-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Prediction 2018 trade hypothetical thread
- Thread starter Groin guru
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Oct 3, 2003
- 26,916
- 30,913
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Soft spot for Brisbane
- Aug 31, 2014
- 16,793
- 31,301
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Collingwood Out: Moore
Collingwood in : Carlisle
St.Kilda Out : Carlisle
St. Kilda in : Hannebery
Sydney Out : Hannebery
Sydney in : Moore
Probably need a swap of few picks or so, but I think that’s fair.
Collingwood in : Carlisle
St.Kilda Out : Carlisle
St. Kilda in : Hannebery
Sydney Out : Hannebery
Sydney in : Moore
Probably need a swap of few picks or so, but I think that’s fair.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
- Oct 6, 2013
- 9,139
- 6,332
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Sixers, Exers, GWS Womens
What are you interested in? can you point towards an investigation that correctly outlines Fremantle's needs?
Pies: In Beams Out: Moore, pick 52
Sydney: In Moore Out Hanneberry
Saints: In Hanneberry, pick 22 Out pick 3
Brisbane: In Pick 3, 52 out Beams, Pick 22
Sydney: In Moore Out Hanneberry
Saints: In Hanneberry, pick 22 Out pick 3
Brisbane: In Pick 3, 52 out Beams, Pick 22
Port Adelaide In: Pick 15, Pick 10
Hawthorn In: WIngard Out: Roughead,Pick 15
North Melbourne: In Roughead, Polec Out: Pick 10
Hawthorn In: WIngard Out: Roughead,Pick 15
North Melbourne: In Roughead, Polec Out: Pick 10
- Jul 9, 2013
- 11,499
- 14,107
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
St Kilda may as well fold if that's what they are considering doing. No wonder the struggling clubs are voicing concerns about free agency creating a void between the strong clubs and the battling clubs.
- Jul 9, 2013
- 11,499
- 14,107
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Regardless, free agency has opened up the avenues for players to freely move between clubs, and trading has turned into the battling clubs really struggling to attract elite talent, all the while watching it walk out the door.
- Jul 9, 2013
- 11,499
- 14,107
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
What on earth are you on about ?? That has absolutely nothing to do with my post. Been to a home game of St Kilda at Etihad or The Suns at Metricon recently ?? Maybe you want to go look into the increase in membership numbers for the big clubs and compare that with the battling clubs.
Or in stkildas case pushed out the door so they can get free agency compensation picks - see Goddard, Dalsanto etc.
You cant be a rabble and expect to pick up free agents.
If Dusty gets paid $1 million at tigers, hes not walking in to a basketcase for $1.05milliion.
Saints traded well for Carlisle.
I dont think Hanneberry is worth pick 3 at all....but he is worth more than their next pick fourth round i think, and they have opted not to shop their own players in the past. I.e cant see them trading billings or Gresham to get the required pick for Hanneberry.
So they need to split pick 3.
Another option could be 3 & 57 for Hanneberry and 13.
Then swans get a pick prior to Academy selection blakey and pick up 2 guns early in the draft.
Seems you might be alone with this thought? ......on "Talking Footy" your urgent needs were outlined as Key Forwards
Also this below, from channel 7 ADEL
While it won’t happen next year, there is always a chance for Hogan to come back and as soon as that happens you have Hogan and Cox as a lethal duo up forward. Big if but Taberner is more than serviceable in the mean time until we find out if that will happen. I’m not saying Taberner is good, but he use to be at Will Schofield early years bad, where it was just like “what the hell are you doing in our team”. Absolute goose of a footy brain but the athletic ability allowed them to stay in a rebuilding team. Glimpses of 2017 and more consistently this year has shown Taberner has matured enough to be serviceable.
