The Clayton debate (abuse) has been done to death but essentially, this.
He was decent at identifying talent and finding some gems late, as he proved over the 3 clubs.
However, you still have to be able to fill out a list with different types of players and build a well rounded squad, not just go for the home- run, potential-filled pick every time. Clayton never proved that he could do that as you can see with our list mis-management since inception. (Although 2014 looked like we could be well on our way).
He was a talent scout but not a list manager's a-hole
On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app
He was decent at identifying talent and finding some gems late, as he proved over the 3 clubs.
However, you still have to be able to fill out a list with different types of players and build a well rounded squad, not just go for the home- run, potential-filled pick every time. Clayton never proved that he could do that as you can see with our list mis-management since inception. (Although 2014 looked like we could be well on our way).