Analysis 2016 List Management Discussion

[TheCoach16]

ive had to eliminate meat, dairy, coffee, donuts and gluten.

That's all the five food groups!

 

[Iamcarlton]

I'd brace for disappointment mate.

Yes most likely id be filthy if we gave up pick 5 for those gws boys later first rounder should do it .

 

[HBF]

silvagni signed until 2018

Very happy.
Doubt SOS would even consider playing for another team.

 

[ParapMarkets]

Why? Different team making the decision.

SOS probably knows Marchbank amd Pickett are much better than Jaksch and Whiley

Or he knows them the same, hence happy to trade 2 out and then 2 years later trade the other 2 in.

 

[ParapMarkets]

Gold coast have got rocks in their heads if they did that Everitt graham trade imo .

Ssshhhhhh

 

[BlueTongue]

I think Levi on a one year deal is a great idea. And I'd keep doing that year on year. Give him some incentive to improve.

Besides, until we have a replacement putting their hand up to take his spot what are our options? We need a mature big body. Harry is still 2 years away.

That's a bit farsighted. I'd say he'll already be regular 22 within 2 years. He'll fill out plenty over the next 2 preseasons one would think.

 

[agro]

Really hope Byrne is right to go in Feb-Mar 2017..

He did his knee early July - even with a full recovery and a rehabilitation with no complications it's unlikely we'd see him back till June (next year) at best.

 

[Iamcarlton]

Ssshhhhhh

Your right shut the ****up iamcarlton!

 

[ParapMarkets]

Imagine if he wanted to explore his options..

Or imagine if SOS strategically traded him out for a draft pick so he could grab another gaggle of GWS kids.

 

[Aphrodite]

Or imagine if SOS strategically traded him out for a draft pick so he could grab another gaggle of GWS kids.

Child abuse.

 

[BlueTongue]

Unless SoS really rates Pickett I dont like that trade.. but prepared to back him in.

Agreed - Pick 5 is worth too much to us. Would rather have a crack at the draft pool than roll the dice on Picket. Marchbank i'd go for with a later pick.

 

[RudyBlue]

Given we have such an interest in Marchbank, we have to at least consider that there's a very good reason for that to be the case........but I don't think that the reason would be; "Let's stack our backline to the hilt at the expense of other areas of the ground"

I just see Weitering playing forward.
With Docherty, Plowman, Byrne and possibly Marchbank down back and that we're resolute in playing a team defence, we may not need Weitering at full-back as much as we think we may.

The guy is an aerobic beast, a leader, has a straight kick and reads the ball as well as anyone.......I just see him as forward, going.....forward.

The way he played against WC with that niggle, I reckon he could step in and kick 35-40 next year.

 

[ESKIE]

I really don't want to give up pick 5

 

[RudyBlue]

Cripps is going to have his work cut out that's for sure.

Has a genuine contested ball addiction. Not sure we could keep him out of it if we tried.

 

[BringBackSimmo]

Or imagine if SOS strategically traded him out for a draft pick so he could grab another gaggle of GWS kids.

Which pick though?

 

[AB_Blue]

Or imagine if SOS strategically traded him out for a draft pick so he could grab another gaggle of GWS kids.

[emoji35][emoji35]
Check yo self before you wreak yo self.......fool


*may or may not be sarcasm

 

[BlueTongue]

Meh, ruckman are overrated. Show me an All Australian ruckman in a premiership side, the last one was Dean Cox, a next level goat. Every other premiership side get's it done with part timers. What did Nic Nat do in the grannie last year? Ruckman are the LAST thing a side should focus on.

Can't agree. Nic Nat is a matchwinner and West Coast play a lot better with him in the side. Where did North go when Goldstein got injured? Their end to the 9 straight pretty much co-insides with his injury. Max Gawn takes his game to the next level and low & behold Melbourne start winning some games. No co-incidences in these cases.

 

[ESKIE]

Can't agree. Nic Nat is a matchwinner and West Coast play a lot better with him in the side. Where did North go when Goldstein got injured? Their end to the 9 straight pretty much co-insides with his injury. Max Gawn takes his game to the next level and low & behold Melbourne start winning some games. No co-incidences in these cases.

Mummy has been pretty important to GWS

 

[Beer n Skittles]

Can't agree. Nic Nat is a matchwinner and West Coast play a lot better with him in the side. Where did North go when Goldstein got injured? Their end to the 9 straight pretty much co-insides with his injury. Max Gawn takes his game to the next level and low & behold Melbourne start winning some games. No co-incidences in these cases.

Yep. I have no idea how anyone can watch a WCE game & not notice their midfield stinks whenever Nic Nat isn't on the ground

 

[Dominator68]

Mummy has been pretty important to GWS

Understatement of the year

 

[Azul]

That's all the five food groups!

Chocolate not on the list but..

 

[Alice]

Yep. I have no idea how anyone can watch a WCE game & not notice their midfield stinks whenever Nic Nat isn't on the ground

They played OK against Adelaide

 

[Weiterbot23]

what a homesick ACL

Makes sense

He is facing 1 year in a lonely rehab room away from his friend ms and family, then another year in the NEAFL as there's no way anyone with 2 knees is breaking into that side straight away.

Why not ask to come home to a team that is more likely to give you a crack in the seniors one you get yourself right.

 

[thylacine60]

Not sure I like the "you'll get a game for us regardless of circumstances". Has a touch of Daisy about it.

 

[ferrisb]

Hahaha.. mate I wish!! I've been recently diagnosed with Rheumatoid Arthritis and have gone from running around playing cricket at 46 to being bed ridden at 48. The drugs I'm on have horrific side effects so ive had to eliminate meat, dairy, coffee, donuts and gluten. The good news is im pretty well much pain free. The bad news is I eat like a tree hugging, hippie whale watcher.

Great to hear you are better now KP, but I'd choose pain....