Analysis 2018 List Management discussion Pt 2

[HereComesJuddy]

Interesting u lump yourself in as a cohort Crush.
There’s just been a lot of over top opinion of late and some people taking time to think rationally and having an open mind to different ideas, others who get fixated on an idea & won’t let go.
The -we can’t do this, or have to do that, the afl is a conspiracy, salary caps don’t count, singling out one word in a sentence and running worked it (completely out of context) is getting tiresome.
Open, thoughtful, dialogue & discussion would be nice for a change, we all have an opinion but a little respect isn’t to much to ask. U don’t have to agree, but the idea is to come back with a valid reason why

You post amazes me!

You just go all high and mighty about people respecting other peoples opinions... Not calling out people on the use of 1 word. Yet no more than 24 hours ago you did the opposite!

Im not having a go, but you're a big culprit in what you're trying to stop.

Anyways, i hope you stick to your above post. Have a great day!

 

[HarryFlashman]

View attachment 519854 View attachment 519855

You post amazes me!

You just go all high and mighty about people respecting other peoples opinions... Not calling out people on the use of 1 word. Yet no more than 24 hours ago you did the opposite!

Im not having a go, but you're a big culprit in what you're trying to stop.

Anyways, i hope you stick to your above post. Have a great day!

So u take a couple posts, take out the context of the conversation they relate to & use your “evidence”.
Looks like u took “spouting” crap to heart, sorry if it hurt your feelings

 

[HereComesJuddy]

So u take a couple posts, take out the context of the conversation they relate to & use your “evidence”.
Looks like u took “spouting” crap to heart, sorry if it hurt your feelings

You dont hurt my feelings Harry. You actually make me laugh

 

[Metalcrusher]

Interesting u lump yourself in as a cohort Crush.
There’s just been a lot of over top opinion of late and some people taking time to think rationally and having an open mind to different ideas, others who get fixated on an idea & won’t let go.
The -we can’t do this, or have to do that, the afl is a conspiracy, salary caps don’t count, singling out one word in a sentence and running worked it (completely out of context) is getting tiresome.
Open, thoughtful, dialogue & discussion would be nice for a change, we all have an opinion but a little respect isn’t to much to ask. U don’t have to agree, but the idea is to come back with a valid reason why

I am fixated on a idea of where I want the club to go … and I have my own pre conceived ideas on what we should be doing to get there ….

Just so we are clear …

1. Bolts stays
2. SOS stays
3. Dunno much about the board (no comment here)
4. Andy Mac … I really don't know exactly what his job was to comment if he was achieving any KPI's. Seems a good time to move along … considering I see him as part of the old regime that bought us **** all. The 1-2 week thing is just a bloody funny joke (I often wonder if that was his version of twisted humour at times)
5. Only way you can clean house is bringing in the BEST possible talent every year. Draft best talent available at that pick regardless of position.
6. FA should be used to draft for specific needs, and fills specific shortfalls the draft cannot plug.
7. We need to bolster the midfield ASAP. You can never have enough midfielders. You always turn a good midfielder into a HB or HF. Harder IMHO to turn a set HBF into a clearance mid. This way your arc players D50 to centre to F50 become so much more flexible from a coaching point of view. (More strings to the bow etc ..)
8. Talls take longer so you will never see me bag them often if at all.
9. I refrain from character slaughtering 1-3 year players. Ridiculous expecting them to play like 24 yo's .
10. I don't have much time for recycled players (delisted) as I believe they were delisted for a reason … mostly being not up to AFL.

If these things align with any other posters … then I guess I'm a cohort lol!

As I said carry on

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Damn, guess I'm not the only one who gets into the drawn out arguments on here...

Calm down guys, the game is going to start soon. Let's watch and support the team instead.

 

[HarryFlashman]

I am fixated on a idea of where I want the club to go … and I have my own pre conceived ideas on what we should be doing to get there ….

