No Oppo Supporters 2017 General AFL Discussion

[Olian]

Out thought horse.

In what way?

 

[swansfan51]

How many less than 10?

Fremantle had 4 <10 games, GWS had 3 <10, Gold Coast had 3 <10, Richmond had 3 <10

I'm not sure why I bothered to dig this up for you. If another team won a match with 10 players <10 games, while losing the free kick count 20-3, interstate, you would rule it out because of the weather.

 

[Tedeski]

Fremantle had 4 <10 games, GWS had 3 <10, Gold Coast had 3 <10, Richmond had 3 <10

I'm not sure why I bothered to dig this up for you. If another team won a match with 10 players <10 games, while losing the free kick count 20-3, interstate, you would rule it out because of the weather.

Geez! Pretty ordinary team perfomance we've have!
I just didn't realise but those stats point it out.

So should we persist with the same team or bring back Rohan, Tippett, Naismith, Macca & Heeney.
I ask because you've convinced me that should they come into the team, it won't improve us so I think even if fit we should leave them out.
What do you think mate?

 

[swansfan51]

Geez! Pretty ordinary team perfomance we've have!
I just didn't realise but those stats point it out.

So should we persist with the same team or bring back Rohan, Tippett, Naismith, Macca & Heeney.
I ask because you've convinced me that should they come into the team, it won't improve us so I think even if fit we should leave them out.
What do you think mate?

I didn't say that, and you know full well I didn't.

You asked me a question, I've just answered it, and you clearly don't like the answer so you've constructed a straw man.

We play GWS next week, probably without a few of those <10 games players, we're at home, and GWS also have key best 22 players unavailable. So lets see how we go.

 

[Tedeski]

Do you think we can win it?

 

[The King!]

Very impressed with the Lions, they will be ok, some great kids who will get better

Shame they have struggled with retention, since they got rid of that rubbish recruiter have picked well

 

[The King!]

In what way?

Buckley coached buddy out of the game at the scg, couldnt even swing to the left, buckley had a defender every time go to buddys left foot to trap him in

Horse never changed a thing

 

[The King!]

Love tedeskis passion and fight, very defensive but thats being a good fan


But i suspect horse and co must be the same and wont acknowledge weakness and poor play either

 

[swansfan51]

Do you think we can win it?

We should win it. We're at home, they're missing 3 guns from their midfield and we should have our full strength midfield available, we should have Tippett back, and they have a 2 day shorter break than we do.

So yes, we should absolutely win.

 

[Tedeski]

Very impressed with the Lions, they will be ok, some great kids who will get better

They were shit Bedders!
They had 11 players with less than 50 games experience but Richmond had 9 of their own.

 

[The King!]

We should win it. We're at home, they're missing 3 guns from their midfield and we should have our full strength midfield available, we should have Tippett back, and they have a 2 day shorter break than we do.

So yes, we should absolutely win.

Who are you tipping?

I think regardless of who is back ill be tipping GWS,think they have a better plan and structure,

 

[Tedeski]

We should win it. We're at home, they're missing 3 guns from their midfield and we should have our full strength midfield available, we should have Tippett back, and they have a 2 day shorter break than we do.

So yes, we should absolutely win.

So you tipping us?

 

[swansfan51]

Who are you tipping?

I think regardless of who is back ill be tipping GWS,think they have a better plan and structure,

I tipped us to beat West Coast and I will tip us to beat GWS. The only game I haven't tipped us in was the Bulldogs, because they've had our measure for years.

 

[The King!]

I tipped us to beat West Coast and I will tip us to beat GWS. The only game I haven't tipped us in was the Bulldogs, because they've had our measure for years.

Fair enough, think Leon Cameron has Horses measure personally

i also think our midfield is becoming a bit of a one man band

 

[Number37]

Love tedeskis passion and fight, very defensive but thats being a good fan


But i suspect horse and co must be the same and wont acknowledge weakness and poor play either

Hiding your snarkiness behind smilies is childish.
You don't get to 3 GF's in 6 years if you are shit coach. No matter how good your list.
We have plenty of shortcomings and our game style attempts to accommodate that.
I don't agree with the forward setup but (1) it wouldn't matter how good a forward setup if we kick like we do (2) We don't have any run & gun midfielders to break the lines between the arcs. Bomb it long results.
To continually put shit on the coach for the shortcomings of the team as a whole displays a distinct lack of knowledge of the team.

 

[Olian]

Buckley coached buddy out of the game at the scg, couldnt even swing to the left, buckley had a defender every time go to buddys left foot to trap him in

Horse never changed a thing

Fair enough Buddy is predominantly a left footer. It only takes little things and in a 1 point game it helps.

 

[Olian]

I think it's Bob Murphy's 300th this week so they may mention it in the media.

 

[The King!]

Hiding your snarkiness behind smilies is childish.
You don't get to 3 GF's in 6 years if you are shit coach. No matter how good your list.
We have plenty of shortcomings and our game style attempts to accommodate that.
I don't agree with the forward setup but (1) it wouldn't matter how good a forward setup if we kick like we do (2) We don't have any run & gun midfielders to break the lines between the arcs. Bomb it long results.
To continually put shit on the coach for the shortcomings of the team as a whole displays a distinct lack of knowledge of the team.

Whos being snarky ffs.


No one is putting shit on the team anywhere I can see, some people want to discuss why we cant win, get over it

 

[The King!]

I think it's Bob Murphy's 300th this week so they may mention it in the media.

Lol, afl 360 extended movie on the premiership captain who wasn't

 

[Number37]

Whos being snarky ffs.


No one is putting shit on the team anywhere I can see, some people want to discuss why we cant win, get over it

'Horse is a shit coach' is not a discussion.
Repeating 'Horse is a shit coach' over and over and over is not a discussion either.

 

[The King!]

'Horse is a shit coach' is not a discussion.
Repeating 'Horse is a shit coach' over and over and over is not a discussion either.

Whinging about what everyone posts adds nothing at all either, but you keep doing it,

No one is saying he is shit by suggesting he lacks a backup plan or uses forwards poorly, he has a talented enough list to do better in some peoples opinions, guess we rate the team higher than yourself. Each to their own.

Disagree all you want but trying to label anyone who disagrees with you as clueless is pretty piss poor

 

[Number37]

Disagree all you want but trying to label anyone who disagrees with you as clueless is pretty piss poor

Exactly.

 

[Tedeski]

Buckley coached buddy out of the game at the scg, couldnt even swing to the left, buckley had a defender every time go to buddys left foot to trap him in

Horse never changed a thing

Oops!
Looks like that must have just been an accident!

http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/af...s/news-story/d2dbc43b126c1764c81e21cb97798c30

 

[The King!]

Oops!
Looks like that must have just been an accident!

http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/af...s/news-story/d2dbc43b126c1764c81e21cb97798c30

Yeah wheres Horses team? Whats your point

 

[The King!]

Exactly.

If i did that to you I sincerely apologise (thats not meant to sound sarcastic)


For the record i find Horse lacking some fresh ideas, but is he shit, not at all. If i say that in then its most likely stressed in the midst of a game