PowerDrafter
Team Captain
- Sep 23, 2014
- 430
- 249
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls, Chicago Blackhawks
Are you starting Aish as well?The only reason he goes out is if having two collingwood players in defence is an issue
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Are you starting Aish as well?The only reason he goes out is if having two collingwood players in defence is an issue
Depends, my d4 spot is between aish, seedsman and Hampton at the momentAre you starting Aish as well?
Don't like Howe from the Hawks?Depends, my d4 spot is between aish, seedsman and Hampton at the moment
Think O'Brien is ahead of him for that spot, believe one of the hawthorn players (Roughead?) said it in an interviewDon't like Howe from the Hawks?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Different players.Think O'Brien is ahead of him for that spot, believe one of the hawthorn players (Roughead?) said it in an interview
Ah its all up in the air anyway, whoever is named round 1 will get in.Different players.
Howe's a rebounding defender whilst O'Brien is a key forward.
The players seem to speak positively about Howe getting game time but he didn't seem to cope well yesterday under a fast moving ball. I don't think Hawthorn will rush him in, they have plenty of options down back. Gibson, Frawley, Stratton, Duryea, Birchall, Burgoyne, Hodge, Litherland, Hartung, Whitecross, Mitchell rested down back last year, Gunstan at times went to half back last year. I'd think if all those guys are already in the 22, maybe not Litherland, then it's going to be hard for Howe to get a go in there.Different players.
Howe's a rebounding defender whilst O'Brien is a key forward.
Cheap on a D4, what kinda scores are you expecting from that position then? At the moment I'm Boyd, Laird, Bartel, Pittard and Whitecross. Looks like you've taken a very different approach to it.Depends, my d4 spot is between aish, seedsman and Hampton at the moment
Never spend big in the back line personally. I'm a sucker for mid-priced bargains (Libs, Crouch,parish)Cheap on a D4, what kinda scores are you expecting from that position then? At the moment I'm Boyd, Laird, Bartel, Pittard and Whitecross. Looks like you've taken a very different approach to it.
Libba is my only mid pricer. I had them, get burnt every year, picking someone to "potentially break out" is a lot harder than picking a proven scorer. A team of mid pricers will always look better than a team of guns and rookies but in practice they never work out.Never spend big in the back line personally. I'm a sucker for mid-priced bargains (Libs, Crouch,parish)
Are you two both femsle? With that rack, who cares about that voice or that IQ? In fact the voice and the IQ could enhance the experience.Dat IQ!
I only have 5 mid-pricers. I know that's a lot for some but libs, crouch, de goey, aish and parish are pretty goodLibba is my only mid pricer. I had them, get burnt every year, picking someone to "potentially break out" is a lot harder than picking a proven scorer. A team of mid pricers will always look better than a team of guns and rookies but in practice they never work out.
Ah Hawthorn supporters- such high expectations for their team, but such low standards for their women.Are you two both femsle? With that rack, who cares about that voice or that IQ? In fact the voice and the IQ could enhance the experience.
Parish is still classified as rookie price because he is under 220 but I see you point. Personally I wouldn't be running with Crouch and Aish if you have De Goey. I'm assuming that Crouch is your M6? If you dropped him to Mills or a rookie you could start upgrading Aish to a more reliable pick at D4. I only say this because if Aish doesn't fire early you're gonna be stuck for options. That's why I've gone Whitecross at D5 and not at D4. I have no doubt he could come in and average 85+ but if he doesn't it's nice to know that you haven't messed your whole season up on taking a risk.I only have 5 mid-pricers. I know that's a lot for some but libs, crouch, de goey, aish and parish are pretty good
Didn't Eddleston own both those bitches? Brynne and the swans?Ah Hawthorn supporters- such high expectations for their team, but such low standards for their women.
All you'd need is a cattle prod and some rope.Are you two both femsle? With that rack, who cares about that voice or that IQ? In fact the voice and the IQ could enhance the experience.
I said I have standards. Not Morals.Are you two both femsle? With that rack, who cares about that voice or that IQ? In fact the voice and the IQ could enhance the experience.

Wrong thread mate, this thread is about Bryne Edlestone!!!!Anyone looking at Jason Johannisen? Doggies supporters, thoughts on JJ?

Crouch is my M7. I don't know who to upgrade to for aish thoughParish is still classified as rookie price because he is under 220 but I see you point. Personally I wouldn't be running with Crouch and Aish if you have De Goey. I'm assuming that Crouch is your M6? If you dropped him to Mills or a rookie you could start upgrading Aish to a more reliable pick at D4. I only say this because if Aish doesn't fire early you're gonna be stuck for options. That's why I've gone Whitecross at D5 and not at D4. I have no doubt he could come in and average 85+ but if he doesn't it's nice to know that you haven't messed your whole season up on taking a risk.
Make a list of who you think the top 15 defenders will be at the end of the season and pick from one of those.Crouch is my M7. I don't know who to upgrade to for aish though
Yep, and it's amazing how much our on-field fortunes improved once we ejected the last corrupted vestiges of the Melbourne old-boy's club from the premises.Didn't Eddleston own both those bitches? Brynne and the swans?
I think that he's a solid pick and someone who could definitely improve on last year, scored 4 100's last year so he's capable but with Boyd and Murphy still going strong it'll be hard for him to maintain 90s every game enough for him to be a keeper, it looks as if Stevens has also moved to the similar role, Biggs was also there last year. It could be a Hawthorn situation where they all average about the same, or like it was last year, 2 of them doing the majority of the scoring and the rest chipping in when needed.Anyone looking at Jason Johannisen? Doggies supporters, thoughts on JJ?
anyone care to speculate why Malcheski is on the nose? Seems like value to me.Update: Most popular defenders as at 28 February 2016:
1. M.Brown (Ess) (48%)
2. Aish (24%)
3. Shaw (23%)
4. Smith (20%)
5. Yeo (20%)
6. Bartel (16%)
7. Francis (16%)
8. Weitering (15%)
9. Broad (14%) on the rise
10. K.Kolodjashnij (14%)
11. Hartley (14%)
12. Bonner (13%)
13. McVeigh (13%)
14. Rich (12%)
15. Rance (12%)
16. K.Collins (12%)
17. M.Brown (WC) (12%)
18. Malceski (11%) on the nose
19. Hibberd (NM) (11%)
20. Suckling (11%)
The players seem to speak positively about Howe getting game time but he didn't seem to cope well yesterday under a fast moving ball. I don't think Hawthorn will rush him in, they have plenty of options down back. Gibson, Frawley, Stratton, Duryea, Birchall, Burgoyne, Hodge, Litherland, Hartung, Whitecross, Mitchell rested down back last year, Gunstan at times went to half back last year. I'd think if all those guys are already in the 22, maybe not Litherland, then it's going to be hard for Howe to get a go in there.