2020 Non-Crows AFL Discussion

[Tex200]

He was pick 2 in a super draft, surely you'd expect more?

Also, almost forgot how good rankine is wow.
Reidy is our list manager

You really need to fall on your sword with Luko.

Tonight he’s had 18 @ 89%, setting them up with 5 R50 and 2 I50. 457m gained.

See him hit up Rankine with a 40m bullet?

B King 7 and 1.2
M King 7 and 1.3

Luko is actually better than I thought he’d be, thought he was just a pure KPF, but he’s actually much more.

 

[FAITH]

You really need to fall on your sword with Luko.

Tonight he’s had 18 @ 89%, setting them up with 5 R50 and 2 I50. 457m gained.

See him hit up Rankine with a 40m bullet?

B King 7 and 1.2
M King 7 and 1.3

Luko is actually better than I thought he’d be, thought he was just a pure KPF, but he’s actually much more.

I know you're a bit of a fanboy of his but if the same draft was tmrw, he wouldn't go top 10.
I had him 8.

 

[Tex200]

I know you're a bit of a fanboy of his but if the same draft was tmrw, he wouldn't go top 10.
I had him 8.

Comedy

 

[PCORF]

I think Izak Rankine is going to be a superstar If everything falls the correct way for him.

 

[hey shorty]

I know you're a bit of a fanboy of his but if the same draft was tmrw, he wouldn't go top 10.
I had him 8.

That's because you want to be different, you don't actually believe it

 

[FAITH]

That's because you want to be different, you don't actually believe it

Not at all.
It's clearly showing that he isnt worth top 2.
The Kings, Rozee, Rankine, Smith, Walsh are miles better.
Even Duursma, Butters and Chayce I would take ahead of him right now.

 

[ams4crows]

Look at that list Walsh, Luko, Rankine, M.King Rozee B.King, Smith.... The first 7 picks and we with 3 first rounders can't trade up a single spot end up with Jones and McHenry We shot ourselves in the foot big time in that draft.

 

[TryAnHit]

Was that in 2018?

What was our strategy in 2017? Trading away 2 x 1st for Gibbs when we knew these 3 were on the horizon in 12 months.

Heck we would have known in 2016.

So exhausting hearing 2 firsts for gibbs.. We got back there future 2nd which was like a 4 pick downgrade on one of the firsts...

 

[TryAnHit]

Look at that list Walsh, Luko, Rankine, M.King Rozee B.King, Smith.... The first 7 picks and we with 3 first rounders can't trade up a single spot end up with Jones and McHenry We shot ourselves in the foot big time in that draft.

Smith was the sook who refused to go interstate right....
We were slow to move on rozee... but he may have dudd for us... We don't even play Jones in the right spot and give him a chance

 

[jackster83]

Look at that list Walsh, Luko, Rankine, M.King Rozee B.King, Smith.... The first 7 picks and we with 3 first rounders can't trade up a single spot end up with Jones and McHenry We shot ourselves in the foot big time in that draft.

We still could have ended up with one or more of Caldwell, Hately, Duursma or Clark. Not sure why we picked two small mids who can't kick for shit.

 

[treeman]

So exhausting hearing 2 firsts for gibbs.. We got back there future 2nd which was like a 4 pick downgrade on one of the firsts...

Was still too much, but you are right.

Sent from my MI PAD 4 using Tapatalk

 

[mistylake]

I heard Izac Rankine kicked 3 goals on debut.
How did he look?

 

[Viva la Mattner]

I heard Izac Rankine kicked 3 goals on debut.
How did he look?

Pure silk

Angry we didn’t go chips in for him

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

I heard Izac Rankine kicked 3 goals on debut.
How did he look?

Bring back State of Origin football good

 

[StonesThrow]

How the hell do you trade up to get the top 3 picks? Why not do this every year?

NB I was on board to go for rozee around mid top 10. At least that would have been realistic.

 

[Tex200]

So exhausting hearing 2 firsts for gibbs.. We got back there future 2nd which was like a 4 pick downgrade on one of the firsts...

Sorry I was talking in context of what we actually had to use at the start of that draft, not the ultimate Gibbs trade outcome.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

 

[hey shorty]

Pure silk

Angry we didn’t go chips in for him

The Sun's were never going to take anything.

Their draft strategy in the last 2 years has been clear.

 

[1970crow]

Luko, Rankine and Rozee....oh no no no, we can’t sell the farm. Ha ha.

We tracked these 3 from U15. We had 3 years to position ourselves just to get at least one of them.

Nope, nothing.

I really don't think Suns we're ever going to sell 2 or 3. They got the bonus pick so they could draft the pair of players which makes sense given their retention issues. Could have got Rozee, but Gallagher was talking our 2 firsts plus another around the 10 mark. Seemed expensive to me. Rozee has oodles of class, but I reckon Jones' career output won't be far off his mark.

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

Karen Cornes at it again having a go at Fyfe having a surf during the week even though his team won this week.

 

[hey shorty]

Karen Cornes at it again having a go at Fyfe having a surf during the week even though his team won this week.

How boring must his life be, he doesn't seem to think players can do anything during the season

 

[mattymac]

Luko, Rankine and Rozee....oh no no no, we can’t sell the farm. Ha ha.

We tracked these 3 from U15. We had 3 years to position ourselves just to get at least one of them.

Nope, nothing.

Planning ahead isn't our strong suit

In fact I'm not sure we even have a strong suit

 

[BACCS]

We still could have ended up with one or more of Caldwell, Hately, Duursma or Clark. Not sure why we picked two small mids who can't kick for sh*t.

Chayce may not be racking up big numbers yet but I wouldn’t be questioning his kicking when he does get it. Reliable shot for goal too. Someone like Butters wasn’t doing much more than Chayce last season but he got more games under his belt, when Jones hits the 20+ games more consistent full game performances will come.

 

[hey shorty]

We still could have ended up with one or more of Caldwell, Hately, Duursma or Clark. Not sure why we picked two small mids who can't kick for sh*t.

Can't kick ?? Yeah that's not quite right.

Also, I'm quite happy with what we ended up with..... Playing in our side is near on impossible for a kid at the moment.

Hately isn't a need and Clark is another HBF, we don't need those.

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Can't kick ?? Yeah that's not quite right.

Also, I'm quite happy with what we ended up with..... Playing in our side is near on impossible for a kid at the moment.

Hately isn't a need and Clark is another HBF, we don't need those.

?? Hately walks into our midfield