2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[ROOINYOU]

Good to be back for another year. $141k in the bank.

your bank isn't accurate...
No way we get 3 102K Def rookies this year!
More like 70k left.
apart from that though, I like it!

 

[SavDog23]

After changing countless times again. I've come to this team, and it's probably 95% what my Round 1 team will look like.
Unsure on Marchbank though atm. If by Round 1 I don't feel confident with him, then i'll probably downgrade him to a rookie, then EITHER upgrade Bundy -> Heeney, OR if I don't feel Lycett is up to it, Lycett ->Kreuzer/Ryder/Goldstein.
If I do Bundy -> Heeney, it means i'll have 5 keeper forwards, which means I don't have to worry about FWD rookies, as I can count the forward rookies that might play RD 1 on one hand.
Midfield is Locked.

 

[Flandersss]

After changing countless times again. I've come to this team, and it's probably 95% what my Round 1 team will look like.
Unsure on Marchbank though atm. If by Round 1 I don't feel confident with him, then i'll probably downgrade him to a rookie, then EITHER upgrade Bundy -> Heeney, OR if I don't feel Lycett is up to it, Lycett ->Kreuzer/Ryder/Goldstein.
If I do Bundy -> Heeney, it means i'll have 5 keeper forwards, which means I don't have to worry about FWD rookies, as I can count the forward rookies that might play RD 1 on one hand.
Midfield is Locked.

View attachment 464897

Love the Marchbank pick.

Solid team.

 

[ROOINYOU]

After changing countless times again. I've come to this team, and it's probably 95% what my Round 1 team will look like.
Unsure on Marchbank though atm. If by Round 1 I don't feel confident with him, then i'll probably downgrade him to a rookie, then EITHER upgrade Bundy -> Heeney, OR if I don't feel Lycett is up to it, Lycett ->Kreuzer/Ryder/Goldstein.
If I do Bundy -> Heeney, it means i'll have 5 keeper forwards, which means I don't have to worry about FWD rookies, as I can count the forward rookies that might play RD 1 on one hand.
Midfield is Locked.

View attachment 464897

IMO Vlastuin isn't good enough to take the D3 spot.
Great for a POD, just doesn't score highly or consistently enough. 5 scores of 60 or less last year...Yuck!
what do you expect him to average?
80-85 at a stretch.

 

[GT619]

Reckon you need a D4 premo in there, maybe cogs>Brodie & Mirra>Wilson

Good team otherwise mate

Thanks. I’ll take your advice under consideration.

 

[Flandersss]

Thanks

Anytime.

Good game last night btw.

 

[SavDog23]

IMO Vlastuin isn't good enough to take the D3 spot.
Great for a POD, just doesn't score highly or consistently enough. 5 scores of 60 or less last year...Yuck!
what do you expect him to average?
80-85 at a stretch.

Was carrying an injury during the first 7 games of last year. Missed 10 rounds, came back fully recovered and averaged 93 from round 17-23. 95 if you include finals.
Turns 24 this year so still has loads of improvement in him. I reckon he'll average 90+ for sure if he plays 20+ games.
Scored 91 in JLT, even though he had 5 clangers, which is a bit high for him. I think he'll be a great POD.

 

[GT619]

Anytime.

Good game last night btw.

Likewise good game. I’m testing the waters with coniglio see how he goes brodie was in his spot prior and had burton in D4 that’s my original plan. Just playing around with it

 

[Flandersss]

Likewise good game. I’m testing the waters with coniglio see how he goes brodie was in his spot prior and had burton in D4 that’s my original plan. Just playing around with it

Yeah that’s it.

I just think with hardly any def rookies showing up so far, it’s safer going a Burton type at D4. Mid rookies are everywhere lol

 

[GT619]

Yeah that’s it.

I just think with hardly any def rookies showing up so far, it’s safer going a Burton type at D4. Mid rookies are everywhere lol

Big time. If some go with coniglio in their teams they might see him as a keeper and grabbing the extra points to stay ahead

 

[St BKD]

60/40 favouring yes. My worry is he still skinny but he got 20 touches. Tough one.

