Position 2017 Rookies

[atlas1]

How many rookies on-field is to many? I currently have 8.

8 for me as well

 

[Mex13]

SPS? Yes or No?

 

[Significant]

7 onfield rookies

Hampton, Otten, Hibberd
SPS, SPP
Taranto, Turner

only $20k left but have got some expensive rookies with Ollie Florrie on my mid bench also, so can downgrade if someone else raises their hand!

 

[atlas1]

SPS? Yes or No?

Yes for me at the moment, due to good JS

 

[PoopingHindi]

How many rookies on-field is to many? I currently have 8.

7 and a speculative mid-pricer that may well be outscored by the rookies

 

[PoopingHindi]

7 onfield rookies

Hampton, Otten, Hibberd
SPS, SPP
Taranto, Turner

only $20k left but have got some expensive rookies with Ollie Florrie on my mid bench also, so can downgrade if someone else raises their hand!

swap Hibberd for Florent and thats me.

still unsure about SPS though. im going to spend 190k on a rookie i've never seen and start him on the field
at least at that price i can downgrade him to just about any other rookie if he turns out to be a spud

 

[The Lemon]

swap Hibberd for Florent and thats me.

still unsure about SPS though. im going to spend 190k on a rookie i've never seen and start him on the field
at least at that price i can downgrade him to just about any other rookie if he turns out to be a spud

corrective trades are needed. That's why i am going all out with expensive rooks

 

[Significant]

swap Hibberd for Florent and thats me.

still unsure about SPS though. im going to spend 190k on a rookie i've never seen and start him on the field
at least at that price i can downgrade him to just about any other rookie if he turns out to be a spud

Thats my theory but everyone talks him up. A midfield Cyril who loves a tackle and silky smooth. He is being named after no JLT must be a good sign. Although, I wonder if he is going to be the late out :/

 

[DraftPunk]

Still surprsied Marchbank is owned by 37%... other than JS and decent scores in JLT, what's the attraction? As an example, he needs to average 22ppg more than Smith to make the same amount of money.

 

[toxic]

Still surprsied Marchbank is owned by 37%... other than JS and decent scores in JLT, what's the attraction? As an example, he needs to average 22ppg more than Smith to make the same amount of money.

Job Security is gold

 

[TheBuzz]

Otten or Smith?

 

[dmc333]

Still surprsied Marchbank is owned by 37%... other than JS and decent scores in JLT, what's the attraction? As an example, he needs to average 22ppg more than Smith to make the same amount of money.

My theory revolves around JS and the amount of ball the Carlton back line will see.

 

[toxic]

Otten or Smith?

Both

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Still surprsied Marchbank is owned by 37%... other than JS and decent scores in JLT, what's the attraction? As an example, he needs to average 22ppg more than Smith to make the same amount of money.

That's why 37% have him.
I'm with you though and unlikely that I will take him.

 

[pincrusher]

How many rookies on-field is to many? I currently have 8.

I have five but zero first year players.

 

[big bootaaaaah]

I wish I had Biff's almanac

 

[Keg on legs]

It's 3 hours away and I can't decide on marchbank


Decisions to be made

 

[big bootaaaaah]

It's 3 hours away and I can't decide on marchbank


Decisions to be made

Me neither.

 

[TheOz]

Still surprsied Marchbank is owned by 37%... other than JS and decent scores in JLT, what's the attraction? As an example, he needs to average 22ppg more than Smith to make the same amount of money.

JS and the fact that he averaged around 80 odd in the pre-season and looks a player. Not worth the spend with the backline rookies available for selection.

 

[enobrien]

It's 3 hours away and I can't decide on marchbank


Decisions to be made

His JS is pretty certain. My worries are injury history, and what he has to avg to make decent money compared to a Smith etc

Not taking him fwiw!

 

[Double the Fist]

Interesting to note, both Marchbank and Elliot only played two games each last year.

Kinda puts me off!!!

 

[TheOz]

His JS is pretty certain. My worries are injury history, and what he has to avg to make decent money compared to a Smith etc

Not taking him fwiw!

Gotta go at least 80 to make enough cash to justify the spend.

 

[Souup]

Still surprsied Marchbank is owned by 37%... other than JS and decent scores in JLT, what's the attraction? As an example, he needs to average 22ppg more than Smith to make the same amount of money.

Carlton will have the ball in their back line a crapton. Simpson and Docherty averaged 100+. Touhy 80+ and White, Byrne and Weitering all 68+.

Marchbank is a better footballer and finds it more than White and Byrne. Weitering was a first year kpd. Touhy has left and someone needs to get those points.

80-85 for Marchbank for me.

 

[enobrien]

Gotta go at least 80 to make enough cash to justify the spend.

Seems do-able in a Carlton backline, just dont have the nuts big enough

 

[Goody1971]

It's 3 hours away and I can't decide on marchbank


Decisions to be made

I have pulled the plug on him now that Hibberd and Smith are playing