2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[WaynesWorld19]

Todays version

View attachment 464944

IIRC Howe is still injured ? .....good side, well balanced ....how's rnd 14 looking

To get the max value from Sicily, you'll need a DEF / FWD Rookie

 

[Huttabito]

IIRC Howe is still injured ? .....good side, well balanced ....how's rnd 14 looking

To get the max value from Sicily, you'll need a DEF / FWD Rookie

Howe playing in the VFL practice match this weekend instead of JLT1.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Howe playing in the VFL practice match this weekend instead of JLT1.

Thanks .....but a restricted PS

 

[vanders]

IIRC Howe is still injured ? .....good side, well balanced ....how's rnd 14 looking

To get the max value from Sicily, you'll need a DEF / FWD Rookie

Who is the most likely DEF/FWD rookie to get a game? Keefe?

Howe will probably get switched back to Hanley or Savage.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Who is the most likely DEF/FWD rookie to get a game? Keefe?

Howe will probably get switched back to Hanley or Savage.

Yes probably .....i've got Nathan Murphy currently, with no real hopes he'll play .....maybe keep an eye on Harry Dear, longshot

 

[Total_90's]

Fire away with the feedback ladies and gents.

 

[Flandersss]

Fire away with the feedback ladies and gents.

View attachment 465003 View attachment 465005

Need a Burton type at D4 IMO even a Brayshaw type, f all def rookies

 

[Seymour Skinner]

IIRC Howe is still injured ? .....good side, well balanced ....how's rnd 14 looking

To get the max value from Sicily, you'll need a DEF / FWD Rookie

There's probably a fair few issues in your team if you require Sicily's DPP from the get go.
It's a nice bonus, and handy later in the year when you have an almost complete squad and when making trades, but it's hardly a necessity from round 1.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Was carrying an injury during the first 7 games of last year. Missed 10 rounds, came back fully recovered and averaged 93 from round 17-23. 95 if you include finals.
Turns 24 this year so still has loads of improvement in him. I reckon he'll average 90+ for sure if he plays 20+ games.
Scored 91 in JLT, even though he had 5 clangers, which is a bit high for him. I think he'll be a great POD.

I really wanna pick Vlas, partly because then I can call my team FromFirstToVlastuin, continuing my Richmond players themed names, and a constant reminder that I am now trash at SC and will never rank well ever again.
I also think he'll be a solid scorer this year

 

[WaynesWorld19]

There's probably a fair few issues in your team if you require Sicily's DPP from the get go.
It's a nice bonus, and handy later in the year when you have an almost complete squad and when making trades, but it's hardly a necessity from round 1.

Mmmm ......you must have better & more reliable DEF / FWD Rookies than the rest of us .....me, i'm counting upon the "potential" need to cover a non playing rookie Back or Fwd

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I really wanna pick Vlas, partly because then I can call my team FromFirstToVlastuin, continuing my Richmond players themed names, and a constant reminder that I am now trash at SC and will never rank well ever again.
I also think he'll be a solid scorer this year

That's because you don't value DPP ...

 

[markm106]

After changing countless times again. I've come to this team, and it's probably 95% what my Round 1 team will look like.
Unsure on Marchbank though atm. If by Round 1 I don't feel confident with him, then i'll probably downgrade him to a rookie, then EITHER upgrade Bundy -> Heeney, OR if I don't feel Lycett is up to it, Lycett ->Kreuzer/Ryder/Goldstein.
If I do Bundy -> Heeney, it means i'll have 5 keeper forwards, which means I don't have to worry about FWD rookies, as I can count the forward rookies that might play RD 1 on one hand.
Midfield is Locked.

View attachment 464897

Like it. Mids ruck and forward very close to mine to. The Lycett pick opens up some options for sure.

 

[bananatigz]

If we had rookies that looked solid I reckon this would be just about viable. Laird and Hibbo Locked, Vlastuin I think will average around 95 and importantly will pretty much score 90-100 each week.
Midfield is bananas, a lot of the big money needed to generate a good midfield is already there, so as long as you could get decent money production from your rookies upgrading the rest of your team should be fairly simply.
Gawn given. Only other ruck I really like is Kreuzer but I don’t know if I can spend 600k on him, did look good last night though.
Happy with that forward 4, reckon they will all be up there come the end of the year.

Rookies would be the problem, you will fill it round 1 but long term they don’t look like making a whole lot of money outside the mids. Inevitably you will end up dropping a mid for a few midpricers, but it’s a nice concept.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

View attachment 465026 View attachment 465025
If we had rookies that looked solid I reckon this would be just about viable. Laird and Hibbo Locked, Vlastuin I think will average around 95 and importantly will pretty much score 90-100 each week.
Midfield is bananas, a lot of the big money needed to generate a good midfield is already there, so as long as you could get decent money production from your rookies upgrading the rest of your team should be fairly simply.
Gawn given. Only other ruck I really like is Kreuzer but I don’t know if I can spend 600k on him, did look good last night though.
Happy with that forward 4, reckon they will all be up there come the end of the year.

Rookies would be the problem, you will fill it round 1 but long term they don’t look like making a whole lot of money outside the mids. Inevitably you will end up dropping a mid for a few midpricers, but it’s a nice concept.

Good comments .......your DEF is too thin & too reliant on 3 playing rookies ....will that happen consistently ? .....IMO you need to bolster your D4

 

[Hai_Newman]

Now, now

Its OK bruvs no need for offence...we get messy and take some cracks at each other....just how we roll

Join the league of splendid kentlemen and lol in ones face who larfs at your Bitchmond Premiership campaign.

 

[GT619]

IIRC Howe is still injured ? .....good side, well balanced ....how's rnd 14 looking

To get the max value from Sicily, you'll need a DEF / FWD Rookie

Keefe

 

[Flandersss]

Keefe

McVeigh reckons he’ll play if Lobb doesn’t get up

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I’ve only have 28k I won’t have enough to a wilson type etc

Do you always talk to yourself ?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Its OK bruvs no need for offence...we get messy and take some cracks at each other....just how we roll

Join the league of splendid kentlemen and lol in ones face who larfs at your Bitchmond Premiership campaign.

 

[GT619]

Do you always talk to yourself ?

self motivation

 

[GT619]

stuff it. i'm taking the risk
53k

 

[big_bazza]

Been like that for a day or two, ever since the page became "presented by Hi pages".

Does anyone know if theyre going to rectify this shit show? i just had a look on my supercoach site but couldnt find anyway to contact them and whinge, hopefully its like sportsbet and ill have a whinge and instead of getting a bonus bet ill get a free gold subscription.

 

[big_bazza]

Well suck my nuts and call me desmond.

 

[theprospect]

Mu current midfield. Also have Dow, Banfield and Barry on the pine. Thoughts on Ellis-Yolmen? Or would someone like LDU or Clark be a better option for around 80-100k less?

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Mu current midfield. Also have Dow, Banfield and Barry on the pine. Thoughts on Ellis-Yolmen? Or would someone like LDU or Clark be a better option for around 80-100k less?

View attachment 465065

I served Yolmen at work today and he said his knee is fully recovered.

(just wanted to say i served him)

That being said I think Armo is better value.