he comes back into our best and makes you all look stupid

Theres a difference between being fickle and realistic!

dayna36 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Didak has been flogged on the training track he is ready to go may even go straight into the seniors but I doubt it..they flogged Sharrod and then rested him up to keep him fresh for Carlton (due to the 6 day turn around)
Ben Johnson is ready to rock & Wood appears to have recovered from shoulder surger(Wood no pre season).Witts not yet..maybe Ceglar but Wood's experience could be the difference when choosing the 2nd ruck..no way could Dawes take on the scum rucks

so INS Maxwell Wellingham Johnson Wood
OUTS Tarrant(inj) Seedsman Sinclair Paine

Mick98 · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

THATSGOLD said:
Theres a difference between being fickle and realistic!

And you are privy to the inner sanctum of Collingwood?

danielnajdek · Apr 8, 2012

Re: Changes for RD 3 vs the Blues

Ceglar wasn't better then Wood in the VFL. I judge Cam Wood as harshly as anyone else on here however he was much better then Ceglar.

Log In or Create New Account

Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2026 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join

NRL Tipping Competition 2026! - Open Now - Win a badge and a Platinum!

AFL Rd 3 Collingwood v Carlton -Prematch Talk and Team Changes

Post-Human

Brownlow Medallist

Hall of Famer

Premiership Player

Post-Human

Brownlow Medallist

Post-Human

Premiership Player

Hall of Famer

Premiership Player

Post-Human

Post-Human

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Hall of Famer

Premiership Player

Bigfooty Kid

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

Cancelled

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

Team Captain

Cancelled

Hall of Famer

Similar threads