List Mgmt. 2014 Draft Trade FA Megathread

[AFaiL]

Boyd is an eggs in the one basket type of move. You'd likely use pick 1, and nothing else. His value hasn't increased since being picked there last year. If anything, his desire to leave lowers it.

I'd still rather turn 1 into a few picks inside the 20. The most likely scenario being 1 and 22 for 4 and 7. Sure, it doesn't sound as nice as 1 for 4-5-6-7-8-9, but reality is a prick like that.

 

[AFaiL]

Ha, ha, why can't we be greedy? Everybody else is.....

It just sounds stupid. The same crap over and over. Won't happen.

 

[Wright 1]

Robbo on SEN saying he spoke to GWS himself about Boyd earlier. He said it couldnt be more BLACK AND WHITE that they will NOT trade Boyd.

BLACK AND WHITE..............Hmmm

 

[aussierulesrules]

Of course i can given that everyone expects him to be a superstar and would then be then guaranteed a wage of such amount I think he should at least be prepared to play his contract out given the Giants had the faith to draft him whatever pick he was taken. One year of loyalty isnt going to make him poor just less respected.

Respected for what, being loyal to the club who are trying to prise away another club's captain while he's still contracted? How many at 19yo would choose that over possibly a $5 mil or $6 mil contract, when for all they know they could break a leg next week and never be the same again?

 

[Defacto]

Robbo on SEN saying he spoke to GWS himself about Boyd earlier. He said it couldnt be more BLACK AND WHITE that they will NOT trade Boyd.

BLACK AND WHITE..............Hmmm

well there we have it, the other piece to the puzzle. he's not a small bird either

 

[70s sainter]

The best we can hope for is if gws trade whiley to carl for pick 7 and we get 4 + 7 for pick one.
gws would get petrecca
melb - wright + brayshaw
we,d end up with mc cartin + pick 7.
simple.
If dogs had 4 + 6 they would just keep it and pick up Wright/ Mc Cartin and pick 6.

 

[God Save Max King]

Respected for what, being loyal to the club who are trying to prise away another club's captain while he's still contracted? How many at 19yo would choose that over possibly a $5 mil or $6 mil contract, when for all they know they could break a leg next week and never be the same again?

And exactly the type of risk the club has to take.

 

[CALL ME SNAKE]

You can learn from Nick Riewoldt at the saints Thomas.

While at the dogs you learn from........ well.................. Jack Redpath

Hey be nice.
Im sure the young dogs learnt plenty from
Minten-Connell
Alen Jakovich
James Cook
and Kingsly Hunter.

 

[Wright 1]

Robbo now saying that the Beams deal looks like it might happen today. Darcy Gardiner the player to be included in deal

 

[SK_MD_#7]

Don't give up hope.

 

[Rors]

Respected for what, being loyal to the club who are trying to prise away another club's captain while he's still contracted? How many at 19yo would choose that over possibly a $5 mil or $6 mil contract, when for all they know they could break a leg next week and never be the same again?

Exactly... if he goes to the Dogs, we'll just have Rhys Stanley tackle him in the goalsquare - he can ask Jon Patton how that went for him

 

[saintbill]

It just sounds stupid. The same crap over and over. Won't happen.

Granted 4,6,7 won't happen. However, I don't think asking 4 & 7 is unreasonable. We have stated on multiple occasions it is going to take a trade in our favour for us to give up 1. If nobody wants to offer that kind of value, we just take Petracca. Still a win.

 

[Rors]

Hey be nice.
Im sure the young dogs learnt plenty from
Minten-Connell
Alen Jakovich
James Cook
and Kingsly Hunter.

You forgot Jon Ballantyne!

 

[HayesTheChamp]

Robbo now saying that the Beams deal looks like it might happen today. Darcy Gardiner the player to be included in deal

That is absolutely ridiculous by Robbo IMO. One the reasons why the Lions were willing to let Patfull walk, is that they have Darcy Gardiner to play CHB. If he goes, who do they have left? Merrett on last legs, McStay showed plenty up forward so will probably stay there, and Justin Clarke. That's pretty much it.

 

[Barrels]

Robbo now saying that the Beams deal looks like it might happen today. Darcy Gardiner the player to be included in deal

Good get for the Filth that... Gardiner will be a very good player.

 

[Periphery]

Exactly... if he goes to the Dogs, we'll just have Rhys Stanley tackle him in the goalsquare - he can ask Jon Patton how that went for him

Rhys might not even have to bother. If history is repeating itself Boyd will do his ACL this week just like Patton did after the reports of the Dogs offering him huge money came out.

 

[Persevering Saint]

You know the best thing that a Pelican can do?

Swoop.

 

[CALL ME SNAKE]

Im on holidays. What are the rest of you bums doing on your computer/phones all day when your supposed to be working

 

[HayesTheChamp]

Im on holidays. What are the rest of you bums doing on your computer/phones all day when your supposed to be working

In a tutorial at uni

 

[AFLOnline]

Boyd is an eggs in the one basket type of move. You'd likely use pick 1, and nothing else. His value hasn't increased since being picked there last year. If anything, his desire to leave lowers it.

I'd still rather turn 1 into a few picks inside the 20. The most likely scenario being 1 and 22 for 4 and 7. Sure, it doesn't sound as nice as 1 for 4-5-6-7-8-9, but reality is a prick like that.

1 and 22 for 4 and 7?

Let's hope you never become our list manager.

 

[sixtosaint]

Im on holidays. What are the rest of you bums doing on your computer/phones all day when your supposed to be working

I'll be lucky to have a job by Thursday, I haven't done anything for a week.

 

[Fred]

Im on holidays. What are the rest of you bums doing on your computer/phones all day when your supposed to be working

It's so long since I worked I can't remember it.

 

[Half Back Pocket]

Is pick 1 + armo for boyd overkill? And screw the dogs

yes

 

[Persevering Saint]

Im on holidays. What are the rest of you bums doing on your computer/phones all day when your supposed to be working

I have a really bad toothache. I'm waiting until my dental appointment. Believe me, if I had the choice between work and the dentist, work wins every time. I hate going to the dentists more than I hate Essendon... and you guys know how much that is!

 

[Persevering Saint]

It's so long since I worked I can't remember it.

Isn't this your job, boss?