Mega Thread 2013: Trade Hypotheticals

[Sydswans0512]

whats mumford's value? Put into consideration that he'll be going from top 4 Sydney to lowly St Kilda

Not much apparently. Injury prone and has had the number 1 ruck role taken away from him, so everybody seems to think

 

[Super Hans]

I want us to go hard at GWS's pick ten, don't know if we will be able to get it pure though. Maybe through a downgrade.

 

[yakka man]

oh please let us trade our 19 year old key forward who kicks 3-4 goals every week in the sanfl for a fourth round pick and who the frak is sutcliffe?

I'm still waiting for you to confirm that Mason Shaw is kicking bags of goals at SANFL level...

 

[Sydswans0512]

I'm still waiting for you to confirm that Mason Shaw is kicking bags of goals at WAFL level...

How can he he's cleared to the Sanfl

 

[Tragic sainter]

Not much apparently. Injury prone and has had the number 1 ruck role taken away from him, so everybody seems to think

So he's not injury prone then?

 

[Sydswans0512]

So he's not injury prone then?

He's missed 3 games this year thru a fractured cheekbone hardly call that his body giving up on him. He's missed 5 games from suspension over the last few years. Mummy still gets up to the 20 games a year. Does anybody ever mention injury prone with Kreuzer or Leunberger?

 

[Tragic sainter]

He's missed 3 games this year thru a fractured cheekbone hardly call that his body giving up on him. He's missed 5 games from suspension over the last few years. Mummy still gets up to the 20 games a year. Does anybody ever mention injury prone with Kreuzer or Leunberger?

People mention injury prone kreuzer and leunberger all the time. Mummy missed a fair chunk of last year with injury and he must be playing under duress this year otherwise he's just not that good anymore as his good games are few and far between.

 

[Sydswans0512]

People mention injury prone kreuzer and leunberger all the time. Mummy missed a fair chunk of last year with injury and he must be playing under duress this year otherwise he's just not that good anymore as his good games are few and far between.

I beg the differ Mummy doesn't play as a lone ruckman so he doesn't get the over inflated stats he would walk into st kilda and be your first ruck and set the standards towards tackling and pressure. Well Mcevoy and Nicnat are injury prone aswell

 

[The Finger]

I beg the differ Mummy doesn't play as a lone ruckman so he doesn't get the over inflated stats he would walk into st kilda and be your first ruck and set the standards towards tackling and pressure. Well Mcevoy and Nicnat are injury prone aswell

Nicnat maybe McEvoy has barely missed a game although he has played with a injury this year.

 

[Tragic sainter]

I beg the differ Mummy doesn't play as a lone ruckman so he doesn't get the over inflated stats he would walk into st kilda and be your first ruck and set the standards towards tackling and pressure. Well Mcevoy and Nicnat are injury prone aswell

What does st kilda have to do with anything? And most clubs play with two ruckman these days so I don't know what your on about. And I wasn't looking at stats. I've watched almost every Sydney game for the last 4 years and mummy's form is well well below his 2011 form.

 

[Sydswans0512]

What does st kilda have to do with anything? And most clubs play with two ruckman these days so I don't know what your on about. And I wasn't looking at stats. I've watched almost every Sydney game for the last 4 years and mummy's form is well well below his 2011 form.

I'm not having a dig at stkilda guys like Mcevoy and Goldstein have over inflated stas because they ruck for 90% of the game whereas Mummy does around the 60%. Guys like big Mummy make everyone walk a bit taller.

 

[Tragic sainter]

I'm not having a dig at stkilda guys like Mcevoy and Goldstein have over inflated stas because they ruck for 90% of the game whereas Mummy does around the 60%. Guys like big Mummy make everyone walk a bit taller.

McEvoy doesn't play lone ruck... And once again I didn't even glance at stats, I watch almost every Sydney game and mumfords 2011 form was superb and its since fallen off a cliff, I was attributing this to injuries.

 

[Sydswans0512]

McEvoy doesn't play lone ruck... And once again I didn't even glance at stats, I watch almost every Sydney game and mumfords 2011 form was superb and its since fallen off a cliff, I was attributing this to injuries.

Who rucks with Mcevoy? Hickey?

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Who rucks with Mcevoy? Hickey?

I think Stanley does some ruck work.

 

[God Save Max King]

Who rucks with Mcevoy? Hickey?

Hickey plays ruck and Stanley provides a rest for the two.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Hickey plays ruck and Stanley provides a rest for the two.

Hickey averages around 10 hit outs a game it either says he's a poor ruck man or he doesn't spend much time in there

 

[saintsrfreak]

Matthew Watson going anywhere?

 

[Sydswans0512]

Matthew Watson going anywhere?

Would you really wan him?

 

[saintsrfreak]

Would you really wan him?

Beggars can't be choosers

 

[Sydswans0512]

Beggars can't be choosers

Sorry I just think you could do a lot better than Watson unless you get him for a Late second rounder early third

 

[saintsrfreak]

Sorry I just think you could do a lot better than Watson unless you get him for a Late second rounder early third

Well yeah that's what I was thinking, third rounder or a second round upgrade, something like that.

 

[Two Planks]

With Adam Selwood coming to Geelong at the end of the year to play VFL and be an assistant coach, surely geelong and west coast can do a deal to re unite all 4 brothers. Scott Selwood to Geelong in exchange for Mitch Duncan and Cam Eardley. Or Mitch Duncan and a second round pick.

 

[Kramer1]

Well yeah that's what I was thinking, third rounder or a second round upgrade, something like that.

So our developing frst round pick CHB, whose doing quite nicely since he came into the team for a 5-6 pick upgrade in the secound round? Just checking that I have this right...

 

[Sydswans0512]

So our developing frst round pick CHB, whose doing quite nicely since he came into the team for a 5-6 pick upgrade in the secound round? Just checking that I have this right...

He'd worth more than a pick upgrade but I'd be disappointed if we traded for him I know he's only young but seems to reactive.

 

[Beer n Skittles]

He'd worth more than a pick upgrade but I'd be disappointed if we traded for him I know he's only young but seems to reactive.

As a developing KPP he's worth more to Carlton than anyone would be willing to pay.
Could probably get Duigan or Davies for free though, maybe even Laider (although I'd prefer we held on to him).