2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[rocker_oz33]

Yep we need rookies.

I'm going to be in tassie in the early rounds do they have internet there? To do some rookie adjustments .

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Agree with you on Doedee but every man and his dog has already locked him in at D6.

Seen and heard a few doggies supporters state who they think their back 6 will be heading into round 1 and Naughton doesn't figure in any of their back 6's so I am skeptical on him. He does look good though.

Finlayson is a maybe. Looks good but GWS are a hard team to break into. Good if he gets a round 1 gig though.

Out of all the forward rookies you listed the only ones I would be semi confident atm starting round 1 would be Ryan and Fritsch. They both wont score that great though so would be worried starting them at F6.

My whole point with the forward rookies is that even if a few of them get a round 1 birth they will score like crap and do we really want to put up with that as our F6?

Lets see what the next few weeks bring I guess as things can change from here on end.....

F5/6 will be the first upgrade, we will only cop some crap for a short period (6 weeks Guys like Frisch can throw in the odd 90 like Hannan last year.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

What about Vardy? Had a very admirable year last year for WCE. Do they just throw him to the scrap heap? It's not Simon Madden returning from a long-term injury, it's Scott Lycett

Yes ....interesting Dilemma for WC ....also a dilemma for SC Coaches selecting Lycett

 

[Judd_Magic]

F5/6 will be the first upgrade, we will only cop some crap for a short period (6 weeks Guys like Frisch can throw in the odd 90 like Hannan last year.

Ahern and Frisch at F5 and F6 I can see a lot of people going with if Ahren shows something in the JLT.

He should get time on the wing and not be stuck in a forward pocket like Ryan.

 

[JustInsideFifty]

Yep we need rookies.

I'm going to be in tassie in the early rounds do they have internet there? To do some rookie adjustments .

Pretty sure Tassie has a higher % of fibre to the premises than any other state in Australia...
Fast internet won't help you find rookies any better though...

 

[Hai_Newman]

Yep we need rookies.

I'm going to be in tassie in the early rounds do they have internet there? To do some rookie adjustments .

Does your "Cousin" have the interwebs?

 

[Suma Magic]

Current thoughts on rough chances (out of 10) they end up in my team.

Defs:
- Laird 10
- Hibberd 9
- Sicily 7
- Yeo 5
- Hanley 3

Mids:
- Fyfe 10
- Cripps 8
- Danger 8
- Martin 7
- Kelly 5
- Coniglio 5
- Mitchell 3
- Oliver 2
- O'Meara 2

Rucks
- Gawn 10
- Jacobs 3
- Goldstein 3
- Lycett 2
- Kreuzer 2

Fwds
- Smith 8
- Christensen 8
- Walters 7
- Heeney 5
- Dahlhaus 3
- Barlow 3
- Billings 2

 

[Hai_Newman]

Current thoughts on rough chances (out of 10) they end up in my team.

Defs:
- Laird 10
- Hibberd 9
- Sicily 7
- Yeo 5
- Hanley 3

Mids:
- Fyfe 10
- Cripps 8
- Danger 8
- Martin 7
- Kelly 5
- Coniglio 5
- Mitchell 3
- Oliver 2
- O'Meara 2

Rucks
- Gawn 10
- Jacobs 3
- Goldstein 3
- Lycett 2
- Kreuzer 2

Fwds
- Smith 8
- Christensen 8
- Walters 7
- Heeney 5
- Dahlhaus 3
- Barlow 3
- Billings 2

Needs moar McGovern.

 

[Huttabito]

Yep we need rookies.

I'm going to be in tassie in the early rounds do they have internet there? To do some rookie adjustments .

Flick me your login details and I will ensure everything is done properly.

 

[atlas1]

Flick me your login details and I will ensure everything is done properly.

inb4 Huttabito swaps rocker oz's D1 out for Docherty

 

[blackshadow]

not going to move this until after JLT and i can get more stats.

McDonald, Z Smith and Gunners the only 3 I'm tossing between.

All rookies are placeholders so far

$79,800 left over

View attachment 464481

Looking good amigo.

Sent from my F8331 using Tapatalk

 

[Changa10]

Does your "Cousin" have the interwebs?

My cousin from another mother (aka my wife) has interwebs

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Needs moar McGovern.

Shooter is a shit truck and a waste of space. Sorry cuz

 

[blackshadow]

All these teams with a first year rookie at D5 and 2 first year rookies at F5 and F6 so they can bat 6 deep in their midfield are going go be in for a nasty shock come round 1 I reckon.

So far I just don't think it's feasible!

That's what trades are for!

You going with Roughie?

Sent from my F8331 using Tapatalk

 

[Suma Magic]

Needs moar McGovern.

Isn't at the top of my thinking. I think last year he scored better when played as a forward. Doubt he will get much time forward this year. Still should average 90-95 IMO.

Would have been good to get a look at him on Sunday, a pity that campaigner Gray ironed him out.

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

not going to move this until after JLT and i can get more stats.

McDonald, Z Smith and Gunners the only 3 I'm tossing between.

All rookies are placeholders so far

$79,800 left over

View attachment 464481

Shiel to Cripps
Cogs to Dow
Lycett to a decent R2

Like Zac Smith?

TheBeardAmigos

Bookmark this post by Marlowe . If Zac does the business, smack him out with a moustache smiley.

 

[Maddog4]

Team 1, thoughts

 

[BEEG]

Think of going Christensen as my F5 feel dirty.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Just logged into my team and Marchbank is D4 hmmm

 

[atlas1]

Just logged into my team and Marchbank is D4 hmmm

Whoops

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Venebles is raw but the club will pump games into him...
Do I trust him on field...um no.

No wonder he's raw then!

 

[ArdentEagle]

This would be my most mid priced team ever...Somehow it feels right.
(I did have Ah Chee in FWD and Pendles in mids but the injury forced a change of structure.)
I'm backing Cripps to score more than Pendles, I've got nearly 80k left. Could upgrade to Crouch but it'd leave me zero for upgrades

 

[Jcpdragonx]

This would be my most mid priced team ever...Somehow it feels right.
(I did have Ah Chee in FWD and Pendles in mids but the injury forced a change of structure.)
I'm backing Cripps to score more than Pendles, I've got nearly 80k left. Could upgrade to Crouch but it'd leave me zero for upgrades


View attachment 464658

Curnow looked pretty meh tonight, perhaps Sicily instead?

 

[ArdentEagle]

Curnow looked pretty meh tonight, perhaps Sicily instead?

Didn't see the game, thanks for the heads up...I really thought he looked most likely to break out.
Perhaps just getting into his rhythm??

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Didn't see the game, thanks for the heads up...I really thought he looked most likely to break out.
Perhaps just getting into his rhythm??

If he plays too much forward then he isn't worth it, I still think he doesn't have enough midfield experience at this level.