List Mgmt. 2019 Trade Thread

[plugger66]

Ok. you are obviously so in the know, well informed and connected that I will leave this debate alone. You've got your opinion and I've got mine

Well jack did live with me. And lynch said it on radio

 

[bird_man]

Yeh Steven so sore with op could only manage 9 games in three yrs!! Perfect opportunity for Lyin to develop great young talent in awesome side but oh no let's play Eddie etc. the coach would not play the kids and certainly didn't develop them but you keep your opinion. Boring

You realise it's spelt Lyon yeah?

 

[plugger66]

You realise it's spelt Lyon yeah?

It’s just lack of respect to our second best coach the club has had

 

[bird_man]

In 2010
McQualter played 25 games.
Brett Peake played 23
Geary Played 19
Baker played 15
Eddy played 10
Armitage 9
RaphClarke played 8
Steven played 8.
Nick Heyne played 3
Miles played 2.

In 2011
Armitage 22.
Steven played 21.
Peake played 19.
Raph Clark played 17
Dean Polo played 15
Baker played 10.
Geary 8
Lynch/SIppos/Mcqualter 5
Cripps 4
Smith 3
Ledger 2
Winmar 2
Will Johnson 1
Archer 1

In 2012 ( Watters )
Armitage 21
Steven 21
Geary 20
Saad 16
Milera 15
Cripps 12
Siposs 11
Wilkes 10
Newnes 7
Polo 6
Dunell 5
Ledger 4
Raph Cloake 3
Seb Ross 1
Peake 1

Lyon had clearly moved Armitage and Steven into the midfield by 2011.
What was kind of strange was selecting Eddy so much in 2010 , then not playing him at all in 2011.

Didn't we delist Eddy after 2010?

 

[crinkoes]

Didn't we delist Eddy after 2010?

Correct. Re-rookied him but he never played again. Still leaves me scratching my head all these years later considering he was picked for both grand finals, with a broken hand mind you, as a 22 year old and then deemed not good enough to be on the list. So he was best 22 in a grand final side yet not worthy of a list spot anymore.

 

[Sir Skid]

I notice Acres has been targeted again!

Yes, in the first half he made some terrible clangers but so did many others.

22 disposals & the only other player from both teams that played less game time was the injured White. Acres still third for disposals for us. He can find the footy.

Also 24 pressure acts which was the highest recorded on the ground suggest he gave a ****.

All hail GOAT.

Play him in the middle and watch him shine

 

[wayneolsen]

It’s just lack of respect to our second best coach the club has had

Well you got that right - I have a total lack of respect for Lyin
And when did you live with Steven? Suppose you could name his favourite food for us as well.

 

[plugger66]

Well you got that right - I have a total lack of respect for Lyin
And when did you live with Steven? Suppose you could name his favourite food for us as well.

I never lived with jack.

 

[wayneolsen]

I never lived with jack.

Oh I see. Jack lived with you

 

[plugger66]

Oh I see. Jack lived with you

Exactly

 

[wayneolsen]

Exactly

Ok I'll take the bait. When did jack live with you

 

[plugger66]

Ok I'll take the bait. When did jack live with you

A while back. That’s the end of it now. You choose to believe or think I’m lying. Couldn’t care either way. Just know he had bad op

 

[wayneolsen]

A while back. That’s the end of it now. You choose to believe or think I’m lying. Couldn’t care either way. Just know he had bad op

What a beauty you are. So important that you decide when a debates ending!
yes he had op. Must have been when living with you but you're quite vague bout that claim

 

[plugger66]

What a beauty you are. So important that you decide when a debates ending!
yes he had op. Must have been when living with you but you're quite vague bout that claim

Ok

 

[Xxxx66]

What a beauty you are. So important that you decide when a debates ending!
yes he had op. Must have been when living with you but you're quite vague bout that claim

You are on the wrong side of this debate wayne. It's a true story

 

[Sir Skid]

You are on the wrong side of this debate wayne. It's a true story

Yep.
Pluggs does have credibility that some underestimate.

 

[toottoot]

Play him in the middle and watch him shine

Don't know if its just me but I get the feeling from what I've seen in the small amount if time when Blake has played in the middle and not rucking. That he could be our version of Patty Cripps.
A big bodied midfielder that's near impossible to tackle when in full flight

 

[wayneolsen]

You are on the wrong side of this debate wayne. It's a true story

What is the right side
A true story about what
Plugger made his point. I made mine. Maybe he has underestimated my knowledge of said two players and coach

 

[Sir Skid]

Don't know if its just me but I get the feeling from what I've seen in the small amount if time when Blake has played in the middle and not rucking. That he could be our version of Patty Cripps.
A big bodied midfielder that's near impossible to tackle when in full flight

Correct. And almost every time he gets it he does something good with it. We've been crying out for mids yet don't give the kid more of a go in the middle. Nuts imo.

 

[Diehard Saint]

Correct. And almost every time he gets it he does something good with it. We've been crying out for mids yet don't give the kid more of a go in the middle. Nuts imo.

The uses of and best position for Acres has become the most hotly debated topic since Hickey vs Longer.

 

[VDS66]

Correct. And almost every time he gets it he does something good with it. We've been crying out for mids yet don't give the kid more of a go in the middle. Nuts imo.

That's the problem though...

Great in full flight.

It's in close that he's too slow IMO.

I doubt has what it takes to be like Cripps or he would have shown it by now ahead of Dunstan.

I just don't think he has the footy smarts in that respect.

 

[Sir Skid]

That's the problem though...

Great in full flight.

It's in close that he's too slow IMO.

I doubt has what it takes to be like Cripps or he would have shown it by now ahead of Dunstan.

I just don't think he has the footy smarts in that respect.

The space cadet moments are reducing.
To be fair, if Acres has as much time in the middle as Dunstan I reckon he'd be further advanced.

 

[Diehard Saint]

The space cadet moments are reducing.
To be fair, if Acres has as much time in the middle as Dunstan I reckon he'd be further advanced.

Agree. Should be given a lot more time there.

 

[VDS66]

The space cadet moments are reducing.
To be fair, if Acres has as much time in the middle as Dunstan I reckon he'd be further advanced.

Quite possible.

What doesn't add up for me is that even with new assistants, of which one would be welcomed as head coach, no one has said he's our man. Let's give him a go.

He's either very limited or we have Charles, Wonder and blind Freddy coaching the team.

 

[Diehard Saint]

Quite possible.

He's either very limited or we have Charles, Wonder and blind Freddy coaching the team.

I’m voting for the latter.