List Mgmt. 2017 draft thread

[Mr Magic]

Gus Brayshaw is a gun but kid cant get on the park, He is the best pure footballer with better skills

Yeah I know the bigger older one is rated higher in the draft and arguably more credentialed but I like the younger ones polish and movement and it has not come as a surprise to me he has moved up the phantoms over the course of the year

 

[smurfin]

Its interesting.

Freo have pick 5 which if they use it on Naish they are welcome to him I would have thought, next pick 40 unless they most likely have another pick in mind.

Bulldogs have pick 9 which again they would be welcome to Naish if thats the pick they choose to use on Naish. Next is 26 which would be getting to the area one would think unless they are looking at a pick like 17 from Essendon via Richmond for Stringer.

Brisbane are looking at picks 1 and 12 firstly which one would think RFC would not challenge on, Then Brisbanes next pick is 18 which starts to get interesting.

This is from an article by Ben Guthrie which I find amazing. "Richmond has selections No.15 and No.17 in the first round of this year's draft and it is highly likely the Tigers will have to select him with one of those picks even if another club does not lodge a bid for Naish."

The bold is particularly amazing. Even if another club does not lodge RFC while use 15 or 17 on Naish as if the people at RFC are condemned to win a Darwin Award!!!!

I agree that the bold is bullshit. By my analysis, if Naish isn't bid on before pick 17 we use both those picks on other players in the draft. Worst case, he is then bid on pick 18 - 2nd round means flat 197 point discount for us to match, we need to pick up ~ pick 50 in addition to our current 52,53,70 to avoid using next year's points. We would need 5 genuine list spots to take 15,17,~50,52,53 to the draft. Maric, Yarran, Hunt, Elton + 1 traded out. Easy.
Surely we can get pick 50 or equivalent points upgrade to existing picks through Miles, Lloyd or whoever requests a trade. We then have a good chance on getting 3 top 20 draftees without affecting next year's draft.

 

[Stengle26]

Operation get bonar if hes there at 15!!! Could end up the best player in the draft. Aka burton.

 

[THE_GUN]

We need a bid for Naish at #27 to break even with our 2 x 3rd rounders


#50 + #53 =506 points
#27 = 703 points

703
506 -
--------
197 (discount applied

 

[TigersMP4]

We need a bid for Naish at #27 to break even with our 2 x 3rd rounders


#50 + #53 =506 points
#27 = 703 points

703
506 -
--------
197 (discount applied

don't think he'll slide that far. Hopefully we can manufacture a trade for a 2nd rounder so we can keep our options open.

 

[TigersMP4]

A kid i'm really starting to like the look of is Aiden Bonar just killed the combine and would probably be in top 5 contention if not for his injury history

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-10-05/bonar-turning-heads-with-stunning-combine-results

 

[Charlie Pannam]

A kid i'm really starting to like the look of is Aiden Bonar just killed the combine and would probably be in top 5 contention if not for his injury history

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-10-05/bonar-turning-heads-with-stunning-combine-results

Was reading about this guy and his injury woes.
Interesting to see which clubs got the balls to use an early pick on him.

 

[Calcium Man]

Was reading about this guy and his injury woes.
Interesting to see which clubs got the balls to use an early pick on him.

If we have our picks still and he lasts to us think we will, although he is rising fast along with Bradshaw.

 

[thetradesman]

Think we could take a risk on some kids with injury clouds tbh.

 

[4tune8]

along with Balta

 

[Charlie Pannam]

Bonar could be a similar scenario to Burton from the Hawks, although his injury woes don't sound anywhere near as bad.

 

[tunksy]

Bishop thoughts on tom mcartin? Had a good yo yo test result. Could he fit in at chf in the future?

 

[Bishop]

Bishop thoughts on tom mcartin? Had a good yo yo test result. Could he fit in at chf in the future?

Will be a late pick, has a late birthday too. As I've said time and time again - I'd only take a KPF with a top 25 pick otherwise let them go. Strike rate very low.

 

[fargothegreat]

Any chance we take our other father son prospects in Broderick and Lambert?

Or the academy listed Derrick Smith?

 

[Vikingnz]

I don't know much about the draft, but if there was someone we really liked in the Top 10, could we package our 15 and 17 for say pick 10 (so Melbourne have 2 first rounders for Lever), and then hopefully that pick comes ahead of any Naish bid?

 

[cairo tiger]

Bonar could be a similar scenario to Burton from the Hawks, although his injury woes don't sound anywhere near as bad.

Size?

 

[Tango67]

Can he play football?

 

[docko911]

Need a pick in the low 30s/20s to match Naish or we will be taking a few players at the end of the draft.

Does anyone know if we can take 6 picks to the draft, I.e. 6 list spots free but draft only 4 but use the 6 picks to match Naish? Then just rookie list the last two, or do we have to nominate how many players we will be drafting and can’t sway from that?

If the latter it will be a big risk to take Naish with points and then cop two picks at the end of the draft.

 

[hanshotfirst]

Size?

listed at 190cm and 89kgs

 

[TigersMP4]

Bonar tested top 10 in 4 events.
Naish tested top 10 in 0 events.

 

[Tigers Time]

Bonar will be gone by our picks.

 

[HumanMeatball]

Bonar tested top 10 in 4 events.
Naish tested top 10 in 0 events.

Good boy naish. Hopefully not to late to tank

 

[TigersMP4]

Bonar will be gone by our picks.

i'm not so sure about that.

 

[brahj]

What's the ratio of guns in the combine to guns in the AFL?

 

[prodigy]

If Bonar is available at our pick, surely we take him.
I'd like to see us try and move up in the draft.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk