List Mgmt. 2014: The List

[etsal1]

Okay thanks for clearing that up! When Curnow comes back, if both are fit, who would be first selected out of the two? Or could we fit both into the 22?

I think we could fit both but I'd have Curnow in first.

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

Whats our best 22 with everyone in form look like?

 

[etsal1]

Bizarro world. Carrots just got 32 touches against the reigning premiers.

How many times did he give it back to them though

Curnow's kicking is much improved and better than Carrots'.

 

[happydude]

Bizarro world. Carrots just got 32 touches against the reigning premiers.

As etsal1 said it seemed like he gave 20+ back.

He has had some good games but due to bad luck and injury he hasn't had a consistently good year since 2011.

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

Bizarro world. Carrots just got 32 touches against the reigning premiers.

doesn't matter how many times u touch it, if u turn it over

 

[Azul]

81.2% efficiency. AFL website must lie then.

Not sure why you folks think Curnow and Carrazzo can't play in the same team.

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

2012 round 3 Carrazzo played very well until some Essendon scumbag injured him the next week. And everthings been going down hill from there.

 

[Buckley2Menzel]

Whats our best 22 with everyone in form look like?

If everyone was currently healthy/fit I think it would look something like this:

Docherty Jamison Walker
Simpson Henderson Yarran
Murphy Kruezer Judd
Gibbs Curnow Carrazzo
Robinson Waite Thomas
Menzel Casboult Garlett

With Rowe, Touhy, Bell, Buckley, Everitt, McLean, Cripps and Ellard as interchange options.

Just my opinion.

 

[happydude]

I was typing a reply when my boss rang and ****ed it up....


Carazzo can play in the same team as curnow but if he gets back to his 2011 form he can play Brock's roll as the in and under type, he has done very well there before.

If competing for the same role I have curnow ahead of him right now.

 

[blues4flag]

81.2% efficiency. AFL website must lie then.

Not sure why you folks think Curnow and Carrazzo can't play in the same team.

Gibbs, Carrazzo, Mclean, Curnow, Graham, [Robinson]. A lot of one paced midfielders and we can't fit them all in the side. Robinson has strings to his bow so he plays, Gibbs is probably our best player and is extremely damaging with the ball. Of the other four, I don't think we can carry more than 2. Mclean should be last in the pecking order for mine, while Curnow plays first. Toss up between Graham and Carrazzo but Carrazzo's gonna wanna be far more damaging than he was on Friday if he's to stay in the side.

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

If everyone was currently healthy/fit I think it would look something like this:

Docherty Jamison Walker
Simpson Henderson Yarran
Murphy Kruezer Judd
Gibbs Curnow Carrazzo
Robinson Waite Thomas
Menzel Casboult Garlett

With Rowe, Touhy, Bell, Buckley, Everitt, McLean, Cripps and Ellard as interchange options.

Just my opinion.

Don't know about Cripps to early to judge.

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

Gibbs, Carrazzo, Mclean, Curnow, Graham, [Robinson]. A lot of one paced midfielders and we can't fit them all in the side. Robinson has strings to his bow so he plays, Gibbs is probably our best player and is extremely damaging with the ball. Of the other four, I don't think we can carry more than 2. Mclean should be last in the pecking order for mine, while Curnow plays first. Toss up between Graham and Carrazzo but Carrazzo's gonna wanna be far more damaging than he was on Friday if he's to stay in the side.

Shouldn't play Mclean not part of the future, not performing as well as others who can replace.

 

[Buckley2Menzel]

Don't know about Cripps to early to judge.

You're right, but I'm definitely excited as to what he could be. Probably not best 22 yet, just chucked him in because I want to see him there.

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

I throught Gibbs was accoucing hes re-signing at the 150th. Anyone think hes leaving. If he does hope its not the Crows.

 

[etsal1]

I throught Gibbs was accoucing hes re-signing at the 150th. Anyone think hes leaving. If he does hope its not the Crows.

Not going anywhere.

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

Not going anywhere.

Hope so

 

[MC_Doggy_Frog18]

If Judds son is good at footy is there a father-son rule for egales?

 

[FoeverBlues]

2012 round 3 Carrazzo played very well until some Essendon scumbag injured him the next week. And everthings been going down hill from there.

is that when we started to go to the south yarra chemist to check on what the Scums been taking??

 

[FoeverBlues]

Don't know about Cripps to early to judge.

No Mate, he is a very good pick from what little we see of him, Roger and co. deserve that credit at least.
From now on it's up to him, his luck with injury and our development etc..

 

[Love the Drake]

Carlton have to be aggressive at the end of the season. Must trade hard for a current 20-21 y.o KPP and pick up a 17 y.o KPP in the national draft. Also need a bit mor outside run..cripps, graham, Holman have us covered for inside grunt.

 

[etsal1]

Gibbs' manager is on sen on Wednesday nights. However he hasn't been on for the last 3 weeks because he is overseas. Hence Jamo has been filling in with Finey. Probably explains why Gibbs' deal hasn't been announced yet.

 

[etsal1]

Carlton have to be aggressive at the end of the season. Must trade hard for a current 20-21 y.o KPP and pick up a 17 y.o KPP in the national draft. Also need a bit mor outside run..cripps, graham, Holman have us covered for inside grunt.

Ideally we get 2 KPPs at MINIMUM. our stocks are so low we need at least two. and probably 3 if Waite retires.

 

[SE_Blue]

If Judds son is good at footy is there a father-son rule for egales?

I believe he can choose whether he wants to go to the Eagles or Carlton or nominate for the draft. On the flip-side, he could choose Carlton and we could say no like with Sheldon's kid.

 

[etsal1]

I believe he can choose whether he wants to go to the Eagles or Carlton.

you'd hope if he grew up in Victoria he'd choose us to stay at home

 

[marcmurphy#3]

Temay hasn't played VFL development this year.

Secondly - delisting Temay because he hasn't cracked a senior spot is the exact opposite of what Geelong, Hawthorn & Sydney do. I hope we don't do that. Temay has definitely improved this year. Last year was a right off for personal reasons.

Write off in what way? From my memory he was playing most weeks in the VFL so did it restrict him from training?