Really not many teams having a very good 1-2 key forward combo, Dockers can easily grow enough to be in the top half of the league. Key forwards isn’t their need I don’t think. Sure they could use a really really good full forward, but so could a lot of teams. I actually predicted dockers to make the top 8 this year (mainly due to home ground advantage, which seemed to take effect for most of the year). Injuries really ruined them this year, as well as Ross the Boss.
Overpaying to the shithouse to get McGovern is not the solution when you can; 1)wait for Hogan, 2) wait until McGovern is out of contract and try and convince him with what you’ve done with your rebuild, while also seeing if he really reaches his potential 3) see if any other key forwards come up, maybe Lobb.
But please Dockers, give up a lot to get him. Go back to your shit trading habits from the 2000’s
What do you think they are worth?
WaynesWorld19
Post-Human
There's been a bit of talk in the last 2 weeks, about perhaps trading Hogan? .....media trash talk?While it won’t happen next year, there is always a chance for Hogan to come back and as soon as that happens you have Hogan and Cox as a lethal duo up forward. Big if but Taberner is more than serviceable in the mean time until we find out if that will happen. I’m not saying Taberner is good, but he use to be at Will Schofield early years bad, where it was just like “what the hell are you doing in our team”. Absolute goose of a footy brain but the athletic ability allowed them to stay in a rebuilding team. Glimpses of 2017 and more consistently this year has shown Taberner has matured enough to be serviceable.
Really not many teams having a very good 1-2 key forward combo, Dockers can easily grow enough to be in the top half of the league. Key forwards isn’t their need I don’t think. Sure they could use a really really good full forward, but so could a lot of teams. I actually predicted dockers to make the top 8 this year (mainly due to home ground advantage, which seemed to take effect for most of the year). Injuries really ruined them this year, as well as Ross the Boss.
Overpaying to the shithouse to get McGovern is not the solution when you can; 1)wait for Hogan, 2) wait until McGovern is out of contract and try and convince him with what you’ve done with your rebuild, while also seeing if he really reaches his potential 3) see if any other key forwards come up, maybe Lobb.
But please Dockers, give up a lot to get him. Go back to your shit trading habits from the 2000’s
But i agree, Hogan would be a great get for you ....However McGovern is severely underestimated, and i'm not trying to push a trade ...quite the opposite in fact
Bloke who is very quick, can play back & forward ....and is a contested beast
He's only playing 3rd tall because of Jenkins and Walker .....the sole time he was the target FF, he kicked 5
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
I’d suspect it’s a bit of trash, but like Pavlich was for the dockers, there will always be a bit of chatter on him going home.
Yeah I hear you. Just with all the talk about how much he will cost, I think it’s just too much for a rebuilding team to offer. If it was the Eagles with no injuries I’d say that’s a good deal, but too much risk for a rebuilding team.
WaynesWorld19
Post-Human
IMHO it wouldn't be McGovern alone ......i suspect it maybe #13 & McGovern for your first pick .......so a slide of 7 spots for McGovern ??
I’m an Eagles fan so I hope it’s 4 first rounders in the next 6 years plus Cerra and Neale hahaha.
That’s the best deal I have seen for the dockers. If anything I think that’s a bit rough on the crows. Bit of change to go back crows way and I reckon that’s a good deal. If that’s the sort of deal that’s been put on the table, then yes Dockers have to consider that and maybe take it. The talk of two first rounders is laughable though.
WaynesWorld19
Post-Human
WTF ....who suggested that ? .....IMO #8-10 alone for McGovern But what i was suggesting was a good deal ....and we're desperate for an early pick
But what i was suggesting was a good deal ....and we're desperate for an early pick
Hahaha I seen a couple (or it could’ve just been the same person and I just didn’t take notice of the name) posts saying that’s he only way McGovern won’t be a crow.
Yeah I like your deal. One of the best deals I’ve seen on big footy. Could/most likely will be beneficial to both sides.
- Jun 2, 2015
- 646
- 1,306
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
If you think that is fair how about grundy for hickey straight swap. Maybe a third round swap your way to even it out? Wow just wow