Care to elaborate?The state of that
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Care to elaborate?The state of that
Your post was a mess mate.Care to elaborate?
I’d have Ainsworth and Bowes in the top 10. Bowes has a lot of similar attributes to McCluggage, though is a little more inside than Cluga.Would have been perfect for the suns as a team that lacks leadership. Berry's proffesionalism and leadership is phenomenal for a kid his age.
Suns could have done a lot better in this draft considering they had 4 picks inside the top 10 from memory. If the draft were redone today I don't think any of those players would feature in the top 10.
I’ll take the field against McGrath.McGrath will hold onto that number 1 spot IMO, His speed is just electric.
I’ll take the field against McGrath.
I expect Taranto (2), McCluggage(3) and Berry (17) to go past McGrath this year.
With Florent and Bowes pushing up as well.
McGrath would basically have to become a version of Lachie Neale to be in the race to be best from the 2016 draft. And I haven’t seen that from him yet.
Here's my top 11 (no particular order), I think these 11 players are a cut above the rest of the draft at this stage.I’d have Ainsworth and Bowes in the top 10. Bowes has a lot of similar attributes to McCluggage, though is a little more inside than Cluga.
We’ve certainly fast tracked the development of our first 3 picks from 2016. Much more so than the Suns top picks from 2016.
I’m expecting Ainsworth, Bowes and Brodie to cement spots this year in the Suns midfield.
Still can't provide a sensible retort to a differing opinion.Your post was a mess mate.
Still can't provide a sensible retort to a differing opinion.
Reality is McGrath showed little real improvement in 2018 from his impressive debut season as compared to the top end of his draft class.
I think it could be Taranto. He's was covering 15k's a game late last year indicating he's git endurance sorted, and looks like becoming more central in our midfield set ups.My tip is Simpkin and Florent will be the movers in 2019 from this draft - both played every game last year and both have some handy tricks when they get the ball. If they can both push up close to 20 touches a game they will become very good players.
My tip is Simpkin and Florent will be the movers in 2019 from this draft - both played every game last year and both have some handy tricks when they get the ball. If they can both push up close to 20 touches a game they will become very good players.
I’ll take the field against McGrath.
I expect Taranto (2), McCluggage(3) and Berry (17) to go past McGrath this year.
With Florent and Bowes pushing up as well.
McGrath would basically have to become a version of Lachie Neale to be in the race to be best from the 2016 draft. And I haven’t seen that from him yet.
It wasn't a comparison.Don't really see the Neale comparison at all. McGrath hopefully becomes a dynamic inside outside player who uses his pace/agility to exit a stoppage.
It wasn't a comparison.
Have a similar impact for his team as a smaller mid who has a greater impact than his size would suggest."A version of Lachie Neale" if that's not a comparison then what is it?
I think it could be Taranto. He's was covering 15k's a game late last year indicating he's git endurance sorted, and looks like becoming more central in our midfield set ups.
I don’t see Taranto as a big riser in this draft - he is a gun already - him and McCluggage are 1 & 2.
My 2 movers are more to do with pushing into the top 10 and maybe top 5.
Here's my top 11 (no particular order), I think these 11 players are a cut above the rest of the draft at this stage.
Mcgrath, Taranto, McCluggage, Florent, Marshall, Berry, Hayward, Witherden, Fisher, Parfitt and Stewart.
Bowes and Ainsworth would be in the next bracket down for me along with Simpkin, Logue, Venables, Galluci, Perryman, SPP, English, Ridley, Brown, Darcy, Battle and SPS.
I'd argue Brodie is the most deserving of a top 10 pick still at this point. Worth noting that over 8 games (including round 21 when he was taken off injured half way through the second quarter) was ranked:I’d have Ainsworth and Bowes in the top 10. Bowes has a lot of similar attributes to McCluggage, though is a little more inside than Cluga.
We’ve certainly fast tracked the development of our first 3 picks from 2016. Much more so than the Suns top picks from 2016.
I’m expecting Ainsworth, Bowes and Brodie to cement spots this year in the Suns midfield.
Reckon you're underrating Hayward a bit there. He is an absolute jet and has put in some excellent performances against quality opposition, and has held down a spot in a very solid Swans side. Finished 2nd in the Swans goal kicking in 2018 behind only Buddy. Has shown a lot more than a few of the players you've got ahead of him.How I see it now after 2 years in the system:
1. Taranto
2. McCluggage
3. Stewart
4. McGrath
5. Witherden
6. Marshall
7. Powell-Pepper
8. Fisher
9. Florent
10. Bowes
11. Berry
12. Petrevski-Seton
13.Parfitt
14. Ainsworth
15. Perryman
16. Long
17. Ratugolea
18. Ryan
19. Hayward
20. Simpkin
* Haven't seen enough of due to various reasons:
Darcy, Setterfield, Logue, Venables, Scrimshaw and Williamson.
How I see it after 10 years in the system (classy/match winning players): TOP 10 ONLY
1. McCluggage
2. Petrevski-Seton
3. Taranto
4. Witherden
5. Fisher
6. McGrath
7. Marshall
8. Setterfield
9. Bowes
10. Berry
* I UNDERSTAND ALL CALLING ME OUT FOR CARLTON BIAS (WHICH I TOTALLY UNDERSTAND), HOWEVER QUIETLY CONFIDENT SPS & SETTERFIELD WILL SHOW WHY THEY WERE RATED SO HIGHLY AFTER FINALLY GETTING A PRE-SEASON UNDER THEIR BELT. FISHER IS A JET..WILL CONTINUE GETTING BETTER
* Great haul by Brisbane.
Reckon you're underrating Hayward a bit there. He is an absolute jet and has put in some excellent performances against quality opposition, and has held down a spot in a very solid Swans side. Finished 2nd in the Swans goal kicking in 2018 behind only Buddy. Has shown a lot more than a few of the players you've got ahead of him.
Fair call. Haven't seen as much of him as the others I've rated. Will have a closer look this year.Reckon you're underrating Hayward a bit there. He is an absolute jet and has put in some excellent performances against quality opposition, and has held down a spot in a very solid Swans side. Finished 2nd in the Swans goal kicking in 2018 behind only Buddy. Has shown a lot more than a few of the players you've got ahead of him.
1. Taranto
2. English
3. Mcluggage
4. McGrath
5. Setterfield
6. Ainsworth
7. Stewart
8. Brodie
9. Berry
10. Witherdan
11. Fisher
12. Morrison
12. Marshall
13. Brown
14. Hayward
15. Graham
16. Bowes
17. Ratugolea
18. Simpkin
19. Perryman
20. Florent
Didn't include rookies
This is how I'd go