2010 - RD 15-18 - Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion Threads

[ThePezDispenser]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Quick Question, i want to play Chapman in the midfield but i have him in my forward line, is it possible to put him as an emercency and choose a player from my midfield bench who is not playing, Would Chapman take his spot as my Midfield player?

No.

Why would you want him in your midfield anyway. The forward options have really been a let down this year - he is the shining the light of the forward line.

 

[n185]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

So i could have Armstrong out And Yarran in..

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

And why would you want Yarran in your side?
He averages less than 60 ppg.

 

[Spudregus_87]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

OUT: McLeod & Davis, IN: Porplyzia & Bock

 

[BigSledge]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

That was the week most of our guns were rested if you can recall. All the guys you looked up may not have played.

Oh how could I forget I had Riewoldt, Goddard, NDS & Fisher all miss some how I won a league match with 1900 and still rose in the rankings as well

Pretty sure others had Sewell, Chappy out it was the round of death for many!

 

[BigSledge]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Goodwin out of Adelaide side

 

[Spudregus_87]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Cheers Sledge, updating the OP as we speak

 

[thomas_m18]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Cannot believe Phil Davis is gone, not that I have him.

I think I will make GAJ my captain. When in doubt, pick the guy you picked to be your permanent captain in the first place. Stevie J is back as well, so hopefully that ends that permanent forward crap.

 

[BigSledge]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Great effort on your behalf Spud

Looking forward to tonight got Hodge, Goddard, Buddy & Monty running around tonight hoping for 450+ but will settle for an even 400

 

[munk3ymark]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Cannot believe Phil Davis is gone, not that I have him.

I think I will make GAJ my captain. When in doubt, pick the guy you picked to be your permanent captain in the first place. Stevie J is back as well, so hopefully that ends that permanent forward crap.

I'm with you- I was counting on him to fill in for Hoops again (anyone know what's wrong with him BTW- the week after I bring him in he's out?).

I just know the week I drop the (C) from Gazza he'll come good and hit a 180.

 

[Spudregus_87]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Great effort on your behalf Spud

Cheers mate. I enjoy doing it

Cannot believe Phil Davis is gone, not that I have him.

I think I will make GAJ my captain. When in doubt, pick the guy you picked to be your permanent captain in the first place. Stevie J is back as well, so hopefully that ends that permanent forward crap.

Yeah, seems strange that Davis wins the NAB Rising Star nomination last week, then gets dropped for the big showdown this week.

In regards to Captain...still racking my brain...

At the moment, I've gone with Swan (c) & Murphy (vc), but Gaz & Nicky Dal are knocking on the door.

 

[Millington Magic]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Can't wait for the game tonight!

Supercoach wise, it's a big night for everyone you would think. For me, Goddard, Hayes, Fisher, Franklin and Hodge. Everyone's got Hodge and Goddard, Franklin quite popular, too. So I'm hoping St Kilda play Sammy Fish loose in the defensive half like last week.

Chapman captain, or Boyd? Not sure yet. I am sure now that Ablett is not captain, he will rip out 170+.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

strange ph davis is out after wining the NAB rising thingy,l thought he was going to be a lock cover for the rest of the season he better be back soon.l'll might put sally as skip this week something diff.

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Davis was their third-picked tall, so with Bock back in he's out.

 

[BigSledge]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

I'm with you Spud went Swanny as captain this week with Goddard vice.

With regards to Davis the inclusion of Bock leaves the Adelaide side too top heavy in the back line so whilst Davis played great on the weekend he is behind Bock, Rutten & Stevens in the pecking order. Real tough break for the kid and FWIW I actually think he should have been kept ahead of Stevens.

Will probably get a look in again towards the end of year if he keeps his form up in the SANFL as up until recently Stevens was poor and Bock has been as fragile as glass this year. Could be a handy back up but for those that have trades I can see Davis>Smith being popular this week

 

[BigSledge]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

strange ph davis is out after wining the NAB rising thingy,l thought he was going to be a lock cover for the rest of the season he better be back soon.l'll might put sally as skip this week something diff.

Mind my ignorance but who is Sally?

 

[Spudregus_87]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Hawks vs Saints: teams as selected

 

[Satan]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Cannot believe Phil Davis is gone, not that I have him.

I think I will make GAJ my captain. When in doubt, pick the guy you picked to be your permanent captain in the first place. Stevie J is back as well, so hopefully that ends that permanent forward crap.

"fan blooy tastic'

krispy in DEf , Silvani, Shaw and Davis all out

 

[rocker_oz33]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Mind my ignorance but who is Sally?

selwood

 

[FBDonkey]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

I cant believe they closed the JM wankfest. i thought that thread would be bumped for life

I couldnt decide between Swan and Chappy for captain so i went with Chappy because i will be at the game.

 

[Spudregus_87]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

On the other hand, happy the 'which two rookies do I pick' thread has been closed.

Kudos to the SC Mods for being proactive in this matter.

 

[Spudregus_87]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Ross Lyon thought Bateman would play on Nicky Dal Santo

Might change people's captaincy selection.

EDIT: Confirmed by Dr Smooth a couple of minutes before the bounce.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Heavy hitters tonight, Hodge, Goddard, Montagna, NDS and Franklin. Hoping for 550 odd.

 

[dUkezz]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

hodge buddy hayes gilbert and goddard tonight, was gonna put buddy captain for shits and giggles

 

[Biggie]

Re: spud_jjj's Round 17 Preview, Scores & In-Game Discussion

Happy to have Monty skipper instead of Hodge........