My worry is Richo doesn't have the gonads to dump Gilbert and Weller. I think that's the only way Coff and Clark get a game. I'm praying he does.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[JDavey]

Wanted to see what a team looks like where I get in Kreuzer at the expense of taking any premium mid rookies. Only playing 5 rookies and have set and forget ruck structure.

Potential to fix by putting Hanley down to a Byrne/C.Ellis/A.Aliir type and putting the money into premium rookies. Seems good

 

[ROOINYOU]

Was carrying an injury during the first 7 games of last year. Missed 10 rounds, came back fully recovered and averaged 93 from round 17-23. 95 if you include finals.
Turns 24 this year so still has loads of improvement in him. I reckon he'll average 90+ for sure if he plays 20+ games.
Scored 91 in JLT, even though he had 5 clangers, which is a bit high for him. I think he'll be a great POD.

fair enough..
IMO D4 is the spot to back breakouts(if you can call it that with Vlas). I'd put him there and upgrade Marchbank by downgrading a FWD.
3 genuine premo DEF is how I roll..
FWIW.. I hope Vlastuin gets the 90+ for ya. I like his game, just not for me in SC.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Anytime.

Good game last night btw.

Pfft st.kilda are terrible, another year of disappointment comming up for you.soz campaigner

 

[bato]

I think as long as I can cover every line with at least ONE top 3 player in every position, I'll be really happy by the end of the year.

 

[St BKD]

Again I've made a million more changes. Never had Lycett but I have no idea who R2 should be and the Witts and wait and see strategy worked last year. Hoping he can be a solid stop gap until the best r2 presents himself.

BF has convinced me on Sicily. He was never in my plans at all. But the dual pos will be handy af and if he can average 85-90 and play 22 games I'm more than happy having him as a F6/D6 in my completed team.

J.Lloyd not 100% convinced on but he racks them and a steady improvement gives me confidence he is a good pick.

Criticism welcome... not really. This is the best team possible :-/. In all seriousness I would appreciate input... thanks.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[ROOINYOU]

View attachment 464925

I think as long as I can cover every line with at least ONE top 3 player in every position, I'll be really happy by the end of the year.

GAZ niggle has me way off him..
reckon we'll be lucky to see 15 games from him. hope i'm wrong. I love his bald brilliance!
Titch, Zerrett or one of the Crows boys would be a safer pick.

 

[vanders]

Todays version

 

[Flandersss]

My worry is Richo doesn't have the gonads to dump Gilbert and Weller. I think that's the only way Coff and Clark get a game. I'm praying he does.

On [device_name] using BigFooty.com mobile app

Definite wait & see for me with Coff & Clark.

 

[Seluro]

Alright gang, version counter has gone out the window but I feel like I am getting closer...

This leaves me with about 110k to address my admittedly light rookies when we have a little more info. Alternatively, I could mend my impending ruck trainwreck with some tweaking.

Really not sure which two of Venables, Rioli and Ryan will get the gig but again, will wait and see. I am not expecting much out of any of them but what else is out there!

Let me have it

 

[hardballgets]

13k on the bench, its done.

what ya gonna spend the 3k ok?

 

[Flandersss]

Pfft st.kilda are terrible, another year of disappointment comming up for you.soz campaigner

Yeah don’t think Richo is the one to take us to the next step.

All good, Hawks won’t do anything either. Burton on the other hand OMGawddd

 

[MUFASA12]

182K in the bank, let me know what you lads/lasses think!

 

[PoopingHindi]

View attachment 464979

182K in the bank, let me know what you lads/lasses think!

looks solid.
O'Mera and Armitage at M5/6 is a risk but i guess you already know that.

i'd downgrade Rayner to a standard priced rookie and use whatever cash you've got left to turn Christensen into a proper forward.

 

[MUFASA12]

looks solid.
O'Mera and Armitage at M5/6 is a risk but i guess you already know that.

i'd downgrade Rayner to a standard priced rookie and use whatever cash you've got left to turn Christensen into a proper forward.

think i'm gonna wait till brissy plays sydney on saturday to see how rayner and Christensen perform, even though its preseason, playing sydney would be a pretty decent simulation going into the season proper. as for armo if he has a stinker next week i'll swap him for a rookie and take the cash.