Just so we are clear …

1. Bolts stays
2. SOS stays
3. Dunno much about the board (no comment here)
4. Andy Mac … I really don't know exactly what his job was to comment if he was achieving any KPI's. Seems a good time to move along … considering I see him as part of the old regime that bought us **** all. The 1-2 week thing is just a bloody funny joke (I often wonder if that was his version of twisted humour at times)
5. Only way you can clean house is bringing in the BEST possible talent every year. Draft best talent available at that pick regardless of position.
6. FA should be used to draft for specific needs, and fills specific shortfalls the draft cannot plug.
7. We need to bolster the midfield ASAP. You can never have enough midfielders. You always turn a good midfielder into a HB or HF. Harder IMHO to turn a set HBF into a clearance mid. This way your arc players D50 to centre to F50 become so much more flexible from a coaching point of view. (More strings to the bow etc ..)
8. Talls take longer so you will never see me bag them often if at all.
9. I refrain from character slaughtering 1-3 year players. Ridiculous expecting them to play like 24 yo's .
10. I don't have much time for recycled players (delisted) as I believe they were delisted for a reason … mostly being not up to AFL.

If these things align with any other posters … then I guess I'm a cohort lol!

As I said carry on

Mate, throw in “look/explore” the opportunity to trade 1 for a couple picks- keeping one & using the other for a gun & I 100% agree entirely with you.

 

[Metalcrusher]

Damn, guess I'm not the only one who gets into the drawn out arguments on here...

Calm down guys, the game is going to start soon. Let's watch and support the team instead.

heck that! Lets fight!

 

[Metalcrusher]

Mate, throw in “look/explore” the opportunity to trade 1 for a couple picks- keeping one & using the other for a gun & I 100% agree entirely with you.

Yeah forgot that one …. In my opinion you should NEVER trade a top 1-6/7 pick unless you can leverage the shit out of another team to a massive benefit of ours.

For example only … IF we land pick 1 …. bend Adelaide over for 3 inside first round picks …. say 8/9/23 (or whatever it is without checking ….).

I do not see the need to trade this years first for Shiel now …. I can see the appeal in that though.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Really? Are u saying he’s not inspirational and lifts those around him when he’s making 2nd, 3rd & 4th efforts.
If u want to make this personal it really shows your quality as a person.
It wasn’t an angry post, it was disputing the rubbish u and your cohorts are spouting

Did not miss Kruezer at all today and my opinion hasn't changed. Kruezer is not a key player moving forward. Think Phillips should be our permanent ruckman moving forward if Im honest.

 

[HarryFlashman]

Did not miss Kruezer at all today and my opinion hasn't changed. Kruezer is not a key player moving forward. Think Phillips should be our permanent ruckman moving forward if Im honest.

Make that call before the game you hero

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Make that call before the game you hero

Told you yesterday I wanted to move Kruezer on, didn't I? But then you crapped on about how indispensable he is. Which he isn't.

 

[The Blue Baggers]

Told you yesterday I wanted to move Kruezer on, didn't I? But then you crapped on about how indispensable he is. Which he isn't.

Phillips is a better ruck nowadays !!

 

[The Blue Baggers]

Need to go

Graham
Mullett
O'Shea
Rowe
Polson
Lamb

 

[Metalcrusher]

Need to go

Graham
Mullett
O'Shea
Rowe
Polson
Lamb

Try again. You were close though.

 

[The Blue Baggers]

Try again. You were close though.

Acknowledge some need to stay for the minute but all will not be in our next finals team !!

 

[Arr0w]

Need to go

Graham
Mullett
O'Shea
Rowe
Polson
Lamb

Polson will stay and in time you will like it

 

[Metalcrusher]

Acknowledge some need to stay for the minute but all will not be in our next finals team !!

Agreed!

 

[The Blue Baggers]

Polson will stay and in time you will like it

I hope your right !!

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Need to go

Graham
Mullett
O'Shea
Rowe
Polson
Lamb

That's a no for me. I really like Polson. I really like his intent despite the brainfarts.

 

[The Blue Baggers]

That's a no for me. I really like Polson. I really like his intent despite the brainfarts.

Hope your right , compared to the others he at least has sometime to improve !!

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Acknowledge some need to stay for the minute but all will not be in our next finals team !!

One of them will be.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

#getgaff

 

[Pablito]

Interesting question.

Does anybody see Phillips as being a long term 1st choice ruck after kruezer finishes up?

Played well on ryder today imo.

 

[Metalcrusher]

Interesting question.

Does anybody see Phillips as being a long term 1st choice ruck after kruezer finishes up?

Played well on ryder today imo.

Yes ….. for a 2-3 year period though. He is a skilled tap ruckman. Our midfield just don't know quite how to work with him yet. He was getting qulity left and right .. sometimes backward taps today yet our midfielders got hammered in the CC. They are used to Krooz following up his ruck work with a clearance...…..

 

[Metalcrusher]

#getgaff

If we can mate …. we can only offer ….