List Mgmt. 2014: The List

[LordLucifer]

I personally rather the idea of 3 KPF. Casboult plays the 3rd KPF well and doesn't get the main KPD.

Mate, I'd have six KPF if we could find them but I'll settle for two really good ones for the moment.

 

[JustaBattler]

Methinks - we are all busy saying the same thing...

 

[LordLucifer]

I'm a tall guy but I could never bulk up as much as my mate as my frame won't allow me to.

Come out with me for a few nights on the pizza & beer diet, I'm sure that will all change.

 

[HARKER]

Oh definitely. Walker playing on the 4th tall KPD would cause all kinds of headaches. MM is obsessed with his run and carry out of defence.

Tuohy gets back to fitness and form with Docherty stepping up and Walker can easily find himself in the forward line again.

Reckon it's not too far away.

 

[happydude]

Come out with me for a few nights on the pizza & beer diet, I'm sure that will all change.

I love pizza and beer.

I'm in

 

[Sector 7G]

Tuohy gets back to fitness and form with Docherty stepping up and Walker can easily find himself in the forward line again.

Reckon it's not too far away.

DB -back in 4 weeks. I think that is the run we need from the backline for the next 2-3 year till he goes in to the middle

 

[Jeremias]

Some people never cease to amaze me.

Honestly, anyone who would decline to trade our first and second round picks for Tomlinson and Shiel because "we need key position players" either has rocks in their head, or simply has not seen the latter two play.

To get to where we want to be we need far more than just a KPF or a KPB or a combination of the two. Quite clearly we need more class across the field.

Let me put this hypothetical to you. Let's say GWS were to delist both Tomlinson and Shiel and they enter the National Draft. Do we take them with our first and second picks?

The answer is a clear no.......because both would be long gone by that stage of the draft.

 

[Cringle]

Was watching Shiel VS BL on Saturday. Is an absolute Jet. Will win a brownlow.

 

[happydude]

I haven't seen much of them play admittedly so I'm out of this debate

 

[Just Kreuzing]

I love pizza and beer.

I'm in

Me too, how many do you guys need for a quorum ??

 

[Big Sim]

I haven't seen much of them play admittedly so I'm out of this debate

Ignorance is no excuse for not entering into a debate on Big Footy HD, you piker. Just make shit up like the rest of us.

 

[happydude]

MoAR premierships, less spudzzz pls

 

[happydude]

Me too, how many do you guys need for a quorum ??

More the merrier, bigfooty blues fitness program

 

[Just Kreuzing]

More the merrier, bigfooty blues fitness program

I will organise Aph's mods credit card for the evening also.

 

[HARKER]

Let me put this hypothetical to you. Let's say GWS were to delist both Tomlinson and Shiel and they enter the National Draft. Do we take them with our first and second picks?

The answer is a clear no.......because both would be long gone by that stage of the draft.

Depends on the circumstances J.

I think we'd all say that Melbourne came out ahead with the trade of pick #2 for Tyson and Salem.
That's effectively a pick #2 for a #3 & #9. You'd do that 99 times out of a hundred.

If Shiel does want to come home (I know he's contracted for another year) and Tomlinson sees better opportunity elsewhere, someone may just get lucky.........again.

 

[happydude]

Ignorance is no excuse for not entering into a debate on Big Footy HD, you piker. Just make shit up like the rest of us.

But seriously, shiel is too short to be a KPP and Tomlinson isn't athletic enough to play in our midfield do not want.

 

[LordLucifer]

I love pizza and beer.

I'm in

It'll cost you extra to get home, the airlines will charge you for the extra baggage you're carrying.

 

[LordLucifer]

I haven't seen much of them play admittedly so I'm out of this debate

I've seen plenty of Shiel, he is a very good mid, no doubt about it.

Tomlinson I've seen way less of and he may indeed be a good player.

 

[LordLucifer]

Some people never cease to amaze me.

Honestly, anyone who would decline to trade our first and second round picks for Tomlinson and Shiel because "we need key position players" either has rocks in their head, or simply has not seen the latter two play.

To get to where we want to be we need far more than just a KPF or a KPB or a combination of the two. Quite clearly we need more class across the field.

Let me put this hypothetical to you. Let's say GWS were to delist both Tomlinson and Shiel and they enter the National Draft. Do we take them with our first and second picks?

The answer is a clear no.......because both would be long gone by that stage of the draft.

Okay, let's trade for two more shorter guys who may be very good players.

Next year we will still be howling from the rooftops (like we have been since SOS & Sticks retired) about our inability or reluctance to find quality key position players.

Get the goddam spine right first & foremost and the rest will fall into place very easily around them.

 

[LordLucifer]

Me too, how many do you guys need for a quorum ??

There is no minimum quorum, just minimum on the size of pizza & number of cartons of beer.

 

[Silvagnis]

i still take Fev at 193cm over Levi at 197cm any day

Fevola was a gun and a genius until he snuck a crayon up his nose at the age of six.

Moral of this thread is Cripps is a KPF.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

There is no minimum quorum, just minimum on the size of pizza & number of cartons of beer.

Sounds like my sort of scene Sheik.

 

[LordLucifer]

Fevola was a gun and a genius until he snuck a crayon up his nose at the age of six.

Moral of this thread is Cripps is a KPF.

Since when ??

He's a borne & bred grunt midfielder in the new-age bigger bodied size that the Swans pioneered with Josh Kennedy.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Fevola was a gun and a genius until he snuck a crayon up his nose at the age of six.

Moral of this thread is Cripps is a KPF.

Thought he was a ruckman...

 

[FoeverBlues]

It was that and how he read the ball. He was dynamite on the lead but also knew where the high ball was going to land and made it impossible for the defender to take that space. He was awesome.

Full back of the century does not think so..